Top Restaurants in Paradise Island
New Providence Island, Caribbean Food Guide: 10 Seafood food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Paradise Island
Reviews on Seafood food in Paradise Island, New Providence Island, Caribbean. Paradise Island is known for powder soft beaches and crystal clear, turquoise water, great for diving and snorkeling. Visitors can try their luck at the Atlantis Casino and dine “around the world” at celebrity chef restaurants. Spend the day at Aquaventure Water Park or swim with dolphins at Dolphin Cay. Take a scenic stroll through Marina Village or shop for souvenirs at Bahamas Craft Center and Craft Cottage. Or just soak up the Caribbean sun on a beautiful beach.
Things to do in Paradise Island
10. Crabs and Ting
Overall Ratings
4 based on 252 reviews
Reviewed By TravelDon10
This doesnât make the category of a restaurant. It is a shack on the beach. The 2 food items on the menu is cooked in very unacceptable conditions. Overall, DO NOT waste time coming here if you want a restaurant. This listing should be removed as it does not meet the criteria for a restaurant.
9. Nobu
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1461 reviews
Reviewed By DinedThereSippedThat
Weâve been here several times over the last three or four years as a couple, with friends, and with other couples and I usually always rate excellent or very good, but the last two times the service was so inconsistent that I am giving my final rating of nobu Atlantis just âaverageâ. If only the service could be as good as the food. I almost always get the tasting menu and everything is so delicious, but the service takes away from it. Not normal that weâre paying upwards of $120 per person and I have to wait 15 minutes for a glass of wine or a refill on my water. Tip is included so the servers act professional at the beginning of the meal, but stop caring quickly as the meal progresses. If you donât mind bad service definitely check it out for the amazing food.
8. The Poop Deck
Overall Ratings
4 based on 2131 reviews
Reviewed By Melissa B
I felt this place was way overpriced. I got the mahi-mahi with Bahamian mac and cheese, peas and rice and plantains. I felt like the plantains didn't have any seasoning on them, and maybe that's how they make them down there but I've had them other places and they were more crispy and had seasoning. I wasn't impressed. I also wasn't impressed with the Bahamian mac and cheese. My cousin loved the rum cake and the cheesecake, I wasn't a fan. The Mahi-Mahi was delicious, but expect to spend at least $100 here.
7. Montagu Gardens Steak & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 623 reviews
Reviewed By ThomasL711
Went here through a flier at the Harborside Resort concierge. They pick you up bring you back. You arrive at a dark lit and don't see anything but guided to nice restaurant experience. A great conch chowder, terrific grouper and perfectly grilled shrimp at prices below resort level.
Paradise Island Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Paradise Island
6. Dune at The Ocean Club
Overall Ratings
4 based on 764 reviews
Indulge your senses at Dune, a chic restaurant by internationally renowned restaurateur, Chef Jean-Georges Vongerichten. Perched atop a white sand beach amidst dramatic ocean views, Dune serves an innovative blend of French-Asian cuisine infused with loca
Reviewed By DinedThereSippedThat
Iâve eaten at Dune at the four seasons 5 to 6 times now and without exaggeration during one week in June ate there three nights. Needless to say I got to recognize the faces and tried every fish dish on the menu. Vacationing in the Bahamas you already know to expect high prices and if youâre coming to a celebrity chef restaurant in a luxury resort then you know to expect even higher prices and this is exactly what youâll find at Dune. The food is pretty good considering where you are and the options around you, but the service does not match the prices. Itâs still rather on the slow side, uncaring, and forgetful. Friendly, but friendly doesnât get results. Manage your expectations to not receive things too quickly and have to ask two or three times when they get busy and youâll have a great time. The resort and the grounds are five star without hesitation, the food is four stars, but the service brings it down to an average of three or 3.5. I donât know why the Bahamians canât get their service to a certain level considering theyâre getting pretty good gratuity for the prices of these meals.
5. The Bearded Clam Sports Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 467 reviews
Reviewed By Passenger107952
Had the best Conch Friiter and Chips with Slasa!Kedra was great! Hope to be back soon!Bar is located very close to the Cruise port .. steps away..Wow! Thank you so much for your great review. I will let Kedra know you left a review about her. She is pretty awesome. I'm glad she took great care of you whilst you were here. We hope to see you soon! Thanks once again, Becky.
Top 10 Bahamian food in Paradise Island, New Providence Island, Caribbean
4. McKenzie's Fresh Fish and Conch
Overall Ratings
4 based on 214 reviews
Reviewed By sublimemoon
Had the shrimp with rice and peas, but at the time we went, the only other sides were plantain and corn, and the rice and peas was the last for the dinner meal. Decent meal, nothing to rave about. The have a big menu and the prices are really reasonable compared to the Atlantis.
3. Bahamian Club
Overall Ratings
4 based on 619 reviews
Reviewed By Dean B
Two adults and two picky teens and we managed to get an excellent meal. Service was very attentive. The decor is nice but they put a table of 8 right next to our booth. They weren't loud but it trapped us in so much that the waiter couldn't do the flambe dessert beside our table. We had 8 pm reservations and by 8:30, the place was crowded.
Where to eat Italian food in Paradise Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Cafe Martinique
Overall Ratings
4 based on 712 reviews
Chef Alessio Pitzalis and his team have created a comprehensive and eclectic epicurean experience for the updated Café Martinique at Atlantisâ fine-dining concept, which launched in early 2019. Café Martinique is the resortâs newest and only restaurant to
Reviewed By rocketrod23
Iâve always immensely enjoyed my experiences at Cafe Martinique. Though this is my first time at the NEW Cafe Martinique, Sat, Aug 10, 2019, it did not disappoint, in fact, I consider it one of the best restaurants worldwide that I have been fortunate enough to experience. The service was impeccable ( forgive me I cannot recall his name right now) the food outstanding, the ambiance first class, and the music by pianist, Lee Callender was the icing on the cake! Lee is an amazing performer. You have patrons for life, and I intend to share our experience with all! Thank you, Cafe Martinique! Rod RagazzoWindermere, FL
Best American food near Paradise Island, New Providence Island, Caribbean
1. Cafe Matisse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1842 reviews
Reviewed By Silver1881
Matisse is one of the only restaurants that has maintained a very good level of food and service in Nassau over the years. This is probably due to Greg the owner and Allen the manager running the place like professionals. Staff are also the best on the Island by far.The outdoor open space is one of the nicest on the Island and you would not think you are in the middle of downtown Nassau. The food is good not incredible but for Nassau its one of the best. I still would like to see an Italian serve veal but probably because its rare to find in the Bahamas they don't have any on their menu. The pasta is good, Fish is ok and could be done in a more Italian tradition than American.The pizza definitely needs improvement.I still gave it 5 star because you will hardly find a better experience in Nassau.
Most Popular Mediterranean food in Paradise Island, New Providence Island, Caribbean
