Location: East Rochester
Top Restaurants in East Rochester
New York, United States Food Guide: 10 Pizza food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in East Rochester
Reviews on Pizza food in East Rochester, New York, United States. Fred Ricci (D) First elected 2011
Things to do in East Rochester
10. All Star Pizza
Reviewed By jawlmt
We order our pizza from All Star most of the time. We try other places in the area, one's with big reputations, but we always return to All Star. Their pizza is always consistently good, their prices are very reasonable and the delivery is quick. Why go anywhere else?
9. Pontillo's Pizzeria
Reviewed By Jason C
The pizza had a nice sauce and cheese, but the crust was a touch on the thick side and a little doughy. Toppings were all good, and the wings we had were just alright. We'd try it again, but would likely look elsewhere first.
8. Pontillo's Pizza & Pasta
Reviewed By Lovin_Life99
2.25 for a good size slice that is re-heated in their awesome oven. This creates a perfect layer of crisp, absolute perfection! Favorite Pepperoni pizza because the sauce is to die for. The Buffalo Chicken is my favorite buffalo chicken pizza too! The other topping I love is sausage. Overall slice quality A++ If your favorite pizza is buffalo chicken or Pepperoni pontillos is a must
7. Compane....A Brick Oven Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 112 reviews
Been open for about a year now. Excellent. Would like to write a review.
Reviewed By Larry W
We had talked about visiting this place on Main Street in Fairport numerous times, but this was our first actual visit for dinner, and we were fairly impressed. It's a pretty place inside, with only 20 tables, but very intimately arranged and decorated. Our waiter walked us through the long list of entrees and specials, many of which were created with a lot of imagination. I had the salad special, which was greens with figs and goat cheese, plus other compatible veggies and more. It was very good. I also had another appetizer as my main course; the lightly-fried calamari, which was also very nicely done and served with a pair of dipping sauces. It was a nice meal, and dinner for the three of us (with no alcohol or desserts) came to $77, which was quite reasonable. We will return in the future. BTW, we had reservations (for 5:15 PM), which is probably a good idea as they did get crowded.
6. Guida's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 41 reviews
Reviewed By Angela W
We order from here quite a bit, there aren't very many choices in Penfield; and the food is generally pretty good. We have had a few small issues in the past, that I felt were not handled with compassion and care for the customer but they were fairly small issues; so we continued to order. Today was the straw that broke the camels back. I called in our order, a calzone at 11:15am. I did call about 10 minutes later to order a turkey wrap. I was told it would be an hour for delivery. Although that's a long time, I called in enough time where that shouldn't be a problem. At 12:47 when our food hadn't arrived, I called Guida's. I was told that it was already delivered to our receptionist. It hadn't been. The employee that answered the phone continued to argue with me and told me that it had been delivered and her driver had already come back. I finally stated that the order may have been delivered, but it was not to the correct location. Although she continued to argue with me, she offered nastily to remake the order and bring it out to us. (now 2 hours after our original order) After barely an apology I was told it would take 20 minutes + delivery time. While we were waiting for our order, a receptionist from another office in the building came up; quite angry with our food. Apparently the delivery driver went to the wrong office suite (which had been confirmed at the original time of order twice) banged on the Dr.s office door disturbing him while he was with a patient. The driver argued with the Dr. and said someone from that office ordered. The Dr. paid for the 1/2 half of the order that was cash and sent the driver away to continue with his patient. When the Drs. Secretary returned from lunch, she brought the order in asking if it was ours; and relaying the story. I called back to Guidas to let them know what happened and asked to speak to a manager. They did not put me through to a manager... I asked what could be done for us, due to the hassle we had to go though... I was told, nothing.We will not be ordering from Guidas again. I will pass along my experience with EVERYONE I know, as well as other offices in the area. Mistakes happen, nobody is perfect. Had this been handled any differently, this review would not have been written, nor my experience shared. An apology, "lets get that remade and delivered to you ASAP free of charge" would have gotten a positive review for handling the situation so well.
5. Pizzeria Favo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 60 reviews
Reviewed By DianneK116
We all had the pizza. We had classic cheese,salad,pepperoni,And white pizza. Everyone loved it.One drawback they have a soda machine with none of the flavors tasted good. Private soda company .You get the pizza right away because it is really thin.
4. TK's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
When you're in the mood for a slice of pizza that will overtake your mouth with the robust flavors of fresh tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and hints of garlic and Italian spices, visit the finest pizza place in Fairport, NY. TK's Pizzeria is the place to go
Reviewed By Jerold J
T K's has been our favorite for many years. We get pizza from all the other places, but keep coming back to T K's because we like it the best.Although there is seating, the interior isn't much. I'll stop in for lunch if by myself but otherwise we use them for takeout.I've read a couple of comments about the owner being rude. He is matter-of-fact, and maybe a bit blunt, but I've never considered him rude. He is hard working and extremely fair. One time I came in at the tail end of lunch service (they close immediately after until evening) and he was done serving. He had a couple of slices left but just gave them to me because they'd been sitting for a bit. Anyway, great spot, give them a try.
3. Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
SALVATORE'S OLD FASHIONED PIZZERIA, ROCHESTER'S FAVORITE PIZZERIA SINCE 1978! Dine-in, take-out and delivery on all our famous full menu items. Pizza Pubs & Saloons. Pizza, Slices & Calzones, Specialty Pizzas, Italian Subs & Wraps, Appetizers, Wings & Chi
Reviewed By B_in_Penfield
Ordered a sheet pizza recently. Always good, nice crust, lots of cheese. My order was ready sooner than I expected, which was perfect. I also ordered a gluten free pizza - which was delicious. It came with it's own pizza cutting roller. Nice touch. Service was friendly and they have lots of different coupons to save a few dollars.
2. Ferrari Pizza Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 8 reviews
Reviewed By Tinahawaii
I have eaten at this location 3 times so far and have been very happy with the food and service. I have tried their pizza, wings, wedge salad and fries. All were very good! My kids love seeing the Ferrari in the restaurant. It's a fun place.
Where to eat Steakhouse food in East Rochester: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Perlo's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 213 reviews
Perlo's offers a warm, comfortable atmosphere with a true feeling of being part of the family. Youâll find great food and a full bar in our upscale yet casual atmosphere. Wonderful home cooked meals including seafood, steaks, chops, Italian specialties an
Reviewed By Clarkvara
Love the Chicken Riggies at Perlo's, good size portions means Chicken Riggies for breakfast the next day. Place is usually pretty packed on Fridays and Saturdays so call ahead for a reservation. Service is good. If there's a down side it's their extremely small and limited wine list.
Most Popular Italian food in East Rochester, New York, United States
