10 Top-Rated Bed and Breakfast Inns in Finger Lakes, New York

May 28, 2023 Renato Branum

New York’s Finger Lakes region takes its name from 11 freshwater lakes placed like a handprint between Lake Ontario and the Pennsylvania border. Skiing, hiking and biking trails traverse the landscape; visitors can also indulge in various wine, cheese and beer trails. The area offers a culinary bounty, with an emphasis on farm-to-table cuisine. Rich history and culture are found throughout the region, with one attraction more inviting than the next.
Things to do in Finger Lakes

1. BrickInn

32 State St, Mount Morris, NY 14510-1147 1 (585) 326-8598
Excellent
100%
Good
0%
Satisfactory
0%
Poor
0%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 91 reviews

BrickInn

BrickInn located near Letchworth State Park - North Entrance is a stately 1915 Brick Colonial home situated on a five acre lot in the Historical District of the Village of Mt Morris. Drive time to SUNY Geneseo University is 10 minutes and Rochester Airport is 40 minutes. The guestrooms at BrickInn are completely updated, bright, fresh and comfortable with a touch of vintage flair honoring the home’s original detail. Each room has a private en-suite bathroom, featuring a large rain fall shower, heated tile floors and warmers for the plush towels & robes. Enjoy our amazing BrickInn Breakfast each morning with seatings at 8 or 9:00 am. We would love to be your hosts while you visit our beautiful Letchworth area and quaint Historical Village.

Outstanding

Reviewed By ISMB2014

Stayed at the Brick Inn with friends for a college reunion weekend. Everything about our stay was perfect and delightful - Chic and Dwight were gracious, the breakfasts were absolutely delicious and the house and grounds are gorgeous. We loved all the little details like home baked cookies and fresh lemonade and iced tea every day. The house is beautifully decorated and the meticulous attention to detail was impressive. We would definitely would stay here again.

2. Idlwilde Inn

1 Lakeview Ave, Watkins Glen, NY 14891-1148
Excellent
95%
Good
1%
Satisfactory
2%
Poor
1%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 136 reviews

Idlwilde Inn

We're closed for the winter, until March, but we invite you to make your reservations now to come experience Idlwilde Inn in the heart of Finger Lakes wine country in Upstate New York. Located on 3 acres in the picturesque town of Watkins Glen, NY our full service bed and breakfast offers sweeping views of Seneca Lake, a full breakfast every morning, Free Wi-Fi, parking, concierge services and all the amenities the modern traveler requires.

Tremendous Bed and Breakfast with gorgeous views and fantastic hosts and staff

Reviewed By HouseAnimalNation

Perhaps the title of our review will give you an indication of our experiences, but this is easily one of the best, if not best, B&Bs we’ve ever stayed at, We were greeted by Marcus and their dog, Stella (she by the way is a very sweet and friendly dog that we loved). We got to meet Elin the next morning as we had arrived late. The attention to details, quality of our breakfasts and beauty of their home was simply amazing. They accommodated us so thoughtfully as among the four of us some were vegetarians and one of us did not eat eggs. This presented no issues whatsoever for Elin and Marcus as their breakfasts were delicious and prepared with our tastes strictly in mind. Another wonderful aspect of Idlewild is the number of “community rooms” to hang out, play games and simply relax. They insisted on our making ourselves at home and utilizing certain areas of the kitchen for storing or heating up leftovers or snacks. Marcus was often checking in to ensure we were comfortable and was so accessible as he responded practically instantaneously to one’s text. The bedrooms themselves were spacious and beautiful, spotlessly clean, too, thanks to their excellent and very friendly staff. Those, too, who assisted in the serving of our breakfasts were equally friendly and yet professional and courteous. Marcus and Elin have constructed a webpage, so user friendly and very informative concerning places to hike, eat or visit. Further, they were incredibly helpful in guiding us to places such as wineries and restaurants and places to hike, thereby expanding on the information already proffered on their website/webpage. The huge and wonderful deck, too, opened up to inspiring views of Lake Seneca and there was a gazebo on the grounds. Many places are within walking distance and be prepared to get some great exercise as the streets present some steep hills. But we loved that too as Idlewild is located and situated such that you get those beautiful views of the region. We’re going back in the late fall so this, too, should tell you how we feel about this place: the area and most importantly its owners, Elin and Marcus, their staff, the accommodations and Stella! Cannot recommended Idlewild Inn enough.

