Location: Elkhart
Top Restaurants in Elkhart
Top Things to do in Elkhart
- 1. Linton's Enchanted Gardens
- 2. RV/MH Hall of Fame and Museum
- 3. Wellfield Botanic Gardens
- 4. Ruthmere Mansion
- 5. The Lerner Theater
- 6. National New York Central Railroad Museum
- 7. Elkhart River, Island Park- Riverwalk
- 8. Midwest Museum of American Art
- 9. Hall of Heroes Super Hero Museum
- 10. Elkhart County Convention & Visitors Bureau
Most Popular Italian food in Elkhart, Indiana, United States
Reviews on Italian food in Elkhart, Indiana, United States. Elkhart is a lively small city in the heart of rustic Amish country, complimenting the rural charm of northern Indiana with world class shopping and dining, lush green spaces, exciting festivals and events throughout the year. Witness the Amish hard at work in the small villages surrounding the city, or discover vibrant arts and nightlife in the revitalized downtown area. Head to verdant Island Park, where the St. Joseph and Elkhart rivers merge, for an oasis of calm within the city downtown.
Things to do in Elkhart
10. Volcano Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By Trainman334
The food was very good. Large portions (even the half-size pastas were hard to finish), great meatballs, fresh salad and large tasty bread-sticks. We were ordering in to our hotel room after a long day. I had finished giving my order, including pastas, sides, salads, bread-sticks and drinks when the person on the phone told me that their policy was that I had to order a pizza in order to get delivery. I understand a minimum dollar amount for a delivery; but a mandatory pizza was new to me. I was tired. I added the small pizza for about 12 bucks and I got the delivery. The pizza, like everything else, was delicious. But, figuratively, it left a bad taste in my mouth. The delivery guy was friendly, the order was accurate and quick. Hot things were hot and cold things were cold. But I couldn't finish the pizza.
9. Volcano Pizza Concord Commons
Reviewed By jason0130
I'm in town for the RV Open House and a vendor brought our office 3 different pizzas from Volcano. OMG, they were delicious. Easily one of the best pizzas that I have ever eaten. Full of flavor, cheese was goooooeyyy and they had plenty of toppings. I'm definitely eating here again the next time I visit Elkhart.
8. Colombo's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 33 reviews
Reviewed By ryanwilt
This place is unbelievable, it's been around for almost 40 years for a reason: their pizza, marinara, & service are simply the best you can find--anywhere! Can't wait to go back soon...do yourself a favor & get to this place if you haven't been in awhile, it's so worth it!
7. Michael's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By Taadow7
Michael's is wonderful! Delicious pizza and pasta! And get the cheese & crackers for sure!!! Enjoyable atmosphere and family owned for generations. I had the spaghetti with olive oil, garlic, mushrooms, & shrimp and it was amazing!!!
6. Davinci's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
Reviewed By Indy_colts2009
First timer here...ordered a buffet of pizzas for an event...variety of toppings and enjoyed the sausage pizza best...crust was a bit thicker than I'd like, I'm a thin crust...but overall I thought the food was good...nice sizes, large, and plenty of toppings. Would order again...
5. Bruno's pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By moncoer
My wife and I had pizza delivered to our hotel from this pizzeria. Delivery was slow-70 minutes - which was the reason the pizza was cold. Deciding on size of the pizza was difficult by the menu description-as a result we certainly over ordered. Having said this, the pizza was good ( the deluxe). The marguerite was not up to par. Prices on the high side.
Where to eat Pizza food in Elkhart: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 119 reviews
Reviewed By pman74
I like Olive Garden, normally. However, this trip was not a good one. While waiting on a table in the lobby, there were 3 host staff that were very busy mocking their manager, instead of seating people. Then after getting seated, the Bread came right out. Then after ordering food, we had to keep asking for our drinks to be filed. No one came to clear our serving bowls, till our food was being delivered. This took over 45 minutes! The table next to us was eating unlimited pasta and was on his 3rd serving before our food came out. He was seated just after us. On top of this, the food special they advertise and I ordered, I get informed that they are out of, 20 minutes after ordering???? Thank goodness for the tablet pay system because I feel I would still be waiting on my check.
3. Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano
Overall Ratings
4 based on 45 reviews
Reviewed By Vickie S
Small, quaint Italian restaurant. The food was good, portions above average but the service was very slow. We were there for two hours and it wasn't that busy. We asked the waitress for bread, motioned her over to take our order. It was forever before our food came out. We had a party of eight so that might have been part of it. One person in our party ordered dessert & we finally told our waitress to forget it & bring our check. She ended up bringing the dessert. I guess she forgot. Overall it was alright but probably wouldn't go back. Somewhat pricey in comparison to other Italian restaurants in the area.
Indiana, United States Food Guide: 10 Pub food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Elkhart
2. Luchesse's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 77 reviews
Reviewed By WorldTravelers1999
Don't get me wrong, Luchesse's has great pizza. We ordered the large pizza - half cheese, half meatball. That size is more than enough for most groups of 4. We also bought two slices of cheese cake - red velvet and pumpkin. Both were very good, but the pumpkin is better. It is seasonal, so you may want to make your way to Luchesse's while supplies last! The establishment was much nicer than expected. For some reason, I was expecting a hole-in-the-wall pizza restaurant was pleasantly surprised when we walked through the door. The customer service is what made this visit a 5-star experience. The staff was outstanding from the hostess to our waitress - Rachel did an outstanding job! We are planning to return soon, as the folks here treat customers very, very well. Highly recommend!
1. Antonio's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 150 reviews
Reviewed By genalisa
This classic Elkhart restaurant is a gem! They have great, authentic Italian food And their pizza is legendary! They have an award-winning Italian salad that is super yummy too. There are a couple of private areas where you could host a party or a wedding. We had our company Christmas party there last year in the large back room and it was perfect! Our employees love the food so much that we often use them to cater our on-site employee parties. They have never failed us!
