Top Restaurants in Tuckahoe
Most Popular Italian food in Tuckahoe, New York, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Tuckahoe including Gigante Restaurant & Bar, Angelina's Ristorante, Burrata Wood Fired Pizza, Rosie's Bistro Italiano, AJ's Burgers, Il Bacio Trattoria, Mamma Assunta, Carlos Restaurant, Scalini Osteria, Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
Things to do in Tuckahoe
10. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
Overall Ratings
4 based on 183 reviews
Reviewed By Diane F
Crisp, light crust, savory/sweet sauce and exquisite, fresh cheese is a sure recipe for delicious pizza. But Frank Pepe beats the others in that it's always baked just right. We come here often and enjoy the delectable pies with mushrooms or other toppings. Go here!
9. Scalini Osteria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
Reviewed By jimnap262
Looking for s new place since Sammys Downtown closed, food was very tasty, drinks were perfect, service was great.
8. Carlos Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 121 reviews
At Carlo's Restaurant, a rustic-modern eatery serving Westchester County's most delicious and honest Italian-American fare, we cater to families and friends looking for good food and a warm, casual place to enjoy it. Each of our Northern Italian-inspired
Reviewed By Codysmom4475
Excellent for many reasons. Varied menu with both traditional Italian & interesting takes on traditional Italian. Great service in spite of an extremely busy environment weekdays & weekends. Great food, cooked to perfection. Comfortable second floor seating if the vibrant downstairs is too loud for your taste. This restaurant hits all the marks, all the time. I have never had a dish I didn't like nor an experience that wasn't fantastic. I would highly recommend Carlos without hesitation. Reservations are definitely recommended. This place does a very vibrant business most nights.
7. Mamma Assunta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 41 reviews
Reviewed By Ana C
Over the years we have dined at this restaurant and every experience is the best! Our recent visit was participating at a private birthday dinner celebration. From beginning to end (some almost 7 hours later) it was fantastic. The bar offers delicious cocktails: I had the Peach martini, the best I ever had.The ambience is reminiscent of an elegant family dining area in a large house in Italy: from the fire place, frescos and flower arrangements, to the white table cloths and elegant glasses. The variety of presented appetizers was delicious & carefully chosen: baccala (cod) salad, polenta squares with a delicious ragú, octopus salad, salume & cheeses platters and the always savory house salad. The pappardelle alla bolognesa and the seafood pasta were outstanding.The entré (couple of choices) weâre delicious & beautifully displayed: we had the elegant and flavorful small lamb chops.The wine offered included well balanced Sauvignon Blanc whites and the always outstanding Montepulciano dâAbruzzo Zaccagnini. The whole meal was accompanied by a stupendous female singer while the very efficient, professional and friendly staff attended to all the guests needs. Elio Di Rosa, owner & restauranteur, indeed runs a wonderful restaurant that evokes the Old Italy with a modern twist but always faithful to the true Italian traditions. We highly recommend this restaurant and look forward to our next visit.
6. Il Bacio Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
Reviewed By Cathrab28
We went for a quick family dinner. Always delicious! Service could have been a tad better. My water glass stayed empty way too long. Avocado salad pizza is a MUST! Super delicious. Half way through dinner though the lights were dimmed. This has happened before when Iâve been there, but didnât realize it must be done on purpose! It was very difficult to read the dessert menu, but thankfully I knew what I was having!Lots of yummy gelato and sorbet to choose from along with Italian favorites. Street parking, have quarters ready if before 7pm on a weekday.
5. AJ's Burgers
Overall Ratings
4 based on 176 reviews
AJ's is a collaboration of America's Favorite Foods served seven days a week serving breakfast, lunch and dinner. AJ makes everything in house using fresh ingredients and an orchestra of recipes. We serve pan sandwiches on our homemade bread; chicken, bro
Reviewed By Cathy D
Just had a great lunch at AJâs. Read about the place on TripAdvisor and it was every bit as delicious, friendly and fun as suggested. AJ spent time chatting about his homemade yummy food, sent over some things he just thought we should taste, and even chatted about bbq sauce with my husband, who has become an amateur rib chef this summer.Burgers were delish. Pulled pork, too. Perfectly cooked rabe. Excellent coleslaw. And spicy pickled veggies just yummy. Not one to take no for a dessert answer, AJ sent small ( thank goodness) bowls of Giffords orange sherbets and vanilla ice cream over causing us to recall the Creamsicles of our youth.Tomorrow: pizza at AJâs!
4. Rosie's Bistro Italiano
Overall Ratings
4 based on 170 reviews
Reviewed By Bill Z
The food is delicious and the restaurant is very elegant. The bar is great and the atmosphere is very nice and is perfect for a first date or romantic dinner. The menu is diverse and the dessert menu is fabulous!
3. Burrata Wood Fired Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 104 reviews
Reviewed By John D
Outstanding restaurant! Ordered to go. The girl that took my order was so friendly and amazing! She had a beautiful smile and a great personality! Ordered pizza, ravioli, and a salad! The pizza was amazing, the ravioli were delicious the sauce top notch and the salad was great too! I will definitely be returning in the very near future!
2. Angelina's Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 102 reviews
Reviewed By Mary F
Will be back soon. There are many restaurants closer to me and that I have been faithful to for years. I will definitely go the extra miles to get back there. My mouth is watering thinking about it. Oh and the prices are not so expensive. Very surprised for the quality and quantity that it was not a fortune. Skip all those fancy places and come here instead. You will not regret it!
1. Gigante Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 24 reviews
High energy vibe dining with unparalleled decor. This Italian influenced, American modern cuisine is sure to stimulate your senses. Chef Samuel Kim brings his culinary mastery from farm to table, serving everything homemade. Open Dinner, Sunday Brunch & L
Reviewed By Dunster1976
My wife, daughter and I had Motherâs Day dinner at Gigante Restaurant & Bar yesterday evening and it was absolutely wonderful. -Service: From the very beginning with the valet parking to the very end when picked up our coats from the hostess the service was superb.-Decor/Ambiance: The place is filled with nice vibes. I would describe the décor as a casual approach to âmodern nouveau eleganceâ (if there is such a description). A wide variety of spacious seating arrangements face onto a really striking bar, and there is a really neat private dining area to the rear. Really cool artwork is displayed throughout the restaurant and private dining areas. Unfortunately the weather was really bad so we could not take advantage of the outdoor seating with the beautiful fire pits that complement the indoor seating.-Food: In a word⦠Scrumptious! The restaurant is categorized as an âItalianâ eatery. While there were quite a few Italian dishes on the menu (I must give a shot out to the Mozzarella en Carrozzaâ¦unique and outrageously good!), there was also a nice selection of other types of selections including a couple of really great Asian Fusion type dishes (I had the Rock Shrimp Tempura as an appetizer and the Beef Tenderloin Kung Pao as an entrée (the sauce for the shrimp tempura was amazing and the stir fried vegetables in the beef tenderloin absolutely succulent). My wife is still ranting about the flavor and texture of the Beef Short Ribs.Near the end our dinner the maître de came over and chatted with us about our dining experience. When we raved about the quality of the food the maître de asked us if we would like to meet Chef Samuel Kim. This turned out to be one of the highlights of the evening. At a new establishment like Gigante I would have expected these guys to give us the stereotypic marketing speil about how great the place is. Instead, both gentlemen were extremely genuine and cordial, and it was obvious that they both are extremely passionate about their professions. For my family, their passion (and that of all of the staff at Gigante) was manifest in a truly wonderful dining experience. We will definitely be back. This is a must for those in search of a great dining experience.
