Location: Plymouth
Top Restaurants in Plymouth
Top Things to do in Plymouth
Most Popular Italian food in Plymouth, Pennsylvania, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Plymouth. Plymouth is a borough in Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, 4 miles (6 km) west of Wilkes-Barre (along the Susquehanna River). The population was 5,951 as of the 2010 census.
Things to do in Plymouth
10. 3 Guys Pizza
Overall Ratings
3 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By Clay C
We just discovered 3 Guys a couple weeks ago, and we have stopped in three times. I enjoy the atmosphere of the bar area, but the seats and tables fill up quickly. It has been my experience that by 7pm, there is not a seat or table to be found in the bar. However, there is a large family dining area that is separate from the bar and I have never seen a "wait time" (to be seated) for that area. The bar has an excellent selection of beer, and usually (at least) one IPA. Tuesday is Steak Night, and you receive a nice cut of steak (along with two sides) for $12.99. The Boli's are exceptional, and a small easily feeds two people, maybe three. Although I have not had the wings, I have seen them delivered to other tables and they look huge. There are specials every night, so be sure to check the menu. The staff is attentive and friendly.
9. Antonio's Pizza
Reviewed By JasonC607
I personally like a nice brown crust,a tasty sauce and good cheese and I consistently get it here. They have a nice menu I have had the chicken parm and Stromboli.. both top notch.. I frequently take the family it is extremely clean and service is always great. It reminds me of the Pizza shops in Jersey
8. Tommy's Pizza Corner
Overall Ratings
3 based on 55 reviews
Reviewed By nastolfi
I'd really like to give this place 5 stars, because their pizza is my favorite in the Wyoming Valley. I love both their round, and their Sicilian pizza. Their wings are also usually very good. I've lived in the Valley all of my life, and have been to Tommy's probably hundreds of times over the last 20 or so years. The food is almost ALWAYS great, but the service is almost ALWAYS terribly rude. It's not too bad if you're ordering delivery, but do expect at least an hour wait because they're usually busy. But every time we go to sit down and eat, I leave there aggravated because the server was rude. There is one in particular, with dark curly hair and tattoos who acts as if you're annoying her just by being there. Granted, they get very busy, especially on weekend nights, but that's no reason to treat people like garbage. The last time I went there to eat was a Friday evening and it was packed and there was a wait. One of the people in line was someone I used to work with and hadn't seen in years so we were chatting as we waited. I was with my son and she was with another person. The waitress (the particularly rude one) sat the people behind us and snapped at us that she would have been able to seat us if we didn't combine parties. I told her we didn't, that we were just talking and she rolled her eyes at us and we had to wait even longer to be seated. Just rude for no reason. I haven't been back to eat in the restaurant since. I think the owner really needs to set some customer service standards. I mean, if you have a business that regularly has a line out the door of people who want to spend their money there, you'd think you'd train your staff to be courteous to your patrons. It's a shame really, the food is good. It's greasy pizza and junk food, but it's good. I just can't take another interaction with that miserable waitress. I'll try back in a couple months maybe.
7. Rodano's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 104 reviews
Reviewed By Pat V
Rodanoâs has a delicious, varied menu (my personal favorite is the Diamond City salad) & courteous & accommodating waitstaff. Rodanoâs also has a banquet room for private affairs (weâve had 2 reunions, a family party & several get togethers held there) & an outdoor area to dine in fresh air. Conveniently located a few doors away from the Kirby Center, making it a great stop for dinner before & drinks after a show or play at the Kirby.I highly recommend Rodanoâs!
6. Vino Dolce
Overall Ratings
3 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By Ron S
Friends of ours invited us to join them for dinner, was our first time here. Small restaurant, located on local expressway and you could miss it if you blink. Reservations recommended. We were told about the special waitress, Renee. Believe she was actually co-owner. Loud, funny, brash and comedic as hell. She could take it and "dish" it out as well. After joking with her for a time, I asked to meet her husband, who was the chef so I could "express my sympathy" for the cross he had to bear. She said to remember that worked "both ways". Service from her added to the enjoyment of the well-prepared meal. Plentiful selection of Italian foods featuring home-made pasta dinners. Good selection of wines and drinks. All in all it was a very enjoyable evening and we definitely plan to return again.
5. Rita's Italian Ice
Reviewed By Jerry E
I had too many problems to list and it is a water Ice stand. i would rather drive to Scoops in Conshohocken for better service and great water ice. This place can KILL YOU. having to wait in a line i am fine with....but to have it start in a parking lot with cars and kids standing between cars is an accident just waiting to happen. I did not want my kids or I to stand in that line and waited on the sidewalk ...then an employee told me that I had to stand in line and wait my turn....I was doing that from the sidewalk.... when it was my turn i would come to the window. within 2 mins a guy was almost hit by a car in the parking lot...that is when the F..Bombs went flying by the driver and the guy who was almost hit...All the kids had to hear that crap. what a mess this place is.
