Location: Bay Village
Top Restaurants in Bay Village
Best Italian food near Bay Village, Ohio, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Bay Village, Ohio, United States. Bay Village is a city located west of Cleveland Ohio in Cuyahoga County, Ohio, United States. The population was 15,651 at the 2010 census. Bay Village is located in Ohio's 9th congressional district.
Things to do in Bay Village
10. Fratello's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 146 reviews
Reviewed By torinash
When Fratelloâs opened nearly thirty years ago, I was a restaurant critic for a newspaper and hungry for a new restaurant in my lakeside community. Little did I know that this Italian eatery, housed unpretentiously in a former Lawson Milk Store, would turn out to be the intimate, classy and extremely fine restaurant it was. And little did I know that all these years later it would still be the fine restaurant it was - only better. Over the years the offerings have been enhanced, but the dishes that made Fratellos a hit back then, that built its faithful customer base and word of mouth trade, are still there: Chicken Fratello, Veal Fratello, with their signature and luscious lemon butter sauce; their slightly tangy house marinara sauce, and veal saltimbocca, to name a few. What Fratellos has mastered is the fine art of consistency: consistently fine food, fine service, fine wines and a fine ambiance where guests donât have to worry about ever being disappointed. Go once, but be prepared to return again and again.
9. D'Italia Foods
Reviewed By lwoods55
This place is perfect for anything Italian. Whether your looking to pick up a quick lunch, need help picking out some dinner already prepared or for some shopping for a special occasion. Everything is authentic and tastes amazing! It's a family owned place and the people are extremely friendly and helpful. The best part of it all is its affordable! Amazing food at great prices, now I'm sold! I constantly crave their chicken Parmesan sub, it's absolutely to die for. I love this place.
8. Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 71 reviews
Enjoy a stroll along the shores of Lake Erie then come to Buca on Detroit Road to enjoy all of your favorite Italian entrees. From the moment you walk into your Westlake, OH Buca, you know you are going to be well taken care of. Our chefs are busily creat
Reviewed By DealScout
Celebrated my grandsonâs HS graduation at BdB today. With a group of 12 I ordered three main entrees, a large pizza, fried mozz, a couple sides and mozzarella bread. Everyone had their fill, and plenty of leftovers.The food ranged from very good to fair. Chicken Fettuccine and the Brussel sprouts were very good. The chicken saltiboca was tasty, but chicken was not tender. The mozz bread was fair, at best....not worth the money, even if it had been better. They let us bring our own cake and provided plates and forks. If we would have had them serve the cake another $15 would have been tacked onto the bill. I appreciate that they told us do we could make the choice. Service was great, our server, Fallen did an excellent job taking care of our group. The place needs some updating and done cleaning. We sat in the Pope room and it was gross how sticky the floors were.
7. La Campagna
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By Bellojoseph
Dined here last evening with a couple of friends and I honestly don't know why I haven't been here before. This is a small, quaint restaurant that delivers personalize service and exceptional food. We started with an appetizer that was a combination of soft cheeses with a fig jam on top and came with these delicate and delicious crackers to spread the cheese on. What a great start! Two of us had a salad and one had the soup of the day, Paese, a garlic and onion broth with a semi-poached egg and pasta She really enjoyed it. Between the three of us we have the linguine and clams, lemon sole stuffed with crab meat and a ravioli dish that highlighted 3 of their sauces. The dinners were amazing!!!! Fresh, cooked to order and delicious. They have a very nice wine selection that is reasonably priced. Carmella, Joe and Keely provided wonderful service and we will definitely return!
6. BRIO Tuscan Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 248 reviews
Come join us for a quick meal or a complete, exquisite dinner with friends. Live the best Tuscan dinning experience at BRIO Tuscan Grille in Crocker Park Village! Join us at BRIO Tuscan Grille, the best Italian restaurant near you!
Reviewed By ColoAvsPuckhead
Located in Crocker Park - easily accessible, parking tower nearby, valet parking along Main Street, some street parking. Greeted promptly and seated promptly for weekday lunch. Ambiance was pleasant and sound level okay, though not too busy a little after peak lunch hour. Menu was good and diverse with special lunch section that included small entrees, soups, and salads. Waitress was excellent - pleasant, appropriately attentive, and happy. All of our items were very good - lobster bisque, shrimp capri pasta, and various salads. Would definitely go again.
5. Vento Tratorria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 57 reviews
Reviewed By JimO80
We had the antipasto board and the cheese board to start. Lovely arrangements of nuts, fruit, cheeses and condiments. The Malbec was smooth and tasty. They didn't have Bacardi Silver, only Capt. Morgan Spiced Rum...bummer. Don't believe the claims the sauteed calamari was tasteless...on the contrary, they were wonderful and tasteful with garlic, parsley and butter wine sauce. Yum. Calamari was cooked perfectly, not rubbery.
4. Carrabba's Italian Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 143 reviews
Reviewed By Jeanette D
I enjoyed everything, from the bread and dipping oil, Italian salad and Eggplant Parmesan. I always enjoy eating at this place. The owner always checks in on us to make sure we are enjoying everything. The servers are very attentive and accommodating. The place smells wonderful from the minute you step inside.
3. Gina's Pizza
Overall Ratings
5 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By skinnycrissy
If you are looking for a pizza place that offers a wide variety of fresh toppings, Gina's has an enormous selection! Just a few of those toppings include broccoli, spinach, artichokes, roasted cauliflower, basil and more! Gina the owner is very friendly and recently prepared pizzas for our fund raiser. She is open for lunch and sells pizza by the slice which I just discovered. I wish Gina delivered daily or even if she offered it just on weekends, but she did delivery for our fund raiser which was nearby. I'm so glad to have a "mom and pop" pizza place in Bay!
2. Arrabiata's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 75 reviews
Reviewed By Riverliver
The restaurant is inviting, and the service excellent. But the food is just average. There is nothing special here about Italian food. We had the chicken cacciatore and the eggplant Parmesan, and both were nothing special. The eggplant parm was soggy - I donât think it had been breaded at all. The chicken cacciatore was OK - with a sauce that was just average. The best part of the meal was the side of linguine with oil and garlic - plenty of garlic made this yummy. The mean came with a nice size side salad and bread and coffee. We were there for the early bird specials, so the value was pretty good ($12 for the meal). We ordered an appetizer of calamari and this too was just average. So we wonât be going back here again.
What to do and see in Bay Village, United States: The Best Places and Tips
1. Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 71 reviews
Enjoy a stroll along the shores of Lake Erie then come to Buca on Detroit Road to enjoy all of your favorite Italian entrees. From the moment you walk into your Westlake, OH Buca, you know you are going to be well taken care of. Our chefs are busily creat
Reviewed By DealScout
Celebrated my grandsonâs HS graduation at BdB today. With a group of 12 I ordered three main entrees, a large pizza, fried mozz, a couple sides and mozzarella bread. Everyone had their fill, and plenty of leftovers.The food ranged from very good to fair. Chicken Fettuccine and the Brussel sprouts were very good. The chicken saltiboca was tasty, but chicken was not tender. The mozz bread was fair, at best....not worth the money, even if it had been better. They let us bring our own cake and provided plates and forks. If we would have had them serve the cake another $15 would have been tacked onto the bill. I appreciate that they told us do we could make the choice. Service was great, our server, Fallen did an excellent job taking care of our group. The place needs some updating and done cleaning. We sat in the Pope room and it was gross how sticky the floors were.
Bay Village Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Bay Village
