Location: New Hyde Park
Top Restaurants in New Hyde Park
Most Popular American food in New Hyde Park, New York, United States
Find out what American restaurants to try in New Hyde Park. New Hyde Park is an area that includes the incorporated Village of New Hyde Park in Nassau County, Long Island, New York, United States, as well as surrounding unincorporated areas. The place name, New Hyde Park, and its postal codes, 11040-11099, are used to serve all of these areas.
Things to do in New Hyde Park
10. Starving Artist Cafe & Gallery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 44 reviews
Reviewed By Kate S
The restaurant was interesting enough. The service was awful. We waited a long while to be waited on. As we waited we watched the waitress bringing the wrong order to at least two different tables. We ordered and when our order arrived there were items we ordered missing. The food was mediocre.
9. The Capital Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 270 reviews
Reviewed By k g
My most recent visit to Capital Grille was disappointingly subpar. Having dined here and the Rockefeller location on a few occasions I expected a wonderful dining experience, unfortunately we had the complete opposite experience. I made a reservation for my friends birthday. Capital Grille is normally one of her favorite restaurants, so we figured a shopping trip and dinner would be the perfect way to celebrate. I made a reservation for 7pm, which was confirmed. We arrived promptly and were escorted to a table, we passed a booth (no reserved sign on it) so we asked the hostess if we could sit there. She said she would check and that we could sit there while we waited. She came back and said we didnât reserve a booth so we couldnât have that table??? Hmm, i advises her I had actually asked for a booth when they called to confirm. The hostess replied âokay sit hereâ and walked away. The waiter brought us our menus. We were discussing the drink menu when all of a sudden the male host comes over in a huff saying that we didnât reserve a booth and if we want a booth we have wait in the lobby until one is available! I was shocked by his rudeness and the forcefulness of his statement. I immediately got up and went to the hostess station and asked to speak with the manager. The manager did apologize and we remained at the table, but honestly the entire situation was disappointing. Our waiter Sheik, was wonderful and the food & drinks were good, but after my experience, and with the way we were treated I doubt i will return. With so many other good steak houses on Long Island I will stick with Del Frisco, Tellerâs or Peter Lugers where they value their guests and treat them with respect. If you choose to dine here, please know you must request a booth if you want one, and that you run the risk of being treated rudely. It is incredibly disappointing to hear your friend's birthday experience was overshadowed like that, k g. This was a special evening and we would have wanted everything to be perfect - much like the experiences you mentioned having with us and in Rockefeller in the past. I am thankful we had the opportunity to address things that evening, but wanted to extend this invitation to connect as well. We value you as our guest and hope to do everything we can to restore your confidence. Here is my email address if I can be of any assistance - [email protected] the best.
8. West End Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 213 reviews
I'm surprised you haven't already got this wonderful place listed
Reviewed By davisrich
We planned this dinner to celebrate our youngest daughterâs college graduation. We were a little apprehensive following the GPS to back end of a partially vacant strip mall parking lot only to find a packed parking lot in front of the restaurant, even at nearly 9pm. We were seated immediately and asked for our drink orders. Server was very accommodating letting me taste wines before ordering. Food, especially the steak was superb. Service was excellent though a bit slow at the end which may be due to the fact it was so late. This is a must visit place for both couples, families and friends night out.
7. Nancy's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 65 reviews
Reviewed By mary a
Nancy's is local to us. It is cozy, friendly, and reasonably priced. Their food is always delicious and consistent. Portions are plenty. It is a bit difficult to self park but there is valet available. The only thing I would like is more tap beer and wine by the glass selection. But we always count on Nancy's for a nice time.
6. Floral Park Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 77 reviews
Reviewed By NHBlueBimmer
This was a great place for breakfast - we've been here twice. Food came out in a decent time, was fresh and warm. Lots to order from, and the staff was pleasant without being overbearing. Most tables were on the smaller side (four people), so the noise level was nice and subdued. Don't park out front by the pay meters. There's a free (2 hour) municipal parking lot just around the corner.
5. Jonathan's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 138 reviews
Reviewed By MPG47
We met at Jonathan's, our first time, to have a combined birthdays, anniversary for my brother and his wife. It was a Sunday Brunch. There were about 17 of us. The service was upbeat and friendly. The food came relatively quickly and almost everyone raved about the quality of their fare. I had the fratata and my wife had an omelete . We look forward to our next visit.
4. Swing the Teapot
Overall Ratings
4 based on 104 reviews
In the heart of the village of floral park
Reviewed By truck2chief
Have spend a few fridays and Saturdays over the last fee months here. Comfortable atmosphere and very good food. We enjoyed the music alot alot as well. Highly recommend.
3. Park Place Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 92 reviews
Located on Covert Avenue on the border of Floral Park and Stewart Manor, Park Place Restaurant & Bar has quickly emerged as one of Long Island's top restaurants. Open seven days a week Park Place appeals to everyone --- couples out for a date night, famil
Reviewed By Lejaceman
It might be cliche to say when a restaurant aims to please their clientele and not nickle & dime...customers return many times over. A big local popular restaurant that serves up quality food (not cheap but you really get what you pay for!) Isn't that what we want? Yummy tasting good well made food served out by friendly servers. And yes the people who dine here are nice too. Always a happy hour crowd that really knows how to enjoy their drinks which makes this place fun to go to. This time we were with friends and we had a wonderful time just at the bar. For a quick weeknight meal with some strong drinks of choice makes life so pleasant during a tough work week. Happy Eating and I'll see you around the tables or perhaps only at the bar!
2. Crabtrees Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 231 reviews
Mediterranean/Continental/Restaurant
Reviewed By LITTLESTAR1941
This visit to Crabtrees was our first since it opened. Mediterranean/American style is not my first choice for eating out. But to make the wife happy and our friend happy since it was her birthday and our 50th anniversary. The service is excellent with water being repeatedly refilled and the crumbs removed very quickly. The 1st thing that annoyed me was this pesky fly throughout the whole time we were at the table. No one is going take swats during a meal so I have no solution. The front door is constantly being opened. My 2nd problem (and I know it is my fault), was the vegetables. Each dish comes with mashed potato and a mix of vegetables like yellow and green zucchini, stringbeans, and pieces of broccoli(ugh) and some slices of beets (ugh 2).For starters our friend had the buratta salad and i shared the escargot with wifey. That came in the full shell on a plate of garlic sauce which is what makes this dish so good.For main course our friend had the darla's chicken, wife had the salmon and I had the porterhouse style 16 ounce pork chop. The chop was huge and covered with sauteed peppers and onions. The chop was very good but I probably would have been happier had I stuck with my first thought of getting 2 appetizers and a salad. I studied the menu and really wanted the calamari plate and the escargot with a salad.Appetizers and salads run from $11-15 while most main dishes run in the teens to 30+.When we arrived the place was not too filled but when we left on a Sunday nite , it was packed. If you are still hungry for dessert, get the gelato.
1. The Lantern Diner
Overall Ratings
3 based on 32 reviews
The Lantern Diner is a family-oriented restaurant serving amazing comfort food the right way. Since opening its Doors once again in 2014 under new management, The Lantern Diner has become once again the Landmark of Hempstead, thanks to our beloved communi
Reviewed By 845sherrys
I love burgers but this one looked very nice and was perfect medium rare...but totally dry and difficult to swallow. The rolls on our burgers were huge, but sweet (not s great accompaniment to meat). And they considered charging for fresh onion. Huh? My husbandâs turkey burger deluxe needed a reminder to bring the included onion rings. I must say the fries were fabulous... burning hot, freshly made.
