Location: Holtsville
Top Restaurants in Holtsville
Top Things to do in Holtsville
- 1. The Escape Room Game Long Island
- 2. Holtsville Ecology Site
- 3. Fire Island National Seashore
- 4. Regal Cinemas Ronkonkoma Stadium 9 Movie Theater
- 5. Country Fair Entertainment Park
- 6. The Pennysaver Amphitheater
- 7. 1940's Brewing Company
- 8. Tiki Action Park
- 9. Padlocked Inc
- 10. Island 16 Cinema De Lux
Best Italian food near Holtsville, New York, United States
Reviews on Italian food in Holtsville, New York, United States. Holtsville is a hamlet and census-designated place (CDP) in Suffolk County, New York, United States. The population was 19,714 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Holtsville
10. Gino's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 44 reviews
Reviewed By Hardrocker8888
I was looking to have pizza for lunch and I came across Ginoâs. They had a wide selection of already made pizza. But you can personalize one if you want. They pizza was great. The staff was friendly.
9. Carlo's Pizza Oven
Reviewed By vegman58
Living in Holbrook for 30 Years, stopped in This Pizza/Bar Lounge, The Pizza Was Excellent! I have not Tried Anything Else, But Is One of My Favorites for Pizza! Nice Bar Lounge right Next To Pizzeria, Very Friendly and Great Service! They also Deliver! Great Job.
8. Pizza Stop
Overall Ratings
5 based on 15 reviews
Reviewed By Susaneac
I have been going to this pizza shop since it opened when I was a kid. Growing up, my dad took my brother and I every Thursday night while mom worked. We have known all of the owners. I am now living in another town but still choose to come here. The food is always fresh and the staff always friendly. Highly recommend the broccoli wheels and calzones. The pizza is great too!
7. Caffe Amici
Overall Ratings
4 based on 180 reviews
Get amazing deals at Caffe Amici. We've been providing delicious dishes. We offer a variety of affordable deals every day. Watch out for our promos! Located in Independence plaza in Selden, NY
Reviewed By Searturefor1969
Stephen & Tania were perfect hosts. I headed to Caffe Amici primarily because of excellent reviews for their pizza. I was torn as I saw Pasta Carbonara was on their special board. Stephen told me I could have the Carbonara any night if I just asked for it. I had the Salami pizza and it was everything the reviews said. When I asked for crushed red pepper for the pizza Tania brought me fresh diced hot peppers in oil she said her mom grows. It was the best hot pepper I'd ever had on a pizza! It was clear they are passionate about their food and their small, intimate restaurant. Their friendliness and hospitality was second to none. It's not fancy, not big, and certainly not pretentious. It's just excellent Italian food prepared and served with love.
6. Medford Pastaria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 114 reviews
Reviewed By HannahLee123
Excellent eggplant anything (parmigiana and rollatini). Nice restaurant ambiance and service for local casual dining in strip mall.
5. Ralph's Italian Ice
Reviewed By Matthew R
We go alot over the summer. The kids love the stuff there. Not open all year around. Definitly could be alittle cheaper byt overall its decent. I like there ices but carvel still has better ice cream.
4. Rio Douro Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 34 reviews
Reviewed By tmginnova
We were traveling to central Long Island for a family event, looking for a nearby decent place to eat. Originally thought Italian, but found this gem, and were happy we did.Attractive interior, and very thoughtful, informative service. They helped guide us to a wonderful steak dish, cooked on hot rocks as I recall, succulent. My wife's fish was good, not quite as exceptional.We also shared a huge, savory salad.An excellent Portuguese red wine, selected with the waiter's help.And leftovers for later lunch.What's not to like?
3. Joe's Restaurant & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 48 reviews
Reviewed By chumley_11
Great pizza...their sauce is like grandma used to make...entrees excellent..like old time Italian meals...small area in the back for eating a sit down dinner...will return !
2. Mama's Pizza Pasta & Seafood
Overall Ratings
4 based on 70 reviews
Reviewed By Earth2Sea2Sky
Went there for dinner one Friday eve in Nov 2018. Had heard this restaurant was good, but it wasn't very crowded, so wondered how good it was. Surprisingly it was very good. Attentive service w/personable wait staff. Good size portions and reasonable prices. Ate @ their Centereach location & it wasn't as good as this location.
What to do and see in Holtsville, United States: The Best Places and Tips
1. Mamma Lombardi's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 273 reviews
Reviewed By Travel50StatesUSA
"Mamma Lombardi's Restaurant" on Furrows Road in Holbrook has been "the place" to go for Italian food for decades. The food is absolutely delicious, and the portions are huge. Most diners go home with enough leftovers for the next night's dinner at home!! The service is both efficient and friendly. The ambience in the dining room is perfect for a special night out. If you haven't been to "Mamma Lombardi's Restaurant" as yet, I highly recommend you plan to go in the near future.
Holtsville Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Holtsville
