Location: Jamaica
Top Restaurants in Jamaica
Best Pizza food near Jamaica, New York, United States
Best Pizza restaurants nearby. Discover the best Pizza food in Jamaica. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Pizza restaurants near you.. Jamaica is a middle-class neighborhood in the New York City borough of Queens. The neighborhood is part of Queens Community Board 12, which also includes Hollis, St. Albans, Springfield Gardens, Baisley Pond Park, Rochdale Village, and South Jamaica. The NYPD's 103rd, 113th & 105th Precincts patrol Jamaica.
Things to do in Jamaica
10. Pizza Classica
Overall Ratings
4 based on 53 reviews
Reviewed By TheSushiGuy
Pizza Classica has been a favorite guys night out destination for us for the past 9 years. Our group of 5 visits this establishment to enjoy their great food and experience their great service. Service was not great tonight. I felt we were ignored the entire evening. Getting drink refills tonight was like pulling teeth. We only saw our server when he took the order, once when we flagged him down for a refill, and when the check was dropped. Definitely, not the experience we anticipated. Never had such Subpar service here. Our group met 13 years ago working as waiters in a catering hall. We know hospitality and still tipped 20%. Maybe our server had an off night.We started with rice balls and wings. Both were very good. Wings were slightly spicy and crispy. As an entree, the three of us split a Chicken Caesar Pizza. It was as good as usual with plenty of grilled chicken. For dessert, I had Italian Cheesecake with coffee. It was a perfect cup of coffee! I would love to know the brand. The Italian Cheesecake was decadent, very light and creamy with a hint of orange.The food quality ended up saving this review from a "Poor" rating. Hopefully, next visit will have better service. I think it was a one off. We would tip 30% for great service. All in all, check this place out for dinner. You cannot go wrong.
9. Romeo Pizzeria
Reviewed By NYCSkippy
We (the family) ordered two pizzas yesterday for take out! The pizzas were still hot when we got the home and everyone loved the crispy crust, the loads of cheese and ample amounts of pepperoni and mushrooms. We will order again soon!
8. Sofia's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 46 reviews
Reviewed By 1travelingGuy
Queens has some great pizza places ; Sofias is Not one of them . Pizza crust is like a doughy sponge and sauce does Not have that real Italian taste . being a native New Yorker - I can Not brag about this restaurant on the contrary I recommend U pass on a slice of this sub par Pizza.
7. Gaby's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 50 reviews
Gabyâs Pizza, located in the Fran Hill Mall on Hillside Avenue and Francis Lewis Boulevard, is consistently ranked year after year among the Top 10 Pizzerias in New York. Gabyâs Pizza represented New York City on the Rachael Ray show to compete against Ch
Reviewed By Natasha C
Scammers! They advertise different prices on their website but then when you order, they increase the prices. Either update the website OR honor the price that is advertised. Thereâs plenty of other pizzeria with better customer service and people skills.
6. Pizza Port
Overall Ratings
4 based on 44 reviews
Reviewed By west0909
An overnight layover at JFK, my hotel receptionist (Delilah at Hampton Inn) suggested Pizza Port for free delivery and great NYC pizza. I called to order around 7:45p on a Friday (no CC option, all cash). 45 minutes for delivery (great for a Friday) and after a day of travel I was starving. Sadly, the garlic knots were stone cold (I'm not sure they were ever "warm" to be honest). As disappointing as that was, the pizza was delicious and just what I needed (made it through half a small by myself and I'm not even sorry b/c it was THAT good). Awesome pizza and fast-ish delivery, netted out with deeply disappointing garlic knots brings this rating to a 3-star (but with a lot of upside potential if they figure out how to deliver warm food).
5. Nick's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 146 reviews
Nick's Pizza Forest Hills has been serving up thin crust pizzas & calzones for over 20 years. Melty mozzarella and fresh ingredients in Forest Hills, NY.
Reviewed By Gary P K
I had no problem with the food, but I had a problem with the manner of service that I received. I asked him to have some wider width lemon wedges for my water so that I could squeeze them into my water. Well, he refused to go into the kitchen to cut a lemon the way I wanted. He also refused to get me a lemon from the kitchen so that I may cut it myself. All I was left with was these non-squeezable really thin lemon slices that absolutely did nothing. These lemon wedges are a garnish, whereas, I should have never been denied these lemon wedges for my water. A very reasonable garnish request from a guest inside of Nick's having dinner should have never be denied. This is the cost of doing business, an extremely small cost, mind you. My bill was $40.00 Good service means as much as the food!!Gary, rest assured you're right to expect outstanding service here -- I'm truly sorry for any miscommunication on our end regarding your lemon wedges. It's great to know you enjoyed the food overall, and I hope you'll have another opportunity to join us for a visit sometime soon. You can always expect a warm welcome here.All the best,Gus, Owner
Where to eat Caribbean food in Jamaica: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Aldo's II Pizzeria and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 59 reviews
Reviewed By Ron T
I'm in Howard Beach a lot, and am beyond tired of the Italian eateries there. Variable food, claustrophobic seating, high noise levels, wait staff that are great at ignoring you and forgetting what you asked for. We found Aldo's by accident. And unlike most reviewers, we made it into the dining room. Out front is a pizza place with quick service. In back is Italian dining, with every single thing we've tried being very good or better, with warm, friendly service, and on our last visit, a live singer (Italian and American easy listening favorites). I've had their veal parm - tender, tasty, and on this visit, lentil vegetable soup - among the best I've ever had, Osso Buco - a special that night, wonderful, over creamy risotto. I couldn't finish it all, so I had the leftovers the next day, still amazing. My wife had another special, sole with crabmeat stuffing. I won't touch most fish unless thin, crispy fried (think LJS) but the fish was very good and the stuffing even better! ONLY thing uninspiring , the mussels. They are in bad need of a lot more garlic! Overall, as a group we are beyond finicky - and we all enjoyed our meal!One note - up front, getting pizza, I'm sure it's inexpensive. Get a dish like mine, not so much. But I did get 2 meals out of it, and enjoyed every last scrap!So ignore reviews from a couple years ago by people stuck at Days Inn or JFK who didn't like what they had. I gather that management changed at some point; one way or another, the arrogant Italian eateries in HB down Cross Bay could learn a lot from the food and service here!
3. Gino's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 105 reviews
Reviewed By gv342
Great Italian food and pizza. Everything is good there. I typically order pizza for pizza night. Although there are many excellent dishes, my personal favorite is File of Sole Franchese.
Most Popular Seafood food in Jamaica, New York, United States
2. Margherita Pizza Incorporated
Overall Ratings
5 based on 36 reviews
Reviewed By JetteEatsandTravels
If you've never had NYC pizza, I suggest you try this first. The pizza is thin crust and comes to you piping hot, super cheesy and salty!! (Perfect pizza combo in my humble opinion) The place is small and you have to stand at the counter to order, but they move quickly and get you in and out in about 5 minutes on most days. Definitely worth a try when you're in town!
1. New Park Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 189 reviews
Reviewed By LollysLook
In a city of great pizza, itâs hard to stand out. New Pizza Pizzeria has been in business for over 60 years and is an old time favorite with great pizza. They serve the crust crispy with fresh sauce and cheese. Itâs perfect.
