Top Restaurants in Palmyra
Top Things to do in Palmyra
Best American food near Palmyra, New York, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in Palmyra. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you. including Yellow Mills Diner, Athenia Restaurant, Pulcini's Farm Market And Ice Cream, West Wayne Restaurant, J & K's Family Restaurant, Macedon Hills Restaurant, Finger Lakes Casino - Vineyard Buffet
Things to do in Palmyra
7. Finger Lakes Casino - Vineyard Buffet
Overall Ratings
4 based on 220 reviews
Reviewed By mamaknows
I used to always rave about this buffet, but was supremely disappointed when I went on MLK Day. A special of 2 for $25 was advertised, but it really was not that special. Popcorn shrimp, dried looking Mexican food, mislabeled Asian food, and a salad bar that lacked a lot vegetables. The desserts have changed and it's been more than a year since I've been here. I
6. Macedon Hills Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 74 reviews
Reviewed By Larry W
This is always a consistently-good restaurant that serves up the basics, especially at breakfast. I had my standard breakfast, which is pancakes with sausage patties and sugar-free syrup. They have it out in no time, and the server is always ready to refill your coffee mug. breakfast for all that is around $11.00. I do recommend this place.
5. J & K's Family Restaurant
Reviewed By Senseiyukidaruma
Always a good place to visit for a good meal. breakfast and dinner. Not fancy but good waitstaff and a good value.
4. West Wayne Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By Larry W
Once again, this diner/restaurant put on a great breakfast for me at the counter seating. I enjoyed a nice portion of pancakes and sausage patties for under eight dollars! Wow! Everything was perfectly done, and two pancakes is enough hereâ¦they a very big! I highly recommend this spot on Route 31 for breakfast any day of the week.
3. Pulcini's Farm Market And Ice Cream
We offer large portions of ice cream for the ice cream lover in you. We also offer a toddler cone for children four years old and younger. We are located in a country setting with plenty of parking. At Pulcini's we offer outdoor seating and air conditione
Reviewed By 893kim
Love this place. The sundaes are amazing. The specialty sundaes are 4 scoops, with numerous toppings. They also sell fresh produce and various little souvenir items, tshirts, picture frames etc. This is a family run business and everyone is always friendly.Great prices also!
2. Athenia Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 44 reviews
Reviewed By Craig G
I was on the way to Canandaigua for a 4 mile walk and stopped here. I was expecting good Greek food, but very limited to Gyros or Chicken Souvlaki. The owners are Greek. I ordered their Haddock dinner instead. Very good portion and taste. Great selection of diner food. Service was great. They have tried to offer more Greek specialties, but the locals don't seem to go for the ethnic food; they like mostly American choices.
1. Yellow Mills Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 84 reviews
Reviewed By CaptnGphs
This is an old-fashioned brick and mortar diner that was common in 1950. Lots of seating in booths and tables. Standard diner fare. I had the fish fry (battered haddock) with O rings, coleslaw and salad. All the food was acceptable; no standouts. Prices were a bit high - maybe the new minimum wage (can't be the rent).
