Location: Edgartown
Top Restaurants in Edgartown
Most Popular American food in Edgartown, Massachusetts, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in Edgartown. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you.. Edgartown is a town located on Martha's Vineyard in Dukes County, Massachusetts, United States. The population was 4,067 at the 2010 census. It is the county seat of Dukes County. Edgartown has the largest area in the entirety of Dukes County and Martha's Vineyard.
Things to do in Edgartown
10. Atria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 434 reviews
Reviewed By Sylvia C
I have eaten here twice this summer and both times frustrates by the 'rules'. Ate in the outdoor tent, but they would not serve burger 'inside' the tent. Ok, got it. Went back a week later, sat outside the tent at a table, and here I could not get pizza. Pizza only served inside the tent. Hunh? Asked to speak to manager. Milly came out and was so incredibly rude I was STUNNED! We live down the street and have been coming here for years. Some food is great, other selections mediocre. Calamari, burgers caprese, chicken dinner are great. I wish I could have tried pizza!
9. Chesca's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 298 reviews
Reviewed By christina_stilista
This restaurant was super busy. Great buzz, great food, and good service. The experience is typical Vineyard cool, low ceilings, authentic restored home like environment...and great food! It is not inexpensive but worth every penny. I love the porch out front for a glass of wine before your table is ready too!
8. Lucky Hank's Restaurant & Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 292 reviews
Reviewed By LoveToTravelBoston
We were back at Lucky Hank's with a couple of friends after a year away. Still the same out of the way location - with parking! Still a quiet garden with a restaurant inside, odd paintings and photos on the walls, seating in the back room, and further out on the back porch.We were seated five minutes after our reservation time - no problem. We'd had drinks at home, so only a couple beers were ordered. I was impressed that they had a very nice thick porter that complemented my vegetarian dinner well.But, the food didn't all impress. Yes, my farm share was great, but it was a little small. The lobster deviled eggs were rich and tasty, but not truly special for the money. The sweet potato fries with my friend's ribs were soggy, although the ribs were really wonderfully meaty and savory in their sauce. Salads were fantastic. My wife had Cod cake appetizers as a main, and did enjoy them a lot. Finally, the brownie with ice cream and berries that came with another friend's three course meal was a different kind of brownie - gluten free - but very nice all the same.Service was friendly, but a bit slow, especially with dessert.So, not perfect, but very good. I'm sure we'll still go back.
7. The Port Hunter
Overall Ratings
4 based on 292 reviews
Reviewed By JoeKupe
Owned by local guys who care about the local economy The Port Hunter is a great addition to the Edgartown restaurant scene. We were three for dinner and I had fabulous cod fish tacos while the other two folks enjoyed the Vegatabowl. Each dish was prepared very carefully and was very fresh. The food was delish but the service was at yet another level. The staff is attentive and everyone has a job. Our waters running low, someone is right on it. Dishes need to be cleared, again someone is right on it. Food coming from the kitchen, there are two folks whose job is it to wipe each plate and make sure it looks professional. Want raw oysters, there are two people at the raw bar keeping it fresh and ready all the time. At one point we were curious how low our waters could go before being refilled, they never got below 75%! And it was not to the point of being annoying, it was professional and very well done. They do not take reservations unless you are a party of six; we were three on Monday night and got right in, but we did see lines later in the week. We will return for sure!
6. Seafood Shanty
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1725 reviews
Join us for delicious dining on the beautiful Edgartown Harbor.
Reviewed By travelingman979
Visited here on Columbus Day weekend with my family. It was a nice evening so we got to sit outside and watch the Chappaquidick ferry go back and forth. I ordered the Lobster roll which was filled generously with lobster which had been lightly tossed with mayo and celery. The only issue was the roll wasn't very good and I found the lobster a bit salty. My wife and son tried the shrimp dumplings which were actually japanese style shumai and both liked them enough to order it a second time. My son also ordered a salmon sushi roll which he found to be quite tasty as well. The service was attentive but unobstrusive. Overall, a nice restaurant with something that will please almost anyone looking for a decent, reasonably (for MV) priced seafood meal.
5. The Terrace at The Charlotte Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 211 reviews
Experience sumptuous dining on Marthaâs Vineyard at The Terrace restaurant at Edgartownâs Charlotte Inn, a member of the internationally renowned Relais & Châteaux luxury hotels and restaurants. The Terraceâs menu fuses classic American cuisine with Itali
Reviewed By Beluga4162
We love the charming atmosphere every inch of this house. Excellent meal and delicious ingredients that are always fresh. Nice waiters and quiet dining. Will absolutely be returning on our next visit!
4. l'etoile
Overall Ratings
4 based on 396 reviews
Located in the heart of downtown Edgartown, l'etoile offers a casually elegant dining and bar experience l'étoile is a vibrant modern restaurant located in a restored historic whaling captain's house on the island of Martha's Vineyard. Chef-owned & operat
Reviewed By travelingirlfrompa
We ate outside in the tent, service was very good, food was good - very flavorful! Beautiful outside area/yard.
3. Among The Flowers Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 705 reviews
Reviewed By Diver4comm
So glad we could fit this delight into our first visit to MV! A delightful collection of indoor & outdoor seating on a gorgeous morning - literally among the flowers of their planters. Delicious mushroom & boursin omelette... mimosas also available
2. Detente Restaurant and Wine Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 251 reviews
Détente, is a modern seasonal kitchen in downtown Edgartown, located on the beautiful island of Martha's Vineyard. By working with local farmers and fisherman we offer you the freshest products. Our menu, which changes frequently, features inventive Ameri
Reviewed By boston65
We loved our dinner here. Cocktails at the small bar were excellent, and then we ate in the very pretty patio. The food was excellent, especially the peach salad appetizer., and the lime semifedo capped off the night . Excellent, well priced wine list. A really great choice for a peaceful and intimate dinner. What great selections, we're so glad you enjoyed it. Thank you!
1. Martha's Vineyard Chowder Company
Overall Ratings
4 based on 911 reviews
BEST CHOWDER IN NEW ENGLAND FROM YANKEE MAGAZINE, BEST CHOWDER 2015 from CAPE & ISLANDS MAGAZINE, MV MAGAZINE and winner of the 2015 MV CHOWDER CONTEST!! - Copper and mahogany grace our nautically chic dining room creating a casual-fine dining atmosphere.
Reviewed By Kristine G
The chowder was perfectly madeâright amount of salt, perfectly cut potatoes, perfectly diced clams. My husband had the lobster roll and I had shrimp cocktail. Not the best shrimp cocktail Iâve ever had, but not bad. The lobster roll was delicious. They have a really good bar with great drink selectionsâwines, beers, vodkas, and tequilas. Checked out the loft upstairs and it was hopping. We left to get Backdoor Donuts, but would return to play darts, pool, etc. Great place.
