10 Top-Rated Bed and Breakfast Inns in Long Island, New York

May 28, 2023 Harland Bartelt

Discover the best Bed and Breakfast Inns in Long Island, New York including Mill House Inn, East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast, The Hedges Inn, House on Chase Creek, Mill House Inn, Aqua by American Beech, East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast, Rockville Centre Hotel, The Stirling House Inn, Jones Beach Hotel.
Things to do in Long Island

1. Mill House Inn

31 N Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937-2601 1 (631) 392-7166
Excellent
84%
Good
8%
Satisfactory
3%
Poor
1%
Terrible
4%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 373 reviews

Mill House Inn

Casual luxury in the heart of East Hampton Village. Just steps to spectacular dining, shopping, galleries and the world’s best ocean beaches. MHI is The Hamptons B&B that Zagat’s named one of the Top 50 Small Hotels in the USA. Your Personal Assistant will provide world-class service and promise ‘to help you travel better’ and we always keep our promise's. Our farm to table breakfast was awarded a 28 by Zagat’s and Google says we deserve 4.5 Stars. Our beautiful rooms and expansive suites have private decks, soaking tubs, steam showers, flat screen HD TV’s and fireplaces, many are child and dog friendly. They may tempt you to spend the day perfecting the art of doing nothing, curled up in your living room watching a classic movie or finishing that novel sipping wine by the fire. It would be our pleasure to show you the MHI Art of Hospitality, the only choice you need make is to give us a call. Rest assured, we promise to take care of everything.

Heavenly

Reviewed By Laura S

This Inn was the most relaxing place we could have chosen. Room 7 was so charming and comfortable. amenities were top notch and the breakfasts. In a word, delicious! The entire staff, Kenny, Dawn, Kellie. And Nicole couldn't do enough for us. We felt treasured and cossetted. Very sad we only had two nights, but hope to get back soon. Delightful place.

2. East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast

9 Bon Pinck Way, East Hampton, NY 11937-3001 1 (631) 904-7248
Excellent
98%
Good
2%
Satisfactory
0%
Poor
0%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 299 reviews

East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast

In the heart of Springs artists community experience an authentic and unique, WOW! world style villa. Enjoy our beautifully appointed rooms, 66 foot pool, hot tub with waterfall, wading pool, and indoor Endless Pool. In our landscaped courtyard and labyrinth sculpture gardens, private and communal seating areas offer relaxation in a serene setting. You can take a one block walk or bike ride to Clearwater Beach Preserve and Marina on never-crowded Gardiner’s Bay to enjoy the adventure of beach combing, swimming, fishing, kayaking. Or explore the area’s quiet streets.Step outside into the silent beauty of a country setting; be greeted by a million stars at night or perhaps a giant moon rising in the woods surrounding the house; sight deer, turtles, possum, wild turkeys. We offer you the tranquility of natural beauty only minutes away from busy, teeming East Hampton. Some of our amenities are a gym, game room with HDTV, Blue-Ray, pool table, darts, living room with fireplace, and, of course, art. Guests are welcome to engage with Rosalind Brenner & Michael Cardacino, the artists/proprietors. And a delicious, abundant breakfast is served every morning.

WOW ! Thoroughly enjoyed

Reviewed By Charles G

This is our second time staying at the artists house . we stayed in the master suite and marveled at the construction ands d attention to detail of the room . This Band B only has 4 rooms and is quiet in an artsy setting . The owners art is all over the house I assume for sale . . Pool exercise room and the Breakfast is restaurant style with an extensive menu . We will definitely return for another relaxing and wonderful weekend

3. The Hedges Inn

74 James Ln, East Hampton, NY 11937-2722 1 (631) 324-7101
Excellent
90%
Good
6%
Satisfactory
2%
Poor
1%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 294 reviews

The Hedges Inn

Overlooking the beautiful village pond The Hedges Inn is an East Hampton, New York landmark. Home to the famous swans that, like our special guests, return year after year. This exclusive enclave is around the corner from world-class beaches, nestled among East Hampton's legendary estates and just steps from the Village. Built in the 1800’s and recently renovated to the highest standards, The Hedges Inn strikes the perfect balance between sophisticated luxury and unpretentious seaside charm. We invite you to enjoy not just the intimacy of your rooms, but to take advantage of our entire house as if it was your own. The Hedges Inn. "Your home in the Hampton's."

