Location: Carmel
Top Restaurants in Carmel
Most Popular Italian food in Carmel, Indiana, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Carmel, Indiana, United States. Carmel /ˈkɑːrməl/ is a suburban city in Hamilton County, Indiana, United States, located immediately north of Indianapolis. It has been one of the fastest-growing communities in the country. In 2012, Carmel was selected as the "Best Place to Live in the United States" by CNN Money magazine, and received the same designation by Niche.com in 2017. The population was 79,191 as of the 2010 and was estimated to be 91,065 in 2016 by the US Census Bureau, making it the fifth-largest city in Indiana.
Things to do in Carmel
10. Puccini's Smiling Teeth Pizza & Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 33 reviews
We offer pasta, pizza, salads & more, fresh each day. Gluten-free and vegan options.
Reviewed By paul30
Have not been here in yearsâ¦.. donât know why, it was very good...Family had a Pizza with sausage, pepperoni, bacon, onions, and peppers...It was very, very good...The crust is thin, but not too thin... lots of ingredients on the pizza like you would make at home...all very high quality ingredients.... Family Size 16" pizza was about 16.00We had a small side salad with their homemade dressing. Outstanding salad that is large enough to share ... and it comes with a basket of garlic bread....all very, very good.,Wife had the Angel Hair pasta with meat sauce and meat balls.. it too was excellent and 10.00Service was very goodI donât know why we took this place off our rotation, but now that we have found it, we will be back... and be a regular...Thanks for the kind words, paul30. We're glad you're back!Liz M.
9. Greek Tony's Pizza & Sub Shop
Overall Ratings
4 based on 33 reviews
Reviewed By Emily A
There's no comparison when it comes to pizza and other fabulous carbs. They are fast, friendly, well priced, and tasty. You don't blow up on salt, and you don't feel you've eaten empty calories. These pizzas are full of quality ingredients, put there by competent people. A fun place, fun food. Say yes!
8. Donatello's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By indyfun
This is a small restaurant, independently owned. They have done a great job with their food selection. All of the sauces are made fresh daily, as well as all of the salad dressings. I had the pasta carbonara ... one of my friends had the meatball lasagna special and the other one had the chicken marsala. We all totally enjoyed the food and the service! Itâs a good idea to get reservations here, as itâs a fairly small venue.All of the entrées come with either a soup or a salad. I had their house salad which was very crisp and fresh, and one of my friends had the creamy asparagus soup. She said it was fantastic.The serving portions are generous, I ended up taking half of mine home. Will definitely return to this little gem!
7. The Old Spaghetti Factory
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By djournot
While traveling for work, I went to The Old Spaghetti Factory for dinner. Everything was delicious - from the warm, crusty bread to the excellent Sangria to the creamy Fettuccini Alfredo. The restaurant was clean, service was quick and the staff were pleasant. Iâll be back!
Where to eat Bar food in Carmel: The Best Restaurants and Bars
6. Pizzology
Overall Ratings
4 based on 128 reviews
Pizzology Craft Pizzeria believes that everyone deserves delicious Pizza made with local, seasonal, ingredients. We support farms that utilize sustainable farming practices to make our award winning wood fired pizzas. We make our cheeses, sauces, sausages
Reviewed By Married40
We moved down to Brown County so it has been a couple years since we have been. Same excellent pizza - love the wood fired taste and great wine. Cozy, great neighborhood restaurant. Good salads too!
Indiana, United States Food Guide: 10 Cafe food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Carmel
5. Roselli's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 72 reviews
Reviewed By Chops1971
While my husband and I were staying at Sybaris Pool Suites, we ordered from Roselli's for dinner (they were the place the staff recommended). We were not disappointed. We ordered their spinach and tomato bread - thought it sounded interesting, and we are so glad we did. It was AMAZING. We also ordered a pizza, which was quite good. We prefer thin crust, and they have a good thin crust pizza. I would highly recommend if you are in the area.
4. Biaggi's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 160 reviews
Casual Italian restaurant offering an extensive selection of house-made and imported pastas, soups and salads, pizza, seafood, steaks and desserts. Large portions of affordably priced menu selections are prepared with the freshest ingredients available.
Reviewed By CathyHerr
Beautiful restaurant with great Italian food. Great food available in the bar as well as the dining room. Personal favorite is the black fettuccine Alfredo with seafood. Great breads with oil. The service we have experienced varies from great to bad. On the bad occasion, it was due to a miscommunication between servers. Food was still great. The other 5 times we went were great. Enjoy!
Most Popular Cajun & Creole food in Carmel, Indiana, United States
3. Ristorante Roma
Overall Ratings
4 based on 100 reviews
Here at Ristorante Roma you will find a place where you can be with your loved ones and enjoy good Italian food. When I cook, I express my knowledge and love for the Italian cuisine through flavors, aromas, temperatures, and visual sensations that come ou
Reviewed By YoBob536
We were visiting some friends in the Indianapolis area and they took us to this nice little slice of Italy. Decor is very nice and makes you feel welcome. Staff is friendly and was eager to help us enjoy our dinner. We ordered various dishes so we could have a variety of the cuisine. The wine list is impressive also. Overall the food was good and the experience was very nice. We enjoyed our visit with our friends and were not disappointed.
2. Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine
Overall Ratings
4 based on 91 reviews
Reviewed By 251garrys
Thanks for a great meal In a great environment. The wine selection was great as was the meal. Nice to have the owner come over and chat.
1. Bazbeaux Pizza (Carmel)
Overall Ratings
4 based on 262 reviews
Reviewed By adam b
It's still good but highly overrated. It's slightly above average pizza. I did try the Mexican last night but it left something to be desired. It badly needs jalapenos. I'm not sure I would try it again. Matt the sever did a solid job for us. We might return.
