Top Restaurants in Wallkill
Most Popular Pizza food in Wallkill, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Wallkill, New York, United States including Tosco's Pizzeria, Franco's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant, Guiseppe's of Walden, Lillo's Pizza, Giuseppe's Pizzeria Restaurant, Carmela's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, Pasquale's Restaurant & Pizza, John Fazio Farm Market & BBQ, Cosimo's On Union, Cascarino's
Things to do in Wallkill
10. Cascarino's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 41 reviews
Wonderful Italian Restaurant in the Hamlet of Montgomery New York
Reviewed By William R
I am not sure who the person behind the register was, but upon entering the restaurant for our first time, the "gentleman" basically barked that the dining area is "in the back." The front of the shop has a few tables and chairs for the pizza, etc. and the back is where the more proper restaurant is.The services was surprisingly good. Though very young (maybe high-schoolers?), the waitstaff were very friendly and efficient. The meals we had were pretty good, with large portions (i.e. doggy bag). We ended the evening with an order of zeppoles, a HUGE plate loaded with hot, sugared, delicious fried dough. Once dinner was done and we went up front to pay, the same "gentleman" was cursing about the phones not working, picking up a ringing phone and then slamming it down. If it had not been for the great waitstaff, I would have rated Cascarino's lower due to the inappropriate behavior/ attitude of who the customers have to deal with.
9. Cosimo's On Union
Overall Ratings
4 based on 386 reviews
Reviewed By 459dawnl
What a nice surprise - a restaurant that totally lived up to its reviews. Server was efficient and friendly, food was delicious - totally reccommend the spicy chicken pasta. Only downside was the noise level...definitely NOT the place for a quiet romantic dinner.
8. John Fazio Farm Market & BBQ
Overall Ratings
5 based on 26 reviews
Reviewed By NUTN2000
Driving up to this spot,do not be taken off by the plain exterior. BBQ was VG. I had the BBQ sampler. Ribs & smoked wings were a 5,cooked perfectly.Brisket and pulled pork were a 3.5 to 4. Brisket was very lean and not quite the style I prefer, the gravy was an odd choice for me....but not bad. Pulled pork w/ slaw was also good. Corn bread was vg but cold...would have been better warm.The bbq sauce & vinegar based were vg.A nice line of beer taps. Nice little meat market and selection of frozen, natural meats.Owner was pleasant and the place was active. Service was good.If you are in the New Paltz area, recommended. We will be back again.
7. Pasquale's Restaurant & Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By joevala
My wife and I stopped for dinner and enjoyed 2 excellent meals. I opted for the Cavatelli Ala vodka and my wife decided on the Chicken marsala. We both had a small salad with the meals. The food was cooked to perfection, tasted good and the waitress Amber was courteous and top notch. We enjoyed the evening and will visit Pasquale's again.
6. Carmela's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 51 reviews
Reviewed By mlown
I have frequented Carmela's on many occasions. It specializes in Italian cuisine but the menu is varied with veal, chicken, steak and fish entrees. I have never had a bad meal there. The food is well-seasoned and delicious. The atmosphere is warm and comforting. The owners and the wait staff keep the establishment clean and attractive. For the quantity, quality and price of its food, you just can't beat it. Also the owners and staff are very accommodating and make it a point to make sure you are satisfied with your meal....I highly recommend this restaurant.
5. Giuseppe's Pizzeria Restaurant
Reviewed By Fdnybabygirl
We've eaten here numerous times and always have a great meal. The wings and pizza are always piping hot and delicious, and their pepperoni pizza roll-ups are phenomenal! Not to mention, the Italian Combo Sub is unforgettable. Friendly staff and cozy little joint.
4. Lillo's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By IRun2Eat
I grew up eating pizza from here nearly every Friday night. The pizza is great and the owners are very friendly. I moved away 10 years ago and recently visited with my family. The pizza we got was slightly burned and even my children wouldn't eat it. This was my first bad experience at this pizza shop.
3. Guiseppe's of Walden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By David G
They have great pizza plus they deliver to us for lunch. I really have only had the pizza which has been consistently great each time I have had it. Others at work love their wraps and lunch specials. Lunch specials are reasonably priced. The management is pleasant and aim to please. Try it you will like it......
2. Franco's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 25 reviews
Reviewed By El B
I have had pizza with husband there we both liked it. It is in the thruway shopping as ya drive in on right.
1. Tosco's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By PatandKen W
When we moved here 13 yrs. ago we started trying all the restaurants around looking for a good pizza. Well, Tosco has the best pizza by far!!!! Tastes like a pizza should taste. And their other specials are perfect. Huge portions. One of my favorites is linguine and white clam sauce.
