Location: McHenry
Top Restaurants in McHenry
Most Popular American food in McHenry, Maryland, United States
Reviews on American food in McHenry, Maryland, United States. McHenry is a small community located in Garrett County, Maryland on the northern most shore of Deep Creek Lake.
Things to do in McHenry
10. Greene Turtle Restaurant
Reviewed By Dougiscool
We went there for a late appetizer and a desert. The place was under half full and servers were sitting near the hostess station. We sat in a cavernous room with few people in there. We ordered the appetizer and that came late and our server left before we could order our treat. We waited and waited till she arrived. Against our better judgement we ordered desert. It felt like an eternity before our food arrived. I made the mistake of letting her go and not saying to bring the check. When she finally arrived with that I didnât let her leave until we had the money ready and could leave. We would probably be there if we needed change. The woman said they got really busy.The food was nothing special so we wonât be visiting again. BTW. On our way out the same servers were still hanging out and the place was not even half full.
9. Dutch's at Silver Tree
Overall Ratings
4 based on 410 reviews
Reviewed By SGcvn69
We came for my in-lawâs 50th wedding anniversary luncheon. We had the choice between the lunch menu or the dinner menu, but honestly...nothing looked good. When the food arrived, it did not match how the place was perceived when viewing the website. The food was really overpriced for what you get. I was really disappointed. The place is beautiful though and they do have docks you can park your boat at and an outdoor bar. Beer selection is limited. I would not go back if given the choice.
8. Ace's Run Restaurant & Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 296 reviews
Located at Will O' The Wisp on beautiful Deep Creek Lake withoutside dining, pub area and family dining. Pasta mania every Wednesday Night. Happy Hour in the pub area Sun thru Friday3p.m. to 7p.m.. Full children's menu. Catering and Private Events.
Reviewed By lisag0314
We sat down, when I got a text from my mom to call me. She had the kids, so I stepped away and told my friends to order me a pepsi. I came back 20 minutes later and there was only water for all of us. 10 minutes later, we finally got our drinks. The waitress then took another 20 minutes to get our food order. We asked for bread. There were enough rolls for 7 out of 9 of us. The food came 50 minutes after we placed the order. Luckily the food was good. I definitely recommend going here as I hope that our server just had a bad night. We still tipped her well since there were 9 of us...and we actually did feel like she just wasn't feeling waitressing that night.
7. Smiley's Restaurant and Fun Zone
Overall Ratings
3 based on 154 reviews
Our guests gleam talking about Smiley's Bar & Grill. We embrace our dining independence by offering a wide ranging diversity on the menu. Business diners love our comfortable bar, chock full of local conversation and selections like our Baked Italian sand
Reviewed By ECJoe
We had a very enjoyable meal at Smiley's. When we were looking at the menu on-line, our expectations were that it would be more like Chuck E Cheese, however, that was not the case. The food, service and general decor of the restaurant was great. The restaurant offers tables by the windows which offer nice views of the lake below. The waitress was knowledgeable, friendly and attentive and the food was well prepared and tasty. The menu had something for everyone in our group and is reasonably priced, especially when you purchase combos that include "fun passes" for the fun zone.
6. The Black Bear Tavern and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 319 reviews
Reviewed By Dougiscool
We got steak nachos which I felt were a bit skimpy but the wings made up for it. Very tasty hot wings with oodles or sauce. The place was a bit dark for me but I didnât want to dine outside. The burgers looked great.
5. The Greene Turtle
Overall Ratings
4 based on 105 reviews
Iconic Maryland bar and restaurant serving famous crab dip, fresh & never frozen 100% beef burgers, fan-favorite wings, a $7.99 lunch menu, and a wide selection of local, craft, and specialty beers. Always a good game on TV, and every seat has a good view
Reviewed By Shannon N
We were in need of a quick lunch for a group of 8, and they did excellent! They were not busy at all, but the server was very attentive and the food came very quick and tasted good. Thank you!
4. Perkins Restaurant & Bakery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 168 reviews
Reviewed By clintb766
There are a few chain restaurants in this area, and I normally don't review chains, but this one is exceptional. The variety of food is excellent. Most recently they added Shrimp and Grits as a breakfast choice. Outstanding, and exceeding expectations. The staff is among the best, engaged and prompt, and always willing to accommodate the patron. Clean restrooms, and dinning area, and a no extra cost back room for gatherings and meetings. A go to place for visitors and locals.
3. Pine Lodge Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 489 reviews
Pine Lodge Steakhouse offers freshly prepared food in a casual and relaxed atmosphere. The log interior and many fireplaces make the dining experience feel like a secluded mountain retreat. The views of Deep Creek Lake, especially at sunset, are exception
Reviewed By charliellauren
Tried this place for dinner. Staff was very friendly and the service was excellent, they constantly were checking on us. Hostesses were friendly and helpful in explaining the layout of the restaurant and seating. TV and bar downstairs, traditional restaurant upstairs, same menu in both places. I got a steak and sweet potato, they were good. They accommodate allergies as best they can but no guarantees. Wife got French onion soup, got salty need the bottom of the bowl And couldnât finish it, salad was good. Other couple got southwest chicken salad and ribs - they enjoyed them.
2. Moonshadow
Overall Ratings
4 based on 244 reviews
We are located in McHenry, across from the college. We're a big, happy family here at MoonShadow and we invite you to be a part of it... our eclectic, artsy-comfortable style and of course the mismatched place settings and vintage salt & pepper shakers we
Reviewed By TrackMomof3
We stopped into Moonshadow for lunch. The waitress was so charming. They focus on locally sourced creatively prepared food. I had a steak and brie "sammich". It wasn't really a sandwich but it was so incredibly delicious! The flavors were perfection. My husband had the pork cheek tacos. He was so happy! Rather than fries, we opted for both to be served with a salad. We selected the berry vinegarette dressing. It was so unique and special we asked to buy some to take home. They even gave us the recipe. My only disappointment was that we weren't in town long enough to go back. I would definitely recommend!
1. Mountain State Brewing Co.
Overall Ratings
4 based on 668 reviews
Reviewed By TombGuard320
So happy this place is now here at Deep Creek. Bonus, our home rental was within walking distance. Don't drink and drive (fair warning). The night we went, we watched the police pull 2 patrons over soon after leaving here. We walked!! Must go to!!