What to do and see in Plymouth, United States: The Best Places and Tips
4. Dave Colarusso's Pizza and Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By Belle A
WHERE: Dave Colarussoâs Pizza & Pasta â 105 W End Road, Wilkes-Barre, PA Located on the Wilkes-Barre side of the Carey Avenue bridge in the little strip mall next to Circle Bar-B-Que. PHONE: 570.822.0181WHEN: Tuesday, 2016.1206 @ approximately 8:15pmCOST: 2 Guests / Eat In - Total Cost $34.61 (Excluding Tip)COMMENT: We are ALWAYS Treated Well Here â This is âOur Go To Placeâ for âChicken Parmigianaâ -- Hands Down, âItâs THE BEST!âWe ran into âDave Colarussoâsâ little restaurant pretty much by accident a few years ago and have been going there ever since. The quality of the food is consistently excellent and is always made fresh to order! If you want a great Italian dish for an absolutely reasonable price ($12.95), this is the place to go! The Chicken Parmigiana is my favorite! The chicken is battered and fried, then topped with a great homemade sauce and cheese then baked to perfection! It is always fresh and when you bite into it, itâs moist, juicy, and tender! Daveâs Chicken Parm beats all others in the area by leaps and bounds! The portion is very generous and the price is very fair. With the Chicken Parm, youâll also get a side of pasta. In addition, I order a dinner salad ($2.25) â the salad is also always very fresh and the lettuce is crispy! âEverything is Absolutely Delicious!â And letâs not forget the basket of fresh bread with plenty of butter that comes with the meal too! My husband and I have ordered other items as well, and all were very good! I still favor the Chicken Parm though! Besides having the most wonderful Italian Food, the owner, Dave just has to be a âGreat Guy!â â Everyone at Calorussoâs is âHappy!â We havenât been fortunate enough to meet Dave just yet, but we did meet his son âKyleâ this evening. We were running a little late so my husband called our order in to have it ready upon our arrival. Kyle took our order and no sooner did we walk in the door, Kyle was there with our pasta and a great big welcoming smile! Everyone who works at Daveâs seems to be quite happy! We are âAlways Greeted with a Smile!â There is the most lovely little lady who works there too; she literally runs around ensuring all patrons are taken care of like theyâre family! Finally, we found out her name is âNaomiâ. Naomi is the sweetest, kindest lady one could ever hope to meet. Naomi goes out of her way to make sure all is perfect with your meal and ensures youâre all happy too! Naomi âDoes it All!â ⦠She greets the folks who arrive, seats them, waits on them and delivers their food, takes phone orders at the counter, runs the cash register, helps the kitchen staff when needed, and cleans up! What an asset Naomi is to Dave Calorussoâs! Dave must be so proud to have Naomi as the front person for his restaurant; Naomi truly makes you want to visit Calorussoâs again, and again, and again! I can honestly say âI have never met anyone like Naomi!â What a wonderful human being! Dave, âThank Youâ for the great food! And âThank Youâ for giving us the opportunity to meet Naomi.
Plymouth Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Plymouth
3. Pasquale's Ristorante & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 45 reviews
Reviewed By Barrysphone69
Not been there in quite awhile. Nice ambiance, good service. Bruchetta was ok, a little bland though. Tomatoes and provolone on bread but no spices. They did bring warm bread with a dipping sauce that was good. Wife's meal was colorful and good but lacked the garlic advertised in the item description. Had the creamy tomato soup instead of the salad which was ok. My meal came with clams and shrimp around linguini. Problem was clams were still in shell and shrimp had tails intact. Messy to prepare before eating. That would have been acceptable except that the spicy sauce wasn't spicy and tasted just like the creamy tomato soup I just finished. All in all an ok experience, nothing to brag about. Sorry I couldn't be a little more positive. Don't like to complain.
2. Cafe Toscana
Overall Ratings
4 based on 218 reviews
Reviewed By ElizabethS5790
We had a wonderful meal at Cafe Toscana, walking from our hotel just down the street. We arrived a little after the dinner crowd. The service was excellent, and the food was delicious. If this restaurant was in Boston's North End, it would be twice the price. What a treat in Wilkes-Barre!
1. Gerry's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 83 reviews
Reviewed By UriusT
Gerry's is great pizza and has a drive through window to pick up your orders! Not the best pizza in Wilkes-Barre, but still great. I can still remember eating Gerry's for school lunch on Fridays at good old Bishop Hoban. Anytime I eat their pizza, it brings back the memories.