Terrific Property

Reviewed By BusinessTraveler2019

I stayed for a week last month and had a wonderful stay. The grounds and house are beautiful, location was perfect for me as I love the walk to Main Beach along Ocean Avenue and this is the closest B & B to Main Beach (about a mile walk which I do not mind as its one of the most beautiful walks to a beach in the U.S. ) Jenny and her staff are friendly, attentive and made my stay like a home away from home. I felt like one of the family! The house is well appointed with spacious living rooms, studies for relaxing, working or enjoying a glass of wine after the beach and an honor system bar which I appreciate (they are counting on the trustworthiness of their guests). What hotel would ever allow you to serve yourself at the bar and without some form of payment? The room was plenty for me and the decor was lovely with a beach theme. Entire property is immaculate, spotless clean. Breakfast everyday was exellent and Jenny makes sure there is something for everyone. Yogurt, fresh fruit, wonderful berries, smoked salmon, bagels, pastry and a choice of one of Jenny's delicious entrees. The casserole of eggs caprisse was delicious. Overall, a great stay and sad to leave. Will be back very soon. I love East Hampton and have been coming out for 20+ years. All my best to Jenny and staff and Love to EH!

4. House on Chase Creek

3 Locust Ave, Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island, NY 11965 1 (631) 899-2196
Excellent
75%
Good
20%
Satisfactory
1%
Poor
3%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 142 reviews

House on Chase Creek

Shelter Island's best value (Travel and Leisure Magazine), a quaint and quiet getaway only 2 hrs by bus or car from Manhattan. Set on a country lane overlooking a picturesque inlet, the House is only 2 blocks from the shops and restaurants on Dering Harbor. Bike rentals, golf, and tennis as well as transportation to NYC are all available within walking distance. All rooms have private bath, AC and can see the water.

Amazing Weekend

Reviewed By TessMoss2022

I had a wonderful experience at the House on Chase Creek. Bill is a wonderful host, property is well maintained, rooms are clean, ambience amazing. House on the Chase Creek is a hidden gem on the Shelter Island. I will definitely go back.

5. Mill House Inn

31 N Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937-2601 1 (631) 392-7166
Excellent
84%
Good
8%
Satisfactory
3%
Poor
1%
Terrible
4%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 373 reviews

Mill House Inn

Casual luxury in the heart of East Hampton Village. Just steps to spectacular dining, shopping, galleries and the world’s best ocean beaches. MHI is The Hamptons B&B that Zagat’s named one of the Top 50 Small Hotels in the USA. Your Personal Assistant will provide world-class service and promise ‘to help you travel better’ and we always keep our promise's. Our farm to table breakfast was awarded a 28 by Zagat’s and Google says we deserve 4.5 Stars. Our beautiful rooms and expansive suites have private decks, soaking tubs, steam showers, flat screen HD TV’s and fireplaces, many are child and dog friendly. They may tempt you to spend the day perfecting the art of doing nothing, curled up in your living room watching a classic movie or finishing that novel sipping wine by the fire. It would be our pleasure to show you the MHI Art of Hospitality, the only choice you need make is to give us a call. Rest assured, we promise to take care of everything.

Heavenly

Reviewed By Laura S

This Inn was the most relaxing place we could have chosen. Room 7 was so charming and comfortable. amenities were top notch and the breakfasts. In a word, delicious! The entire staff, Kenny, Dawn, Kellie. And Nicole couldn't do enough for us. We felt treasured and cossetted. Very sad we only had two nights, but hope to get back soon. Delightful place.

6. Aqua by American Beech

15 Bay Avenue, Aquebogue, Riverhead, NY 11931
Excellent
66%
Good
16%
Satisfactory
4%
Poor
7%
Terrible
7%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 117 reviews

Aqua by American Beech

Situated on an acre of land directly on the Peconic Bay, this newly renovated Aquebogue hotel offers direct beach access and proximity to local wineries, farm stands, golf courses and numerous area beaches. Free WiFi access is available throughout the property. ​ A flat-screen TV, a refrigerator and Bluetooth enabled speaker are included in each room at Aqua by American Beech. Guests can also enjoy a seating area and private En-suite bathrooms. All rooms feature king or queen-sized beds complete with Frette sheets, towels and robes and Maison Margiela Jazz Club bath amenities. ​ Guests of Aqua can make use of the private beach as well as the property’s dockside lawn and garden complete with lounge area, beach chaises, hammocks and a bocce ball court. Other activities include swimming, sunning and exploring the area's many award-winning golf courses, wineries and farm-to-table restaurants. ​ Located in the heart of Long Island’s wine country, Aqua by American Beech is just 1 ½

Not what it used to be..

