Location: New Windsor
Top Restaurants in New Windsor
Top Things to do in New Windsor
Most Popular Pizza food in New Windsor, New York, United States
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in New Windsor. New Windsor is a town in Orange County, New York, United States. The Town of New Windsor is in the eastern part of the county, bordering the Town of Newburgh and the City of Newburgh. The population was estimated at 25,244 in 2010 by the US Census.
Things to do in New Windsor
10. Cosimo's Pizza
Reviewed By 72camille
Amazing! Amazing! Amazing! This restaurant was recommended by 3 different people all within a span of as afternoon. I think it's a disservice to have pizza as a part of their name because their menu is so much more. My co-worker got a snapper dish with brussel sprouts & mashed potatoes and raved about her dinner. I got the restaurants version of carbonara & fell in love. Janine was our server and we couldn't have asked for anyone better. She was attentive but not intrusive. Our glasses were never less than 1/2 empty and she always magically appeared when we needed something. If I were to ever come back to the area again I'd certainly come back & I'd ask for Janine. Outstanding food & superior service.
9. Sal's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By Stacey M
Great family run place. Food is always good and made fast. We were in the mood for eggplant rollatini pizza which was not on the menu. They created an awesome pie that I might like better than ones places make on a daily basis. the fresh basil added a wonderful level of flavor! I have been eating here well over 25 years!
8. Cafe Pitti
Overall Ratings
3 based on 50 reviews
Oven Brick, Wood Burning Style Comfort And Fusion Cuisine, Paninis, Thin Crust Pizza, Always Meat Specials, Desserts, Espresso, Wine And Beer Bar, Waterfront Majestic Hudson River Views.
Reviewed By kathleeno408
We've had positive visits to Cafe Pitti in the past, but will not be returning. Service was very slow and haphazard. My husband ordered two beers and was not served what he ordered either time. He also ordered a pizza special. A single serve pizza with 2 large shrimp and a good amount of crab was $28. It was soggy and disappointing. I ordered a garden salad with green beans, corn, carrots, and granny smith apples. I'm pretty sure the veggies were frozen. It was smothered in a dressing. Pretty awful compared to the menu description. I asked for grilled shrimp on the side and was served 7 large for $4. (Interesting pricing when you consider the cost of the pizza) The shrimp were lukewarm and pale...no seasoning or anything to make them appetizing. My husband had a shrimp avacado salad as a starter. This very disappointing meal cost $72. Waste of money. Only positive was the view which is amazing. We feel really sorry for the hard time you experienced in our restaurant, sad to hear you didnât enjoy anything, your review will help us to improve our failures.Our menu is always made in small batches and from the scratch, never frozen, money we charge for our creations are reasonable price for unconventional cuisine carefully prepared in an open oak burning oven which deserves special kind of treatment and skills.Apparently we did not reach our standards serving you and for that reason just let me say so sorry.
7. ABC Pizza and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Our goal is to ensure the complete satisfaction of every customer with great food and friendly service. Customers are our number one priority and we strive to meet all of your expectations. Complete Italian dinners, pizza, calzones, pasta, appetizers, gyr
Reviewed By Wearytraveler066
We have been going to ABC Pizza for over 35 years. Food has always been good and when I do takeout, Meatball Parm hero is my favorite. ( they have the best meatballs!!)
6. Prima Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 99 reviews
Reviewed By Shortknocer
I would describe Prima as a typical, small town New York Italian eatery. We ordered for pickup and my son-in-law and I shared a meat lovers pie while the ladies both went for salads. Despite encountering a street festival right in front of the restaurant that we were not anticipating, I walked a couple of blocks and went in to find a crowded, busy place. However, our order was ready and I carried it back to our vehicle that was waiting as near as possible behind the barricades blocking off the streets. Everyone loved their food so the pick up ordeal turned out to be worth the trouble!
5. Cafe Richiesto and Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 23 reviews
Reviewed By Gloria G
Stopped for lunch on our way to storm king art center, about 10 minutes away. Huge menu ranging from Pizza, through fantastic salads, through all kinds of sandwiches and breakfast items. Homemade baked goods and ice cream.Breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Focus on Italian food and pastries.Chopped salad for $10.95 was huge and the chicken was tender.Impeccably clean. Delightful staff focused on making sure you were happy. Very casual. Worth a stop when sightseeing in the area.
Where to eat Asian food in New Windsor: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Mama Theresa's Italian Specialties
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By NYnick1
Mama Theresa's deli is amazing! It is a legit Italian deli! I've gone to numerous delis where the subs are over priced and suck on top of that, you dont see that here. Everything is fairly priced and tastes great! The Italian combo is my personal favorite. You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu!!
3. The Pizza Shop
Overall Ratings
4 based on 61 reviews
Reviewed By E1273UKdavidm
Excellent choice for dinner for family looking for great choice for local pizza . Three of our guests were from Texas and South Carolina and were looking forward to having our great New York pizza. Great choice for dinner and everyone loved there pizza. Will definitely go back and highly recommend to others..
2. Brothers Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 249 reviews
Reviewed By jello692017
This reastaurant was another pleasant surpris. When you 1st enter the place looks so small just like a normal pizzeria, but the owner showed to the back, where there are 2 larger rooms for a full service reataurant. Our waitress was a sweetheart and extermely helpful. The wine was excellent and all of our meals were delicious. Highly recommend this place. Italian owned since this is an Italian restaurant.
Most Popular American food in New Windsor, New York, United States
1. Cosimo's On Union
Overall Ratings
4 based on 386 reviews
Reviewed By 459dawnl
What a nice surprise - a restaurant that totally lived up to its reviews. Server was efficient and friendly, food was delicious - totally reccommend the spicy chicken pasta. Only downside was the noise level...definitely NOT the place for a quiet romantic dinner.
