Location: Medford
Top Restaurants in Medford
Top Things to do in Medford
- 1. Holtsville Ecology Site
- 2. The Escape Room Game Long Island
- 3. Fire Island National Seashore
- 4. Country Fair Entertainment Park
- 5. Regal Cinemas Ronkonkoma Stadium 9 Movie Theater
- 6. The Pennysaver Amphitheater
- 7. The Gateway - The Performing Arts Center of Suffolk County
- 8. Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts
- 9. Padlocked Inc
- 10. Long Island Limo Rental
Most Popular Pizza food in Medford, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Medford, New York, United States. Medford is a hamlet and census-designated place (CDP) in Suffolk County, New York, United States. The population was 24,142 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Medford
10. Anthony's Italian Restaurant
Reviewed By mexit
I wanted to take in an authentic Italian restaurant and Anthonyâs Trattoria turned out to be the perfect spot. We began with freshly shucked oysters from Rhode Island and a Caesar Salad with a housemade dressing. This was followed by Florida Key Shrimp, heads still on, cooked in a spicy sauce. Bread board came out with prosciutto, two Italian cheeses and fresh figs. Many of their pastas are made on the premises. We had Tajarin al Granchio, an egg pasta with lump crab meat and garden fresh cherry tomatoes white wine and a hint of chili topped with grated tuna roe. In fact, there is a garden on the premises. Italians have their own version of stuffed cabbage called Involtini di Verza. Fresh savoy cabbage rollups stuffed with ground beef, pork, Parmigiano and ricotta cheese slow cooked in a garden fresh tomato sauce. Next came Risotto with spicy sausage and wild mushroom ragu which was followed with pan seared filet mignon in a black pepper cream sauce. I was stuffed more than the cabbage!Two desserts were chosen: Chocolate Cake and freshly made cannoli (They even make the shells).
9. Gianna's Pizzeria
Reviewed By Kristin B
There are so many pizzeria's on LI, it's very tough to distinguish yourself as a top-rated establishment, especially given the unique tastes of every person when it comes to pizza in NY! Needless to say, pizza isn't bad, but on LI, I've personally had better. Pricing is relatively fair in comparison to surrounding establishments, and staff is ok as well. For us, most business we give is based on convenience/proximity. If you're in the area, give them a try and make your own decision!
8. Mama Bella's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Reviewed By Judilynn S
Hubby and I love to try new pizza places around the area. We tried this place and was very happy we did. The pizza was great. I had chicken bacon ranch and marsala. Both very tender and not dry. Hubby has chicken parm and grandmas. Both very flavorful. They served our pizza on real plates . how classy is that?The desserts and gelato looked wonderful. We'll be back.!
7. Pizza Corner
Reviewed By Kristin B
There are so many pizzeria's on LI, it's very tough to distinguish yourself as a top-rated establishment, especially given the unique tastes of every person when it comes to pizza in NY! Pizza isn't bad, but on LI, I've personally had better. Pricing is relatively fair in comparison to surrounding establishments, and they always run coupons in the local Val-Pak savings packet, so that is the main draw for our business.
6. Bianca Luna
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By benoitleblanc
Maybe I was not lucky and it was the first day for the waitress... She was very kind but didn't know her menu at all and couldn't answer any basic question except reading what was written in front of my eyes...The noodle were over cook and the sauce was discussing and the meat was ok...They give some little pizza slice as complimentary appetizer which was nice...The only good thing was the Tiramisu... Very good... However not listed on their menu, and even the waitress didn't mention it... I had to ask the chef who told me he had it available... Good thing I asked it did save the meal !
5. Primo Pizza & Restaurant
Reviewed By JodyDavis
Wasn't expecting to find such high quality food in the middle of a strip mall, but this place was terrific. They make their dough fresh regularly and on a couple days we visited, the owner, Andrew, was personally making every pizza by hand. We tried four different kinds of pizza during the course of our stay over multiple visits and all were delicious and packed with ingredients.Make sure to check out their daily specials during the week. Thursday, for example, you can buy two of their giant hero sandwiches and get one free. That's enough to feed at least a family of four.In addition to the owner (who has 30 years of experience in the pizza business, and it shows), all the employees we encountered were friendly and eager to help.
4. Tony's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By FrequentTripster
Great pizza that the staff takes pride in making. Excellent and friendly service. Store is pretty typical for a pizza place.
3. La Margherita Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 57 reviews
Reviewed By V5571WHerics
The pizza here is excellent and the staff is friendly and very helpful. Was there recently and saw a slice with some eggplant (which we liked) but the eggplant was not prepared as we would have liked - the gentleman behind the counter was quick to point out they could make a pie exactly as we wanted. We ordered one, as well as a few other pies, and they were all delicious! Definitely recommend!
What to do and see in Medford, United States: The Best Places and Tips
2. Cafe Gia Pizza & Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 81 reviews
Reviewed By OzzysAngel
This is my 2nd review of Gia's, the 1st written a few years ago. The reason for an updated review is my disappointment in all my visits since. Note: this is for the pizza side only. Saturday afternoon, 4pm. I was a few miles away and my daughter wanted pizza. Upon entering, the counter was pretty bare, and anything resembling pizza was burnt looking and old. It's nice to see the same miserable faces behind the counter. They don't smile or pay attention to you for longer than the few seconds it takes to take your order. They put the pizza in the oven and move on to the next person. Every. Single. Time. I have to ask them to take my food out. If I don't, it gets overcooked, crust burnt. They never give a receipt nor are there signs anywhere telling you how much anything is. Chicken bacon ranch slice? I think he called it? Old, hard chicken, cheddar cheese? And no ranch anywhere. Threw most of it out. The pepperoni pinwheel is always good. And the regular slice was ok. There were no knives or napkins in the dispensers. The garbage was full. The tables and floors were absolutely disgusting. I just stood there waiting for the young girl at the door to stop looking at us and get someone to wipe down a table. She finally looked annoyed enough and did it herself. I wish I could say that it was a one time deal, but the past few times we drove out of our way, it's just been bad. I'm disappointed. I used to love going here. What happened Gia's?
Medford Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Medford
1. Medford Pastaria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 114 reviews
Reviewed By HannahLee123
Excellent eggplant anything (parmigiana and rollatini). Nice restaurant ambiance and service for local casual dining in strip mall.
