Location: Hamlin
Top Restaurants in Hamlin
Most Popular Italian food in Hamlin, Pennsylvania, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Hamlin, Pennsylvania, United States. Hamlin Township is a township in McKean County, Pennsylvania, United States. The population was 819 at the 2000 census.
Things to do in Hamlin
10. Rolly's Pizza & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 82 reviews
We decided it was time to open an "American Fusion" restaurant in the area. WWth the finest, most fresh food available for our deserving customers. Offering a Family friendly atmosphere with scenic views, full service restaurant dine in, take out, and del
Reviewed By ANNE C
great food choices and wonderful entrees. Excellent ice cream for your dessert or any time of day with delicious sundaes and other delectable choices.
9. Kay's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 107 reviews
Reviewed By DianeC575
First visit here and will return. Breakfast buffet on Sun 8am-1pm, plenty of options from omelettes, scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, fresh fruits, pastries and more. We arrived at noon and all pans and plates at the breakfast buffet were full and still be replenished. Hamburg's are made fresh, nice & thick & juicy on a kaiser roll. Wait staff all friendly & want to please. ALL desserts are made in house, and what a selection, you really can't make up your mind. Place is divided into 2 dining rooms and walls in the one are decorated with antique signs and memorabilia. Vintage cigarette machines also on display. Place is very clean as is the bathrooms. Been in business for at least 40 years. NO CREDIT CARDS ACCEPTED.
8. John's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 116 reviews
Reviewed By randyorso
Ordered the Classic Antipasto and Dad had the Lentil Soup! He seemed to really enjoy it. I enjoyed the Classic Antipasto! Seating was comfortable. Everywhere was clean. The waitstaff was professional. Nice specials listed at the tables. Thanks to the staff! Was a nice break during the day.
7. Donna's Sterling Corner Bistro
Reviewed By Carm18426
Nestled on a corner of a small road in the town of Sterling in the Poconos this little cafe offers good bistro fare at an affordable price. Known by the locals as having delicious breakfast and brunch selections another couple and my husband and I decided to try it ourselves. The luncheon menu has a large selection of paninis, wraps, hot dogs, burgers, and pizzas which can be accompanied by soup and salad. I selected the "chef's choice" which was a chicken club consisting of a panko chicken breast topped with pepper jack and cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion and their signature romoulade and potato chips. My husband's choice was a Philly steak sandwich, and both of us were happy with our meal.Our friends who are vegetarians were pleased that they could order from the menu and tried their peanut butter silk pie, one of their specialties, for dessert.Our waitress was very cordial and the owner/chef came to our table to see if we were satisfied with our meals.When next time we are in the area, we will return.
6. Kay's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 43 reviews
Reviewed By ThrillSeeker1015
The prices are low and you always get a lot of food at dinner time! I always have food to bring back home! Love the staff here and the food is great! Keep up the great work!
5. R&J's Wild Rover
Overall Ratings
3 based on 19 reviews
We are an Irish Pub, Grille, and Pizzeria. Our menu has Irish favorites, Italian favorites, delicious hand formed burgers, cheesesteaks, and homemade desserts. Our Pub has 8 large TV's that display the NFL, MLB, and BIG 10 networks to name a few. We are o
Reviewed By MTDigs
We will be back, and we will try you again, based on our 1st two visits. However, on this third visit we were very underwhelmed. Maybe because we got everything to go?The Pizza: It was as bad as it used to be when it was called Trio's. We found out, after the fact, that you were short a pizza chef. Please note: Trio's NEVER had good pizza, so if you're using thier style when it's crazy busy it's a bad move. By the way - The pizza sauce should NEVER be left out on the counter by the door. It must have a steady/maintained temperature. And it shouldn't be left unguarded.The Sandwiches: Skimpy and the Corned Beef was Cold-cuts; not real Irish Corned Beef. It was fresh, and a good grade of cold-cuts, but they were still just cold-cuts. I could have gone to Weiss and gotten my meat sliced there and made my own sandwich. A signle slice of rye bread was twice the thickness of the contents of either sandwich: The Reubin, and the Corned Beef on Rye. It was almost as if the meat that should have been on ONE, was split between the two - - - and first the chef pulled out a couple of slices. It was a SKIMPY sandwich. The Chicked Wings: Were plump, fresh, moist and wonderful. Still 1000 x's better than backdraft. These were fantastic wings!!Suggestion: Since I have eaten there twice already, I know how large and good your sandwiches are. So.... If you're running low, don't cheap out. Just tell the customer you were out, or tell us if there's only enough for one sandwich. We were told, on the phone, there was no more Irish Dip Sanwiches left and we accepted it. But if you've run out of real corned beef, don't switch to cold-cuts, and then skimp on the meat for the sandwiches.(Or I hope you're not taking that "It's Take-out, so it doesn't matter" tact to business.)I apologize for your experience. You are correct on the pizza issue...no excuse and we take pride in how delicious our pizza is....this was addressed! As far as your sandwich, skimpy is not satisfactory. However, our meats are NOT deli meat. Our chef roasts everything in house and slices. I will I quite as to what happened. No excuse....I have spoken to all and they did have a response....everyone has a bad day at work....my response....not here. And no, we do not take any adjectives of our service as âit doesnât matterâ. In fact, take out should have EXTRA care...there is nothing worse than getting it home and it being wrong or not what was expected. Thank you for letting us know and we will make every effort that it doesnât happens to anyone else.
4. Aldentes Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
5 based on 36 reviews
Reviewed By Tom V
My son and I stopped in to get lunch and it was fantastic. It had been a while since I was here and it is still the same great food. We ordered a Cheese Steak Stromboli, Garlic Parm Wings and Hot Wings. Food was great, no disappointment what so ever. They also have a few new Stromboli I can't wait to try. I'll be back here for sure. Thanks!
3. 3 D's Deli & Pizza
Reviewed By JOHN M
3 3D's opened recently and the word got around that they had a real Philly style Cheese Steak. Once you leave Philly they are hard to find. My search is over. They make the best in Northeast PA. Steaks and hoagies need a great roll that is crusty outside and soft inside. They have it. I have had multiple cheese steaks, tuna and Italian hoagies. Awesome. Heavyweight two fisted hoagies with quality and quantity and great prices.
2. Piero's Pizza & Hoagies
Overall Ratings
4 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By alp250
This is our go-to pizza place in the area! Their pizza always taste so fresh! I highly recommend the hot wing pizza, it's our favorite! The best part is that they have great customer service and they never take long to make an order!
1. Johnâs Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 96 reviews
Reviewed By randyorso
This large ample lunch salad is healthy, plentiful, and delicious. I really enjoy and look forward to this salad. The flavors are excellent. I love the balsamic dressing, walnuts, chickpeas, spinach, and romaine lettuce, the sun-dried tomatoes are an added nice touch. Very delicious. When I want a salad this is the place!
