Location: Athens
Top Restaurants in Athens
Top Things to do in Athens
Most Popular Pizza food in Athens, Pennsylvania, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Athens, Pennsylvania, United States. Athens is a borough in Bradford County, Pennsylvania, United States, located 2 miles (3 km) south of the New York state line on the Susquehanna and Chemung rivers. The population was 3,749 in 1900 and 3,796 in 1910. The population was 3,367 at the 2010 census. Athens is in a small area locally known as "The Valley", a group of four contiguous communities in Pennsylvania and New York: Waverly, New York; South Waverly, Pennsylvania; Sayre, Pennsylvania; and Athens. The Valley has a population near 30,000.
Things to do in Athens
8. Pizza Hut
Reviewed By Dana71635
Ordered food online. Ordered half chicken supreme and half cheese. Got there to pick it up and it was just a plain cheese pizza but I was charged for chicken supreme which is $4-5 more than a cheese pizza. The manager said the order looked like a chicken supreme pizza with cheese only... REALLY? How dumb! Why would I order any type of supreme with cheese only?! They had my number, they could have easily called for clarification but instead the manager acted like I was the stupid one for ordering online... NOT COOL! So much for convince. Pizza was crappy too.
7. Pudgie's Pizza Pasta & Subs
Overall Ratings
4 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By scranton38
Howie's was closer to my house, but when it burned down we had to resort to Pudgie's. That makes it sound bad, but we were just always used to the other place. Pudgie's had good pizza, salads are great, and subs aren't bad either, but I feel like it got pretty expensive. It's an "every once-in-a-while" thing so it doesn't stop us from going but a sheet pizza costing over $30 is a hard pill to swallow sometimes.
6. Coaches Pizza
Reviewed By QueenKacie
We stayed in Sayre, PA this past weekend for a family reunion. Afterbour family festivities Saturday we got back to the hotel and did not feel like going outbfor food. The desk clerk at our hotel suggested Coache's in Waverly as they delivered to where we were and she said she loved them. We ordered their double play (large cheese pizz an order of wings and 32 ounce soda). We added pepperoni and bacon to our pizza. It came within the hour (just as they had estimated) Their pizza tasted good and the wings were nice and saucy and being medium actually had a little bit of a bite! The only complaint we had was that both the pizza and the wings could have been a bit crispier. Will definitely order again next year when we are back in the area!
5. Soprano's Italian Market
Overall Ratings
4 based on 56 reviews
Reviewed By sugarrunjeep
Hope 7 days a week long hours. Good parking. Great pizza ready to go. Fabulous cookie assortment in their bakery. There is a sit-down section if you want to eat in.
Most Popular American food in Athens, Pennsylvania, United States
4. Howie's Pizza & Subs
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By 671caitlynl
The restaurant has plenty of seating, and the menu has a great variety of choices to feed even picky eaters. Choices ranged from pizzas to subs to salads, and there was also an option for a buffet. Pizza was decent, and the garlic knots were very large & tasty! Subs were made within 10 minutes, and staff was very friendly!
Where to eat Bar food in Athens: The Best Restaurants and Bars
3. Original Italian Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By JamesS2869
I can't say enough about this place and their food! I always get the fettuccine alfredo and I die everytime I get it! So good! Deff try this place out if your in town!
2. Mangialardo's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 106 reviews
Reviewed By JohnCAPWN
The service was very good. The food was reasonably priced as well. 2 in our party had Italian, I had the pork chops. Very flavorful. Weirdness Alert - I eat out 2 -3 times per week, usually pay with cc THIS IS THE ONLY PLACE that doesn't allow tip to be put on the card. Good thing I had some cash! VERY BAD BUSINESS PRACTICE!!! EVERY OTHER RESTAURANT IN THE WORLD DOES IT. WHY CAN'T YOU??
1. Parrish Family Deli
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By Lisamarie L
I was here for business recently, and some of the locals took me here for lunch. It's nothing fancy, but they have a good selection of subs and specialty pizzas that are very tasty (I got a white garlic pizza). Service was quick and friendly. Prices are very reasonable; they don't take a credit card for small orders, which was difficult as the portions were already big enough that I was hard pressed to find anything else to get to bring my order up to the threshold without buying too much food. As it was, I had to suffer through a second slice of pizza ;)