Reviewed By KidNoah

The hotel is no longer the hidden gem that is used to be. Rug in room is falling apart and is a tripping hazard. Black mold in the bathroom shower. Teak mat in shower had huge pieces of wood sticking out which could also hurt someone. Chipping paint. Plants around resort are dead and should be removed, they are not coming back to life in the spring. I sent a few email to hotel and ownership and got no response. Not sure if this is the new standard, but it is not what it was.

7. East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast

9 Bon Pinck Way, East Hampton, NY 11937-3001 1 (631) 904-7248
Excellent
98%
Good
2%
Satisfactory
0%
Poor
0%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 299 reviews

East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast

In the heart of Springs artists community experience an authentic and unique, WOW! world style villa. Enjoy our beautifully appointed rooms, 66 foot pool, hot tub with waterfall, wading pool, and indoor Endless Pool. In our landscaped courtyard and labyrinth sculpture gardens, private and communal seating areas offer relaxation in a serene setting. You can take a one block walk or bike ride to Clearwater Beach Preserve and Marina on never-crowded Gardiner’s Bay to enjoy the adventure of beach combing, swimming, fishing, kayaking. Or explore the area’s quiet streets.Step outside into the silent beauty of a country setting; be greeted by a million stars at night or perhaps a giant moon rising in the woods surrounding the house; sight deer, turtles, possum, wild turkeys. We offer you the tranquility of natural beauty only minutes away from busy, teeming East Hampton. Some of our amenities are a gym, game room with HDTV, Blue-Ray, pool table, darts, living room with fireplace, and, of course, art. Guests are welcome to engage with Rosalind Brenner & Michael Cardacino, the artists/proprietors. And a delicious, abundant breakfast is served every morning.

WOW ! Thoroughly enjoyed

Reviewed By Charles G

This is our second time staying at the artists house . we stayed in the master suite and marveled at the construction ands d attention to detail of the room . This Band B only has 4 rooms and is quiet in an artsy setting . The owners art is all over the house I assume for sale . . Pool exercise room and the Breakfast is restaurant style with an extensive menu . We will definitely return for another relaxing and wonderful weekend

8. Rockville Centre Hotel

1 Sunrise Hwy, Lynbrook, NY 11563-3721
Excellent
42%
Good
30%
Satisfactory
20%
Poor
5%
Terrible
3%
Overall Ratings

4 based on 187 reviews

Rockville Centre Hotel

Our hotel on the Lynbrook - Rockville Centre border is near New York City, JFK and LaGuardia Airports. The Rockville Centre Hotel offers a relaxed, suburban setting along Long Island's south shore that is a short train ride away from the excitement of New York City. Guests who stay at our Rockville Centre hotel can take advantage of New York City and other nearby attractions such as Jones Beach and Long Beach, Jones Beach Theater, Belmont Park, Shea Stadium, the Freeport Nautical Mile and Bethpage State Park. Each is within easy driving distance of our Lynbrook, NY hotel. Corporate guests will appreciate that JFK Airport is seven miles away, and LaGuardia Airport is twelve miles from our Lynbrook hotel. The Lynbrook and Rockville Centre business districts, Molloy College, Hofstra University, Adelphi University, and Rexcorp Plaza are all within six miles of our choice hotel in Lynbrook-Rockville Centre, NY. Business travelers can also take advantage of the 24-hour business center with copy, mail and fax services. During your Lynbrook vacation or business trip, we encourage you to try our complimentary hot breakfast bar. We are also proud to offer complimentary access to the Bally Total Fitness Center while you stay at our Rockville Centre hotel. Book your reservations now to take advantage of our excellent Lynbrook hotel deals and rates.

An excellent value!

