Location: Middleton
Top Restaurants in Middleton
Most Popular Italian food in Middleton, Wisconsin, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Middleton, Wisconsin, United States. Middleton is a city in Dane County, Wisconsin, United States, and a suburb of the state capital, Madison. Middleton's motto is "The Good Neighbor City." The population was 17,442 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Middleton
10. Gino's Italian Deli
Overall Ratings
4 based on 23 reviews
Reviewed By Nate D
I always get the number 13 on asiago. I simply cannot go wrong with the sandwich. Furthermore, I love how Gino's accepts credit cards but provides a discount to cash payers. There's nothing worse than a business that doesn't except credit cards these days.
9. Pizza Brutta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By JeffreyK102
Pizza Brutta has a wide range of pizzas, which you can customize to just about any combination. The pizzas are made right in front of you and cooked in cool wood-fired oven. The crusts are perfect, and the ingredients are fresh. I frequently see the manager working on the line or serving, and the employees seem very engaged. A variety of local beers are offered, and there is a small selection of red and white wines.The service is good, but there can be quite a line to order. On a busy night, expect to wait 15-20 minutes after you order for your pizza. The salads are quite fresh and are ready much sooner--a great way to start your meal. The restaurant can get a bit noisy. In the warmer months, there are a few tables outside. Parking may be a challenge on weekend nights and afternoons but the Middleton location is much easier to park at than the Madison location.
8. The Roman Candle Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By markusgogo80
I had a Lunch Meeting in there. The place is known about the, Pizzas and now I understand why. I had small âRoman Candleâ pizza in there - and that was delicious and big enough. For people outside of US - you need to remember, that everything is bigger in here. Small size is for single Person and large is for few families .Overall good experience.
7. Benvenuto's Italian Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 90 reviews
Benvenuto's is locally owned and operated, and ready to serve you at all Seven of our locations. Stop in today and come, eat and enjoy! Our Italian Grill theme and our diverse menu appeals to almost everyone. We have the philosophy of offering great food
Reviewed By martinione
My family reserved the small side room for a Celebration of Life luncheon. Though some of the staff unfortunately decided that they were too busy to show up- the remaining staff and management did everything possible to make our luncheon a success. As we were in no great hurry- everything worked out perfectly. Our cocktails and meals were delicious. Lots of tasty bread. Plenty of friendly smiles and attitude from our servers. Will definitely return next trip to town.
6. Oliva
Overall Ratings
4 based on 102 reviews
Reviewed By vivioakr
2 stars because the food is very good, very delicious tomato sauce, but the waiter, he acts like is bothered with the fact of people going there, 1st.when he brought my salad he threw my plate on the table with disgust. 2nd. I asked for my plate to come WITHOUT the spaguetti and it came with the spaguetti anyway, terrible spaguetti btw, too hard, was that AL DENTE? , 3rd the lemonade was more ice than lemonade and when we ran out of lemonade nobody asked to refill it... I think I can live without going there again, I don't have time to be misstreated by a waiter, there are other italian restaurants around Middleton!
5. Vin Santo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 151 reviews
Reviewed By patl853
My husband and I visited recently to celebrate an anniversary. We were seated at a table for two near the center of this small restaurant. It had a wood top that was disgusting and stained. Numerous grease spots, dirty rings from previous drink glasses.Really? How much would it cost to replace one little table, or just put a tablecloth on it? Or maybe a coat of paint? If our table looked this bad what does the kitchen look like?Very disappointed!
4. Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano
Overall Ratings
4 based on 119 reviews
Reviewed By rockydogz1
This dish was absolutely superb and cooked perfectly with seasonings that enhanced the taste. Green beans also perfect and slightly crunchy. Mashed potatoes incredible with a hint of garlic. Truly and incredible meal expertly prepared. Server was excellent and very attentive.
Most Popular Mediterranean food in Middleton, Wisconsin, United States
3. Novanta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 109 reviews
Reviewed By kjjh
Classic pizza done right. Fresh ingredients cooked in 90 seconds, service is always friendly, price is right. They have several mozzarella styles to choose from as well, and cannolli, although I never get that far. Run by same people as own the Cafe d'Alba in Hilldale, but here the focus is the pizza. Best in town.
Top 4 Contemporary food in Middleton, Wisconsin, United States
2. Villa Dolce
Overall Ratings
4 based on 149 reviews
Reviewed By Robert H
We each had a different entree from pizza to seafood to bolognese. I would say everything was average. They have a very nice atmosphere and our server Fiona was excellent, but the pizza does not match up to Racine pizza, it was rather flimsy. The bolognese has good homemade pasta but there was very little meat in the dish. I probably will not return.
Best Steakhouse food near Middleton, Wisconsin, United States
1. Johnny's Italian Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 413 reviews
At Johnnyâs, our steaks take center stage and are complemented by a gourmet assortment of Italian cuisine and seafood, alongside an expertly curated wine list. Whether you choose our famous Steak DeBurgo or the classic Chanel No. 5, youâre sure to satisfy
Reviewed By eleanorp863
Recently visited this establishment and found excellent service at the bar as well as a truly wonderful martini! The French onion soup was excellent as was the fillet and I must say that the zucchini fries are a welcome addition to the menu! If it is just one or two of you I recommend you get the light portion because they are plentiful! If you like them crispy... ask for crispy! Steak temperatures were right on target and after the initial cut, I could cut the steak with my fork. Crazy good. The staff are welcome and friendly, the ambience and atmosphere are right on target. Enjoy! Eleanor - thank you for the wonderful review. I am so happy to hear you enjoyed everything. Sounds like you made some delicious choices! I have shared your review with the team. We hope to dine with you again soon!
Where to eat American food in Middleton: The Best Restaurants and Bars
