Location: East Durham
Top Restaurants in East Durham
Best Italian food near East Durham, Durham, New York
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in East Durham. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. Coordinates: 42°22′21″N 74°05′44″W / 42.37250°N 74.09556°W / 42.37250; -74.09556
Things to do in East Durham
6. Millrock Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 136 reviews
Located in the Great Northern Catskills, Millrock is a lively restaurant inspired by Italian traditions and rustic American roots. Millrock opened in the fall of 1996 and is located on historic Main Street Windham. Since then, Millrock has been committed
Reviewed By FromJersey123
My sweetheart and I enjoyed a nice meal our first night in the Catskills. The penne with vodka sauce was fair. It was tasty, but not anything special. We shared a chicken marsala too. That was also tasty, but not unique, exceptionally good or memorable. So, if you're looking for good service with a decent, Italian meal in a casual setting, consider Mill Rock Restaurant. However, don't have high expectations. I've had better Italian food, but I've also had much worse. So, I guess this place was average. However, the waiter was a nice young man and he worked hard and was quite pleasant.
5. Messina's LaGriglia Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 105 reviews
Reviewed By Slc498
This restaurant lacked everything. There were only a few tables with people upon my arrival, but they had a hard time deciding which table to give me. When people came after me and the waitress had to choose which table to give them, she often uttered a curse word while deciding where they should sit. At no point was the place more than half full (at any given point there were about 6 tables with people). I was alone, most tables had two people with two waitresses. Almost never could I find my waitress and whenever I did she kept telling me she will be right over to me. At one point, I was tempted to get my own water because I waited about 15 mins with an empty glass but ended up calling over the overwhelmed other waitress dealing with her three tables of people. Food was edible. I got Grandmaâs spaghetti and meatballs but asked for angel hair which I was told was great. Well, andpparently no one wanted to tell grandma her cooking is bad, I couldnât eat most of it. I waited about 25 mins for the check to find out they charged me $2 extra for angel hair. After waiting almost 15 mins for the waitress to return, I finally got up and went to her. She asked the manager what to do about the $2 charge that I was not made aware of. The manager asked if I complained, the waitress said yes, and the manager responded to the waitress that she should tell me to âscrewâ myself but she took it off my bill. Would not be returning here again.Lots of made up drama. it is hard to believe the experience was that bad. Sounds like someone was having a bad day. I am from Coram N.Y 53 Andover Drive right off of Route 112.
4. Vince Anna's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 48 reviews
Reviewed By petersD1632KA
We arrived shortly after opening, at 5:00.We were greeted nicely and seated.The service, overall, was prompt and friendly.My wife had the shrimp cocktail appetizer. Four large, fresh shrimp and the cocktail sauce was just right. Not too spicy and not too bland.The salads were fresh. The blue cheese dressing was kind of mayonaise-ish. Really the only disappointment in a very good meal.The gluten free pasta with white clam sauce was very good.I had the chicken cacciatore. It was delicious!I look forward to our next visit.
3. Vesuvio Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 164 reviews
Mountain Top Fine Italian Dining Restaurant Proudly Women Owned Business Serving From 4 Decades Makes You feel Home
Reviewed By lunarscape
We stopped for dinner and the place is in disrepair. Maybe they are the process of rebuilding. The staff was extremely rude and seemed to enjoy making travelers feel unwelcome. Do yourself a favor and skip this joint.Thankyou for coming to the restaurant and letting us know what you experienced in my restaurant And I personally apologize for the service. I would like you to come to Restaurant again And would like to offer you a dinner on me please
2. Angel's East Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By Jeff B
Stopped for lunch. Quite a few chooses for meals. Chose the Italian sub. Good sized portion, came with fries. I was only able to eat half the sub and most of the fries. The other two in the party were also unable to finish their meals. So great value for what you get. Service was fairly quick. I thought the prices were very reasonable. Would definitely go again.
1. Messina's LaGriglia Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 105 reviews
Reviewed By Slc498
This restaurant lacked everything. There were only a few tables with people upon my arrival, but they had a hard time deciding which table to give me. When people came after me and the waitress had to choose which table to give them, she often uttered a curse word while deciding where they should sit. At no point was the place more than half full (at any given point there were about 6 tables with people). I was alone, most tables had two people with two waitresses. Almost never could I find my waitress and whenever I did she kept telling me she will be right over to me. At one point, I was tempted to get my own water because I waited about 15 mins with an empty glass but ended up calling over the overwhelmed other waitress dealing with her three tables of people. Food was edible. I got Grandmaâs spaghetti and meatballs but asked for angel hair which I was told was great. Well, andpparently no one wanted to tell grandma her cooking is bad, I couldnât eat most of it. I waited about 25 mins for the check to find out they charged me $2 extra for angel hair. After waiting almost 15 mins for the waitress to return, I finally got up and went to her. She asked the manager what to do about the $2 charge that I was not made aware of. The manager asked if I complained, the waitress said yes, and the manager responded to the waitress that she should tell me to âscrewâ myself but she took it off my bill. Would not be returning here again.Lots of made up drama. it is hard to believe the experience was that bad. Sounds like someone was having a bad day. I am from Coram N.Y 53 Andover Drive right off of Route 112.