Reviewed By Phil-Yardley

As those of us who travel on Long Island know, there aren't a lot of choices for hotels. The Rockville Center Hotel is a gem and a great value. The room rates are significantly less than the other two quality hotels in Rockville Center. The staff is friendly and helpful, especially Alex, one of the front desk clerks...for instance, I accidentally left my car keys near the front desk, and he figured out whose they were and called my room. And he has great recommendations for restaurants. The rooms are spacious and well maintained. (I have stayed at the hotel 3x.) The lobby and dining area are spacious. The dining area is for breakfast, which comes with your daily rate, They have an excellent continental breakfast, and each guest can get scrambled eggs (not runny!) and bacon too. They do not have a gym or pool, but they do have an arrangement with a nearby gym. The hotel is in a great location: it's on the border of Lynbrook and Rockville Center. Even though it's on Sunrise highway, it's very quiet in the hotel..very thick walls. I will be going back there in a few days. :)

9. The Stirling House Inn

104 Bay Ave, Greenport, NY 11944-1404
Excellent
93%
Good
6%
Satisfactory
1%
Poor
0%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 299 reviews

The Stirling House Inn

Waterfront luxury in Greenport Village. Thank you to our guests! June, 2015 - Tripadvisor inducted The Stirling House into its Hall of Fame for receiving the Award of Excellence for the fifth year in a row. Featured on NBC's The Today Show, The Stirling House Bed & Breakfast is the top rated waterfront inn of Long Island. Quality abounds and the guests come first at The Stirling House, Long Island Wine Country's gem. Award winning breakfasts, gorgeous views of Greenport Harbor and Shelter. Boutique hotel, with expert concierge service. Vine Time, the total wine experience is both hosted by The Stirling House. Licensed by NYS Liquor Authority, The Stirling House is the North Fork's ONLY fully wine licensed B&B. Stirling House provides their guests with complimentary area beach passes, as well as towels and chairs on demand. Wi-fi, i-Pod docking stations, ensuite pruvate bathrooms, flatscreen TV/DVD players, fireplaces, and so much more. You will never want to leave the porch! Better Homes and Gardens, Wine Enthusiast, Frommers, NY Daily News, WPIX TV, Edible Magazines, and Coastal Living rate The Stirling House B&B as their first choice. Shouldn't you? Celebrities come here to feel normal, and normal people are treated like celebrities.

The Best Place to Stay in Greenport

Reviewed By HoniDijon

We really enjoyed our weekend getaway from Brooklyn at The Stirling House - where we found exceptionally clean, comfortable amenities (in the Shelter Island Room) with lovely views of Peconic Bay within walking distance of Greenport Village and the North Ferry to Shelter Island. The real gem is Clay - the host with the most, who warmly greeted us with extraordinary baked goods and Prosecco! We really enjoyed Clay’s breakfast on the porch - and his great vibes. We cannot wait to return! Also - very happy with Clay’s COVID-safe practices :)

10. Jones Beach Hotel

3275 Byron St, Wantagh, NY 11793-4213
Excellent
30%
Good
29%
Satisfactory
10%
Poor
10%
Terrible
22%
Overall Ratings

3.5 based on 93 reviews

Jones Beach Hotel

Jones Beach Hotel is an excellent choice for travelers visiting Wantagh, offering many helpful amenities designed to enhance your stay. Rooms at Jones Beach Hotel provide a refrigerator and air conditioning, and guests can stay connected with free wifi. In addition, while staying at Jones Beach Hotel guests have access to a concierge. You can also enjoy an on-site restaurant. Need a place to park? Free parking is available at Jones Beach Hotel. During your visit, be sure to check out a popular Wantagh oyster restaurant such as SmorgasBar, which is a short distance from Jones Beach Hotel. During your visit, be sure to check out Wantagh Park (0.8 mi), which is a popular attraction within walking distance of the small hotel. Enjoy your stay in Wantagh!

Hidden Gem - Clean rooms, amazing accommodating staff & great location

Reviewed By WorldwideTravler1089

I travel a few times a year to Long Island to visit family or for business and stumbled across this hidden gem and now I always stay at the Jones Beach Hotel. Their pricing is phenomenal, rooms are clean and the staff goes above and beyond to meet any need I've had while staying there. I highly recommend this hotel if you want to be close to the Jones Beach or the amphitheater. The parkway is a couple blocks away, great local restaurants and Cedar Creek Park is right behind the hotel. In my opinion this place is a steal for the location and great customer service.

ThingsTodoPost © 2018 - 2024 All rights reserved.