Location: Whitefish Bay
Top Restaurants in Whitefish Bay
Most Popular American food in Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin, United States. Whitefish Bay is a village in Milwaukee County, Wisconsin, United States. The population was 14,110 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Whitefish Bay
10. Lakefront Brewery Beer Hall
Overall Ratings
4 based on 219 reviews
At Lakefront Brewery Beer Hall, we pride ourselves in our homemade recipes that use the finest ingredients from Wisconsin farms and local entrepreneurs to offer you a genuine taste and experience of Milwaukee. We only take reservations on Friday nights fo
Reviewed By MiltonLisboaPortugal
We were woundering where all the people from Millwaukee gather in a weekend. As we mostly saw quiet streets in the city center. Well this beer hall could be one the places. And we understand why:- very nice and helpful staff. Truly commited to this brewery project,- great food (had the fish tacos and the saudages and both were delicious)- amazing beer! Would love to find all these beers back in Portugal...Great place to spend a morning or afternoon!
9. Sanford Restaurant
Overall Ratings
5 based on 416 reviews
Reviewed By Porter S
My wife and I have dined here about 10 times now, sometimes with guests we have brought along, more often just the two of us. We have always been very favorably impressed with the superior quality of the ambience, the service, and of course the food. As for ambience, the single dining room is small and well appointed. The building looks like Old Milwaukee on the outside, but inside the restaurant looks like L.A. I personally hate loud dining rooms, and have never had a problem with the noise level here. There is an overall atmosphere of efficient professionalism throughout the place. The staff are all well trained, friendly and knowledgeable. The wait staff know all the details about the menuâs choices. The food is wonderful. We will keep coming back for sure.
8. Solly's Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 196 reviews
Sollyâs Grille is an 82 year old small cafe/diner. You sit on swivel stools with backs at two horseshoe counters. Our butter burgers were originated in 1936 by my stepfather Kenneth Salmon. We also serve our homemade pies, tuna salad, chicken salad, cold
Reviewed By mintysnowflake7
We visited Sollyâs early on a Friday evening for dinner, my first time going. The atmosphere is an old-school diner, and they do not have any alcohol or beer â instead, you can order shakes and malts. The seating is all counter seating around the main grill and soda fountain, so if youâre with a group or it is crowded, you may struggle to find seating. The service was okay â the server who ended up finishing our dinner with us was friendlier. It was cool to see the burgers being cooked in front of you, and although I appreciated that the servers were able to do some of the cooking as there appeared to be only one chefâ¦please be sure to have them wear appropriate cooking attire, like gloves and hats/hair netsâ¦because I did unfortunately suffer the consequences. Because of that, I am disappointed to say I think I would avoid returning.I was torn between one of their famous burgers and the fish fry (since it was Friday). Ultimately, I went with the fish fry, which was fine, but I would say to stick with what theyâre known for. The fish fry was decent, but it was breaded â I feel like battered fish fry is so much better. My significant other had the Peno Burger (jalapenos, pepper jack cheese, and onions) which was delicious and dripping with butter, as theyâre known for. Check your diet at the door! The fries were good, nice and crispy. We didnât have enough room for dessert, but they had a variety of pies available.
7. Benji's Delicatessen & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 105 reviews
Reviewed By Patricia K
Four people, four different orders, and enjoyed by all. Service was extremely fast and much appreciated for a nice stop on a long drive. Incredible chicken soup like mom used to make. Sandwiches were delish! One companion said the hope poppel definitely something to try!
6. The Cheesecake Factory
Overall Ratings
4 based on 185 reviews
The Cheesecake Factory offers something for everyone featuring a wide variety of over 200 menu items prepared fresh to order each day, plus over 30 legendary varieties of the Finest Cheesecake.
Reviewed By melissawisco
Stopped for lunch after shopping at Bayshore Mall. More and more restaurants seem to be closing near Bayshore. We were able to get seated right away on Sunday for lunch around 12 pm which was great. Our waitress was pleasant. The menu is huge like 14+ pages and calories are listed next to each food item. I ordered a side of grilled asparagus which was delicious for less than $7, the skinny-licious turkey burger I ordered for $8 came with no side and was about half the size of normal burger but nonetheless was flavorful. I won't come back due to price/value.Hello and thanks for your feedback. We are sorry we have not been able to provide you with an exceptional experience. Perhaps you'd like to join us for Happy Hour for discounted food and drinks. We also offer wonderful Small Plates and Snacks that are a great value. Thanks again and we hope you can give us another try.
5. Moxie Food + Drink
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
The North Shore's newest restaurant, serving inspired American Comfort Food in an upscale-casual atmosphere. Warm. Welcoming. And waiting for you.
Reviewed By Yoop6424
This place checks all the boxes. Great food; pesto salmon, the best risotto Iâve ever had, great Tuscan bread, shrimp and scallops pasta, chocolate torte with berries! All amazing! The espresso Martini was great, the service was lacking but they were slammed and had one bartender and two servers who rocked it, with the support of a great food runner and two young bus boys: definitely can be overlooked due to the great demeanor of the servers and outstanding teamwork. A great spot. Definitely will be back.
4. The Bay
Overall Ratings
4 based on 73 reviews
The Bay Restaurant located right in the middle of the Whitefish Bay Downtown Business District. Enjoy some of the best dishes served in Whitefish Bay in a warm and inviting neighborhood hangout. Open brick and dark original hardwoods set the tone for a de
Reviewed By Jennifer J
I met for a business meeting after a busy lunch. Our server Lauren was busy cleaning, but payed great attention to us and made us feel very welcome. Was perfect environment to talk. Will definitely keep on list of meeting places!
3. Jack Pandl's Whitefish Bay Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 123 reviews
John Pandl opened Pandl's Whitefish Bay Inn in 1915 right here in this historic building. The current owner is his grandson. Enjoy traditional German favorites as well as popular American entrées in a casually intimate atmosphere with fresh flowers on you
Reviewed By scottagordonsg
Jack Pandl's Whitefish Bay Inn is a true old school, family style dining experience with a German influenced menu. The entrees are decent but not great and the service can be 'uneven' at times.
2. The Anchorage
Overall Ratings
4 based on 264 reviews
The redesigned Anchorage restaurant and River's Edge Lounge uses high quality locally sourced ingredients to enhance all their dishes.
Reviewed By payitfwd71
I was under the impression that the restaurant was open until 9:00. I arrived just after 8. The lights were on. Doors were open. But nobody home. No host/hostess or waitstaff. Completely empty. I waited a little while but nobody came out. So back to the hotel room I went. Ordered room service and the food was excellent!I had never heard of anything such as Quebec Poutine Tots and I am not sure what every ingredient was in it but it was delicious. The entree was just as good... Herbed chicken with risotto may not be the most adventurous item to order but it was amazing! Ate more than I should have. Portions were quite large. I wish I could have dined in the restaurant and viewed the river but I still feel myself lucky to have had such a memorable meal.
1. Devon Seafood + Steak
Overall Ratings
4 based on 240 reviews
Devon Seafood Grill is an upscale seafood restaurant offering simply-prepared fresh fish, premium steaks, an impressive wine cellar and handcrafted cocktails.
Reviewed By Pat N
We visit Devons 4 or 5 times a year. Tonight there was no Wow factor. People that came in after us got their food before we did. The food was good, the server was OK, but it took a really long time for our food to come. Open table asks is the visit is a special event, and it was, but no one mentioned it or asked. By the way it was our 50th Wedding Anniversary. Flet disappointed, for the price I expect more from Devons.