3. Vintage Gardens Bed & Breakfast

310 High St, Newark, NY 14513-1407 1 (315) 860-0245
Excellent
92%
Good
7%
Satisfactory
1%
Poor
0%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 199 reviews

Vintage Gardens Bed & Breakfast

A Luxury Bed & Breakfast with Five Guest rooms. One night stays welcome. Formerly the Jackson's Perkins Rose Company Estate this historic 1840's Tudor with the personallized service of a Boutique Hotel. Furnished with antiques and gracefully poised on a park-like setting, including formal gardens and fall colored woodlands. Two blocks from the Eire Canal in the New York Finger Lakes region, just minutes from Rochester, wine trails, apple farms, outlet shopping, and area attractions. Encounter warm hospitality and the charm of a vintage B&B with modern conveniences.

A step/sleep back in time.

Reviewed By briankeithparrish

Quaint little place. Love the old vintage style rooms with the 100 year old floor squeaks. We were visiting the Palmyra/Newark area on and LDS (Mormon) historical sites tour so it was quite fitting. Everything is not perfect which makes it perfect. Such character and we were well taken care of. Lovely sun rooms and sitting areas. We were out and about and only slept here. Next time will enjoy the property more. Would definitely come back.

4. Glass Magnolia Bed & Breakfast

8339 Main St, Interlaken, NY 14847-9787 1 (607) 304-3119
Excellent
86%
Good
12%
Satisfactory
1%
Poor
1%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 206 reviews

Glass Magnolia Bed & Breakfast

A beautiful 1800's Greek Revival home situated in the heart of the Finger Lakes, NY. We have 11 well appointed guest rooms, all with private baths. Our guests enjoy a gourmet breakfast each morning including a choice of entree, sides of meat, potatoes, home baked bread, fresh fruit, coffee, tea and juice. Just minutes from the Cayuga and Seneca Lake Wine Trails. Great for romantic getaways, or for groups to get together, relax and enjoy all that the Finger Lakes has to offer. Whether you are coming for the wine/beer trail, amazing hiking and boating or just a quiet respite, we are here for you. Make our home your home away from home!

Great place to stay!

Reviewed By Charles L

Glass Magnolia sits between Seneca and Cayuga lakes. Interlakken is a quiet town surrounded by what are mostly dairy farms and wineries. The house is in a downtown area but enjoys a spacious back yard with some privacy. We stayed in the Lady Jayne room which had its own private entrance. Despite some peculiarities, like a small step up into the bathroom, the king sized bed was very comfortable. Both Nancy and Wally, our hosts, were gracious and made excellent suggestions for restaurants, wineries and waterfalls. BTW Wally was an executive chef for 40 years before retiring. The breakfasts were better than great! For an example, our last meal he served us Brie and Ham stuffed French toast with a side of sautéed onion tater tot mix pressed into a waffle iron. Three slices of bacon garnished the top of the potato waffle. The French toast was served with a peach butter and a homemade raspberry sauce. The guests were also able to get fresh brewed coffee or cold bottled water 24/7.

