Location: Garden City
Top Restaurants in Garden City
Most Popular Diner food in Garden City, New York, United States
Reviews on Diner food in Garden City, New York, United States. Garden City is an incorporated village in Nassau County, New York, United States, in the town of Hempstead. It was founded by multi-millionaire Alexander Turney Stewart in 1869, and is on Long Island, to the east of New York City, 18.5 miles (29.8 km) from midtown Manhattan. The village is located mostly in the Town of Hempstead with a small portion in the Town of North Hempstead.
Things to do in Garden City
7. Carle Place Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 69 reviews
Reviewed By Melonie S
I stopped in with a bunch of co-workers during lunch time at the suggestion of one of them who lived in the area. It's a big establishment that's handicap accessible and offers valet service. Service seemed to be the problem of the day at this diner. We had a difficult time placing our order. After looking at a menu and waiting and waiting and waiting, we finally asked if we could order. I noticed there was a table behind us that had been there before us and had just received their food. That wasn't a good sign. I ordered the Challah bread French toast with a side of sausage and coffee. It took a very long time just to get the coffee. As a coffee snob, I would say the coffee was drinkable. My meal consisted of 2 very thick slices of Challah bread and two sausage links. I've never said this before and I don't want to sound like my mother but, the French toast had a weird aftertaste. I can't explain it. Did I eat them? Yes. The links were ok but cooked many hours earlier.After finishing our meal, we waited for our check. It never came. We asked our waiter for the check. It never came. We had to ask another waiter who told our waiter and eventually we received our check. The service was so poor that I actually saw a table of three across from us nearly stand up in the booth to signal they were ready to order. The prices were very reasonable, the food was questionable, and the service was poor. If this diner was in NJ, it wouldn't last long.
6. Garden City Coffee Shop
Overall Ratings
4 based on 23 reviews
Reviewed By LollysLook
My husband and I had breakfast at The Garden City Coffee this morning. Itâs a small old fashioned coffee shop with booths, tables and counter service. They have a small breakfast menu with diner type made to order breakfast items. We ordered pancakes and waffles both were good.
5. The Lantern Diner
Overall Ratings
3 based on 32 reviews
The Lantern Diner is a family-oriented restaurant serving amazing comfort food the right way. Since opening its Doors once again in 2014 under new management, The Lantern Diner has become once again the Landmark of Hempstead, thanks to our beloved communi
Reviewed By 845sherrys
I love burgers but this one looked very nice and was perfect medium rare...but totally dry and difficult to swallow. The rolls on our burgers were huge, but sweet (not s great accompaniment to meat). And they considered charging for fresh onion. Huh? My husbandâs turkey burger deluxe needed a reminder to bring the included onion rings. I must say the fries were fabulous... burning hot, freshly made.
4. The Lantern Diner
Overall Ratings
3 based on 32 reviews
The Lantern Diner is a family-oriented restaurant serving amazing comfort food the right way. Since opening its Doors once again in 2014 under new management, The Lantern Diner has become once again the Landmark of Hempstead, thanks to our beloved communi
Reviewed By 845sherrys
I love burgers but this one looked very nice and was perfect medium rare...but totally dry and difficult to swallow. The rolls on our burgers were huge, but sweet (not s great accompaniment to meat). And they considered charging for fresh onion. Huh? My husbandâs turkey burger deluxe needed a reminder to bring the included onion rings. I must say the fries were fabulous... burning hot, freshly made.
3. Biscuits & Barbeque
Overall Ratings
4 based on 110 reviews
Reviewed By M5641VDsteveng
Food is fair place. I have been to New Orleans many times and the food here does not compare in quality or selection.The place does have the old diner charm
2. Thomas's Ham & Eggery Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 220 reviews
Reviewed By Eva S
The best skillet omelets I've eaten. The boss n staff are awesome. Always busy there. My favorite is the chicken and leek frittata with little bit of hot sauce OMG. Mmmmmm mmmmmm good. Definitely recommend this place to anyone who likes eating breakfast anytime of the day. P.S. they have other great stuff on their menu but I go there just for the breakfast items. So if you're in Carl Place and you're hungry go visit them. They won't disappoint you .I use to eat breakfast at diners and then I tried this place. Never went to a diner to eat breakfast again.
1. The Lantern Diner
Overall Ratings
3 based on 32 reviews
The Lantern Diner is a family-oriented restaurant serving amazing comfort food the right way. Since opening its Doors once again in 2014 under new management, The Lantern Diner has become once again the Landmark of Hempstead, thanks to our beloved communi
Reviewed By 845sherrys
I love burgers but this one looked very nice and was perfect medium rare...but totally dry and difficult to swallow. The rolls on our burgers were huge, but sweet (not s great accompaniment to meat). And they considered charging for fresh onion. Huh? My husbandâs turkey burger deluxe needed a reminder to bring the included onion rings. I must say the fries were fabulous... burning hot, freshly made.
Best American food near Garden City, New York, United States
