Location: Margaretville
Top Restaurants in Margaretville
Best American food near Margaretville, New York, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in Margaretville. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you.. Margaretville is a village in Delaware County, New York, United States. The population was 596 at the 2010 census. The village is in the town of Middletown, on the border of the Catskill Park.
Things to do in Margaretville
9. Two Old Tarts
Overall Ratings
4 based on 62 reviews
Two Old Tarts serves comfort food to fit nearly every mood. We serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner with beer and wine available. We also serve fresh baked goods, coffee, espresso, and fine pressed teas.
Reviewed By TheTravelgirl2
We made reservations a few hours early on a Friday night, but there were plenty of tables on arrival. Some nights are crowded...it just depends, so it's better to be safe than sorry.The New York strip was cooked perfectly and they gladly substituted a vegetable medley for the usual potato for my husband, who's on a low-carb diet. The spinach souffle was more dense than one would expect, but was decent.The Pickled beet and Goat Cheese salad was delicious! Portion size was average not a small plate- but not a large, filling salad either (although I didn't add the chicken or shrimp.) I should've ordered soup to go with it. Their bread, served with olive oil and balsamic vinegar was also very good. Had to resist dessert, but visited the adjoining room where their many baked goods were on display- they looked very moist and appetizing!Acoustics kind of bounced voices and sounds around the dining room...no carpet or curtains, etc to absorb the noise. Not a big deal- just happened to notice. Service by the owners was warm, friendly, and efficient. So glad we dined here!
8. Outsiders Kitchen + Cafe
Bringing cafe fare with a creative twist to our little corner of the Catskills! Utilizing time-honored family recipes with an injection of newly inspired flavors, our kitchen team spends their days making from-scratch soups and salads, creatively crafting
Reviewed By Texasgirl0915
Stopped for a quick lunch over the weekend and we (all big city out of towners) were all impressed. Sandwiches, salads, soup and wraps were available. Order at the counter and the high quality food comes out very fast. Small dining area but the tables turn fairly quickly. Also seems to be a local take-away favorite.
7. Summerfields
Overall Ratings
4 based on 84 reviews
Reviewed By Kelly L
My friends and I were skiing up at Bellayre during the week and we were having trouble finding restaurants that were open later on a Tuesday night and open in bad weather. We were so excited to find out Summerfield's was open and we headed there in 4 wheel drive!Luckily for us, it was taco Tuesday and there were about 7 types of small individual tacos we could mix and match for 2 to 3 dollars each! It made my cold and snowy day! The tacos were great! I loved the chicken bacon ranch one the most! Aside from local beers, they also had local cider so we were excited beyond belief!We are so happy to hear about your dining experience and hope to see you soon! Thankyou
6. Arkville Bread & Breakfast
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Kitchen & some seating located in a Caboose with separate Dining Room, Outdoor Deck & Porch seating.
Reviewed By Cyn H
I've become addicted to this quirky, cute caboose and their delicious breakfast! If you get the chance to try the homemade corned beef hash, do it! You won't be disappointed.
5. Bun N' Cone
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By Denise P
I have visited Bun N' Cone many times over the years and there food and ice cream are always fresh. The price is reasonable and the staff is always friendly .
4. Binnekill Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 15 reviews
Reviewed By carolann257
Consistently delicious comfort food in a welcoming atmosphere. Beautiful copper fireplace in dining room and comfortable seating in the rustic bar area. Nice menu selection along with creative cocktails, all served by friendly and attentive staff. Favorite dishes include Shrimp & Grits, Pork Belly, Salmon with Blood Orange Glaze, Mushroom Salad with Walnuts & Fennel, Coconut Shrimp, Pork Schnitzel (Monday is Schnitzel night) and Blackberry Stuffed French Toast served during Sunday Brunch. Looking forward to warm weather to enjoy outdoor seating on the deck overlooking the stream!
3. Oakleys Place
Overall Ratings
4 based on 105 reviews
Woodfired Pizza & Wood Grill Burgers & Chicken Sandwiches Also Shrimp and Steamed Clams
Reviewed By Katie F
Everything at Oakleyâs was delicious! The atmosphere and the staff are very welcoming and all smiles. The owner walks around to make sure his customers are happy with the food and the service. Overall had a wonderful experience and definitely will be back!! Definitely recommend to anyone to stop in and grab a bite!
2. Inn Between Steak & Seafood Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 49 reviews
Reviewed By A1shopper
We where staying at the Roxbury hotel and they suggested this place. We went last night and everyoneâs food was amazing. We got the duck, filet mignon with Merlot sauce, surf and turf. The mashed potatoes and brown gravy where delicious. Our waitress was amazing and I wish I knew her name but she is from the Bronx and had us laughing the entire meal. A great dinner and would highly recommend.
1. Crazy River Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 59 reviews
Reviewed By Grandpear
While heading south through the Catskills, we happened upon this restaurant so decided to give it a try as we had been driving for awhile.You just never know about these so called âcafesâ. Maybe itâs just me, but in many cases, they seem to offer smaller sized portions as opposed to pubs or restaurants. Well, not in this case. I had a really delicious Reuben that easily satisfied my large appetite. My grandson had a huge bacon burger, he saved half of for our continued ride, and my wife had a really tasty chicken sandwich. My granddaughter had a hot dog with a side of perfectly cooked onion rings. Man were they good. Nice clean place all around. We sat on the outside deck and the co-owner, clearing tables, was very friendly to us. He said his wife did the cooking and their goal was to give plenty of good food for a reasonable price. I think theyâve achieved their goal and then some.