5. Inn at Taughannock Falls

2030 Gorge Rd Rte. 89 at Taughannock State Park, Trumansburg, NY 14886-9118 1 (607) 323-8251
Excellent
69%
Good
15%
Satisfactory
6%
Poor
7%
Terrible
4%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 251 reviews

Inn at Taughannock Falls

Inn at Taughannock Falls is located in Trumansburg, New York, just 9 miles from downtown Ithaca and Cornell University. This stunning estate, expanding across 12 open acres, overlooks Cayuga Lake. The property features four buildings comprised of 24 guest rooms and suites, one of the best restaurants in the area, and the region's premier outdoor event venue. Surrounded by Taughannock Falls State Park, which hosts the tallest waterfall on the east coast, a 215-foot vertical drop, is easily accessible by our hotel guests. The park also includes a variety of activities such as hiking, swimming, canoeing, kayaking, water skiing, and more. The Inn at Taughannock is a famous landmark, servicing the community since 1935. Originally built in 1873, the entire first floor of the Victorian mansion is dedicated to the Inn’s fine dining restaurant, which features a traditional American cuisine with a Mediterranean influence. We offer a variety of accommodations from classic Victorian architecture filled with antiques to modern rooms with conveniences such as flatscreen TVs, refrigerators, Keurig coffee machines, and microwaves. Our recently renovated Hillside Residence offers 6 bedrooms and sleeps 12 in comfort. The Le Grande Suite offers a fully outfitted kitchen and huge family room with a pool table. Hillside may be rented by the room or in its entirety for a group to enjoy. Located at the start of the Cayuga wine trail, the Inn is located in the heart of the idyllic Finger Lakes region, with over 100 wineries within a half-hour from our location. The Inn at Taughannock has just completed construction on a 10,000 square foot event garden called “Enchantment," an elegant setting with majestic stone fireplace, numerous fire pits and a Gatsby style translucent sailcloth tent, capable of handling any size event. We offer tours of this venue, year-round, which operates from May to October. Please join us and experience our exceptional customer service which has earned 5-star reviews.

Road trip New England

Reviewed By Susan N

The Inn was very nice! Super clean. Very friendly and helpful staff. Location is terrific. I would definitely stay here again. The food in the restaurant was so-so but convenience was nice. The falls is so close, make sure you see it!

6. The William Henry Miller Inn

303 N Aurora St, Ithaca, NY 14850-4201
Excellent
93%
Good
6%
Satisfactory
1%
Poor
0%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 335 reviews

The William Henry Miller Inn

The award winning William Henry Miller Inn is located in the heart of downtown Ithaca. Built by Cornell University's first architecture student, the details are stunning--chestnut woodwork, Tiffany stained glass, original shutters. Our full breakfast features all homemade breads, homemade English Muffins and bagels accompanied by homemade jams. Our evening dessert buffet is the perfect way to end the day. We are happy to accommodate dietary requests. Within walking distance of fifty restaurants, Cornell University, Cascadilla Gorge and just a short hop to Ithaca College, we are really central to everything. Providing concierge service and a business center, parking is right on site. Parking and wireless are included in the rate. Proud to be a member of Select Registry and Lynnette Scofield received the Innkeeper of the Year Award by Select Registry.

Clean, comfortable, and beautiful

Reviewed By Lisa H

What a wonderful stay at the fabulous, clean, and comfortable William Henry Miller Inn! We had a great night’s sleep in the Turret. The location can’t be beat. We easily took a waterfall-filled hike before an amazing breakfast. From the desserts waiting for us in our room to the coffee and tea station to the service, there is attention to detail that exceeded our expectations.

7. Los Gatos Bed & Breakfast

1491 State Route 14A, Penn Yan, NY 14527-9105
Excellent
95%
Good
4%
Satisfactory
1%
Poor
0%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 751 reviews

Los Gatos Bed & Breakfast

Our contemporary solar powered home has five large comfortable rooms, including two log cabins. All have queen sized beds, private baths, and air-conditioning. We feature beautiful country views, yet are just minutes from Seneca and Keuka Lakes. Enjoy one of our award-winning breakfasts, then relax and watch the goldfinches and hummingbirds as they flit through our flower gardens. Fill your days with all that the Finger Lakes have to offer, then relax on our spacious deck and gazebo. In the evening, we can recommend a restaurant that suits your mood. On clear nights we can give star tours with a large telescope on our back lawn.

