Location: New Milford
Most Popular Italian food in New Milford, New Jersey, United States
Reviews on Italian food in New Milford, New Jersey, United States. New Milford is a borough in Bergen County, New Jersey, United States. As of the 2010 United States Census, the borough's population was 16,341, reflecting a decline of 59 (-0.4%) from the 16,400 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn increased by 410 (+2.6%) from the 15,990 counted in the 1990 Census.
10. Lieto Italia Ristorante
Overall Ratings
3 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By Rachel B
we usually get to Lieto before 6pm for their amazing Early Bird special. The food is consistently excellent. for the $15.95 you get soup, salad, a main, pasta side, dessert, and coffee. And quite a choice for the main options. the servers are wonderful, polite. Easy parking on the street or small side lot.
9. Sopranos Pizzeria and Restaurant
Sopranos Pizzeria Chef Alanzo - prepares and serves exquisite dinners to parties from two to 200 at your home, business or private catering event. His blend of French-Mediterranean cuisine draws on a lifetime of skills and the knowledge that all meals, no
Reviewed By maria r
Sopranos Pizzeria is our fall-back for when we need dinner as a family. Its quick and convenient and consistently good. Nice variety of pizza, awesome garlic rolls, great calzones and a full menu to choose from. Small seating area where singles, couples or a family feels welcome. Also great for take out or catering. A friendly owner and staff make it homey.
8. La Toscana Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By paul3776
La Toscana is primarily a take out pizzeria with a small dining room. Family owned and operated it serves very good pizza and decent Italian dishes. Weâve generally focused on pizza, both there and delivered but have tried several entrees which were good. BYO, limited on site parking and friendly service.
Where to eat Fusion food in New Milford: The Best Restaurants and Bars
7. Calabria Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By Rick D
While I think their pizza is just OK, everything else I've ever eaten here was delicious. They have garlic knot sliders that are super delicious and would go back just for them. We've also had them cater a few get-togethers and everyone has always raved about the food.
6. Sanducci's Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 99 reviews
Sanducci's Trattoria is a casual Italian eatery that is family owned and operated serving lunch & dinner . Dine in, takeout, delivery, on & off premise catering is available. Having a party? Celebrate with us in our party room and leave it all to us. Than
Reviewed By Justin W
Sanducci's is one of the best Italian restaurants in Bergen County. The food is always consistent and the service is always friendly and welcoming.There is a nice buffet on some afternoons and reasonable lunch specials. I had a chicken with lemon and wine with fresh vegetables, which was very good. I had a cannoli for dessert that was freshly filled and served with whipped cream.The food is always consistent and service wonderful.
5. BV Tuscany Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 114 reviews
Reviewed By 715richardh
Three of us went to BV Tuscany for a nice Italian dinner. Our expectations were exceeded!The service was top-notch. Several staff members helped us, each took pride in their service, and all knew the menu and offerings.The food was very innovative, and excellent. I had a shrimp dish that was a special of the night. It had no pasta, but lots of shrimp with marinara sauce and spinach. SO delicious! We shared the panna cotta and tiramasu. Both were very good.Not a cheap meal, but considering, it's a bargain. Love the upscale atmosphere, the neighborhood feel, and the food and service.
Top 7 Mediterranean food in New Milford, New Jersey, United States
4. Maggiano's Little Italy
Overall Ratings
4 based on 238 reviews
Welcome to Maggiano's in Hackensack. We are conveniently located in The Shops at Riverside just minutes from Manhattan, Garden State Parkway & Route 4. Our 300 seat dining room is ideal for your next social or business event. Maggianoâs blends the traditi
Reviewed By Mister219
The place reminds me of an old restaurant in one of those Italian movies. The decor was nothing special. The staff was great. The bread with olive oil was "ehhh"... we ordered the spaghetti and chicken parmesan. That was reallygood. We ordered the baked ziti as well. That was good also. We wanted the lasagna but they ran out of it. If you've ever been to Carmines in New York this place is similar. Only the portions are a little smaller. Food in comparison probably the same. Price not bad. Plenty if parking. Very clean.
3. Amarone Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 149 reviews
Reviewed By nanag1
Warm welcoming staff serving excellent food. The chick pea soup was tasty and served hot. Pasta with artichoke was excellent in white wine and chicken marsala with shrimp was delicious. Their menu is large and they are accommodating to food issues. We will definitely return
2. Roman Pizza & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 45 reviews
Reviewed By jameseC5390VD
There are many reasons they have been in business so long, but the main one is the high level of quality that goes into everything from the locally sourced ingredients to the helpful, friendly staff, the frequent menu upgrades and modern dining room and comfortable old school Italian restaurant experience that is becoming more difficult to find these days with all the corporate chains doing cheap knockoffs of traditional, family owned high quality local establishments like Roman's. So skip the chains and go right to the source.
1. Sanzari's New Bridge Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 86 reviews
Reviewed By AALowndes
We visited as a couple last week to celebrate our anniversary . Sanzariâs has been recommended to us by friends and reviews looked great. However we were left a bit flat by the experience . Things that were good- staff weâre great- pork chop did live up to hype- ambience was lively , layouts good - wine was nice - sitting at bar before meal was pleasant, they had a good singer on and the bar staff were friendly Things that were not great- my wifeâs teriyaki calamari was awful, it was coated in a sticky sweet and sour sauce and was nothing like it was described on the menu . It was like a Chinese take away dishâs and was far to big. - my lasagne was bland and tasteless, I was really looking forward to it with it being an old fashioned Italian I expected a great lasagne. It was supermarket quality at best unfortunately and again far to big. - at the end of the evening we felt rushed out, we didnât sit till 9 and everyone had gone, the feeling was they were waiting for us to get up and leave. - bill, it was too pricey for the quality of the food we received . At the time we tried to brush it off as we had a nice evening overall but on reflection it didnât come up to scratch on the food front. Will probably not return which is a real shame .......
Most Popular Pub food in New Milford, New Jersey, United States
