Top Restaurants in Long Island
Where to eat Caribbean food in Long Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Caribbean food in Long Island, Out Islands, Caribbean including Max's Conch Bar & Grill, Tiny's Hurricane Hole, Chez Pierre, Moonshine Bar and Grill, the forest 2, Outer Edge, Seaside Village at Jerry Wells, Stella Maris Clubhouse Restaurant, Lloyd's Restaurant And Sports Lounge, Rowdy Boys' Bar & Grill
Things to do in Long Island
10. Rowdy Boys' Bar & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 23 reviews
Reviewed By Sonabeca
I ate here three times during a recent visit to the island. Good fish burger with salad, bad pancakes, great bacon, excellent lobster dinner! Coffee was instant so avoid that choice. Good rum cocktails and nice ladies working here. Slow service, but it's relaxed, not bad service.
9. Lloyd's Restaurant And Sports Lounge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By rayharris2016
A friend and I had a meal her and the food was fabulous. I had the seafood pasta and he had different types of chicken wings. Surely enjoyed my food with the nice cold Kaliks .
8. Stella Maris Clubhouse Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By JWinkle
The food here was very good. My kids loved the burgers and cracked chicken. The mixed drinks were really good as well and didn't have the mix from a bottle taste. They seemed really fresh. It's a little on the high end price wise and the food takes a bit to get out to you. Visit the pool or playground while you wait.
7. Seaside Village at Jerry Wells
Overall Ratings
4 based on 46 reviews
Minutes North of Deadman's Cay airport on Long Island, Bahamas
Reviewed By liveforwater
I have had conch salad all over the Caribbean and by far this is the best I have ever had by a long shot. It takes time to make so have a beer and relax. You cannot get any fresher nor any better. Words do not describe how good it is.
6. Outer Edge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 38 reviews
Reviewed By swpratt
Clarence Town is the island capitol so you will probably visit the Outer Edge or Rowdy Boyz or both.Great setting on a deck overlooking the harbour where you can see ridiculously ostentatious boats, charter skippers cast netting for bait and also lean over and spot lots of fish - including the biggest needle fish I have ever seen. Friendly service and comfortable tables - we had the shrimp and the fish tacos which I must say were delicious and made a change from conch,.burgers or grouper fingers.
5. the forest 2
Overall Ratings
4 based on 34 reviews
Reviewed By Pensacola18
We had the grouper fingers and cracked chicken along with plantains. This might have been what we were looking for the whole week we spent on the island, unfortunately it was on our last day. We are heading back this Summer and will make a trip there early, and maybe often.
4. Moonshine Bar and Grill
Overall Ratings
5 based on 33 reviews
Wander down to the Ocean Pool at Stella Maris Resort and you'll find something new. The Moonshine Bar and Grill opened just before the end of the year, 2007. You can enjoy your favorite tropical beverage or a light meal with a pool view to the west and th
Reviewed By PJ D
I can't describe how welcome Sue made me feel at the Moonshine Bar and Grill. I almost felt like I have known her for years. Just a gem of a lady! Fried plantains were delish and accompanied by the Caribbean Sensation drink I had - let me tell you.....I will be back. The views, the pool, the breeze....it was sooo perfect! Can't say enough good things.
3. Chez Pierre
Overall Ratings
4 based on 62 reviews
Reviewed By 206adrianj
We booked a 3pm table for 6. Pierre warmly greeted us on arrival and ran through the menu and drinks procedure. Two hours later fully sated variously on delicious appetisers, lobster, shrimp, pizza accompanied by wonderful fresh locally sourced salads and an extensive choice of drinks we repared to the 3 mile beach for a dip in the clear blue water. Finally departing after sunset we settled the bill which by Bahamas standards came as a very pleasant surprise. If there is a better quality and value restaurant in the Bahamas let me know as I need to go there too. Thank you Pierre for memorable meal.
2. Tiny's Hurricane Hole
Overall Ratings
5 based on 63 reviews
Tiny's thatched roof patio style cook house and bar is a relaxed and moderately priced beach front destination for locals and visitors alike offering authentic family island experience incorporating the features-characteristics-culture of beachfront locat
Reviewed By pfigdore
Facing south, you can enjoy the changing colors of the evening sky without being blinded by the setting sun. My wife ordered blackened grouper with a side of cole slaw while I ordered two grilled barbeque pig wings (made from the pig shank) with a side of french fries. While waiting my wife had a Kalik while I ordered a Tinyâs Tonic (rum with local sour orange). The pig wings were excellent, quite juicy and tender, and at $5 each, a great price. Although the grouper was excellent, at $15, it was a bit overpriced (or undersized) as that is all that came with it. I highly recommend Tinyâs Tonic. It will cure what ails you. Total for the meal, a beer and three tonics: $71. Note that all prices include a 15% gratuity and VAT. Also, Tinyâs is CASH ONLY.
1. Max's Conch Bar & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 191 reviews
There really is only one street in Deadman's Cay of Long Island Bahamas, they don't technically have a street address.
Reviewed By markej
We had a light lunch of conch salad and conch fritters at Max's. They were doing predictably good business even on a weekday lunchtime in May. The food was great though and the insects didn't trouble us too much. The menu came on a whiteboard without prices, but we shouldn't have worried. It was the best value we had in the Bahamas, and amongst the best food too!