Fabulous Friends weekend

Reviewed By LMY123

What a great find! We stayed in the cabin; it is a perfect place to relax, bed is comfortable, and the quilts are warm and pretty. Enjoyed the beautiful views in the morning with coffee or at night at the fire pit with friends after a fun day at the winery. Breakfast is delicious the home-grown berries and juice made it even better. The owners are super friendly and knowledgeable of the area all question my husband asked had been answered, thank you Charles for taking your time to talk to us, you and your wife are blessed with a beautiful home and grounds. We all LOVED our stay. Hope to see you again.

8. OAK VALLEY INN & SUITES

4562 Millennium Dr, Geneseo, NY 14454-1194
Excellent
83%
Good
14%
Satisfactory
1%
Poor
1%
Terrible
2%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 327 reviews

OAK VALLEY INN & SUITES

The Oak Valley Inn and Suites in Geneseo, NY was built in 1868 as a Poor House on 118 acres. Over the years the Inn has been completely renovated but the rooms are still complemented with high ceilings and tall windows. It is located in a beautiful, historic community in the heart of Livingston County. Each of the 13 guest rooms has its own private bath, individual heat and air condition controls and natural toiletries. Suites are available with fireplaces, jetted tubs and King or Queen beds. There are local attractions for everyone from fine dining, to fishing all within minutes from the Inn. Free WiFi 8 acres to enjoy nature and relax in the peace and quite. An outside fire pit is located out front to keep you warm on cool evenings. Come and enjoy our relaxed family atmosphere and freshly prepared breakfasts!

Solid room, great staff and delightful location.

Reviewed By tfrose30

The room was very comfortable and exactly as depicted. Margie is extremely hospitable and always available to help or chat. Jay's breakfast was a treat, followed by some great discussion. Look forward to a return visit.

9. BrickInn

32 State St, Mount Morris, NY 14510-1147 1 (585) 326-8598
Excellent
100%
Good
0%
Satisfactory
0%
Poor
0%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 91 reviews

BrickInn

BrickInn located near Letchworth State Park - North Entrance is a stately 1915 Brick Colonial home situated on a five acre lot in the Historical District of the Village of Mt Morris. Drive time to SUNY Geneseo University is 10 minutes and Rochester Airport is 40 minutes. The guestrooms at BrickInn are completely updated, bright, fresh and comfortable with a touch of vintage flair honoring the home’s original detail. Each room has a private en-suite bathroom, featuring a large rain fall shower, heated tile floors and warmers for the plush towels & robes. Enjoy our amazing BrickInn Breakfast each morning with seatings at 8 or 9:00 am. We would love to be your hosts while you visit our beautiful Letchworth area and quaint Historical Village.

Outstanding

Reviewed By ISMB2014

Stayed at the Brick Inn with friends for a college reunion weekend. Everything about our stay was perfect and delightful - Chic and Dwight were gracious, the breakfasts were absolutely delicious and the house and grounds are gorgeous. We loved all the little details like home baked cookies and fresh lemonade and iced tea every day. The house is beautifully decorated and the meticulous attention to detail was impressive. We would definitely would stay here again.

10. Baldwinsville Bed and Breakfast

70 Oswego St, Baldwinsville, NY 13027-2426
Excellent
98%
Good
0%
Satisfactory
0%
Poor
0%
Terrible
2%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 61 reviews

Baldwinsville Bed and Breakfast

The Baldwinsville Bed and Breakfast is a charming historic shingle-style home in the village of Baldwinsville with four guest rooms all with private bathrooms. Three guest rooms are Queen Non-Smoking rooms and the fourth is a Double with two beds. The house is listed in the National Registry of Historic Places and represents one of the fine examples of 19th century period architecture in the Oswego - Oneida Street district.

Recommend this place!

Reviewed By angpfister

Beautiful setting. Check in was easy. Our room was so charming, comfortable and clean. The hosts are very hospitable and the breakfast was absolutely delicious! Parking was a little tricky, but we figured it out. Would definitely stay there again!

ThingsTodoPost © 2018 - 2024 All rights reserved.