Location: Pittsford
Top Restaurants in Pittsford
Most Popular Seafood food in Pittsford, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Seafood food in Pittsford, New York, United States. William A. Smith, Jr. (R) elected 2013
Things to do in Pittsford
1. Black & Blue Steak & Crab
Overall Ratings
4 based on 492 reviews
The black & blue experience centers around Inventive Design, Inspired Cuisine, and a complete focus on Gracious Hospitality.
Reviewed By chopin1981
I have been going to BB for the past 16 years. I have praised this restaurant in my past reviews. Today was my first big disappointment.We had a reservation for a birthday dinner. When we were seated the server asked if we were celebrating anything special and I have indicated it was my birthday. She wished me happy birthday and proceeded with the order.I requested an oyster martini which the restaurant has offered for years. The server seemed confused, and I assured her that BB makes these as I had them before.The serverâs assistant spilled our bread over the table, and then spilled water on my not-so-cheap purse and the chair while pouring it into our glasses. He didnât notice anything.Towards the end of our meal a large party arrived and was seated next to our booth. Our server lost interest in us all together. I wasnât offered a refill on my soda even though the glass was empty.Then, we received the bill but no champagne or birthday cake (it was customary of BB to offer these to us in the past years for birthdays and anniversaries). So, I asked the server if there was a reason why the table next to us celebrated a birthday with a cake while we werenât offered any. She claimed she was new and she wasnât aware. Then I reminded her that I told her personally what the occasion was when she asked us at the beginning of the evening. She changed her story into saying it was her mistake. We waited 15 minutes for the cake which was pathetic.Additionally, at the beginning of the evening I asked the server to put the points for the dinner on my VIP card, and since I didnât have it with me I would give her my name towards the end of the dinner. She didnât listen and put the points on my husbandâs card. I told her I asked specifically to put the point in my card as my husband doesnât use his and they would be lost. She informed us this would not be possible. So, I asked for the manager. She was unhappy about it.The manager fixed the points issue, but the evening was a big disappointment. Iâm giving BB 3 stars as my food was good. Otherwise, it would be one star.Thank you for reaching out regarding your disappointing experience. We would like to apologize for your disappointing birthday dinner. If you are open to sharing more with us, please consider emailing [email protected]. We would like the opportunity to make up for our mistakes!
Best Steakhouse food near Pittsford, New York, United States
2. The Northside Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 146 reviews
Reviewed By Alisonvo
A large group of family attended a holiday Brunch at Northside and it was horrible. The dining room was WAY too crowded, to the point that it was difficult to even get to the buffet. We had to move tables for a lady with a walker to get through. The buffet had run out of many items by the time we got there (not even at the end of the seating times), and staff were distracted and surly when we asked if there would be more food. (The answer was no.) The food that was left was not tasty and not good. We asked for a refund and got yelled at--needless to say, there was no refund. We will never go back.
3. Lobster Trap
Overall Ratings
4 based on 9 reviews
Reviewed By WineMeister
Now just to clarify - this is NOT a restaurant, just a great place to purchase seafood. They seem to have everything. We cam here to get clams, they have about eight different varieties (maybe more) and we purchased about five dozen clams. They had Maine and Brazilian lobster tails, scallops, all sorts of crab legs and all sizes of scallops. This place is amazing and the staff is quite knowledgeable and very helpful.Stop in here for your next clam bake, lobster or crab boil, etc. You will NOT be disappointed. Keep in mind, I am pretty sure they close at 6pm so get there early!
