Top Restaurants in Mayaguez
Mayaguez Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Mayaguez
Discover the best restaurant in Mayaguez, Puerto Rico including Gonzalez Sea Food Restaurant, Restaurant El Siglo XX, Pizzeria Sancho Panza, Ricomini Bakery, Pizzeria Don Quijote, Restaurant Hacienda Latina, E Franco & Co, Rex Cream, Buena Vibra, Friend's Cafe Puerto Rico
Things to do in Mayaguez
1. Gonzalez Sea Food Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 393 reviews
Reviewed By cskeenga - Aguadilla, Puerto Rico
Numerous people recommended this restaurant to me because they had excellent seafood at an affordable price. I was a little disappointed. However, the staff was great. Our waitress was friendly and prompt and the owner went around greeting people at all the tables. I really enjoyed the welcoming attitude of the staff. My wife ordered the Chillo Entero, which was huge and wonderful. I ordered the grilled lobster, which was a nice size but over cooked. I would really like to try this restaurant again because their staff was great and it might of just been an off day for my lobster.
2. Restaurant El Siglo XX
Overall Ratings
4 based on 95 reviews
Reviewed By Mr_Alejo - Houston, Texas
Good small restaurant with variety for their lunch specials. Twelve of us stopped for lunch and it was served promptly. We had several small kids so we split an adult plate for two of them. Food was typical from Puerto Rico. I would definitely come back if I'm ever back in town.
3. Pizzeria Sancho Panza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 108 reviews
Reviewed By Tio C
All the time I visit Mayagüez get to Sancho Panza. They have all kind of food that is good for your kids, your family, and your fiends. Variety for all gustos. Sabrosa comida, te atienden bien y los precios son razonables. Ve con mucha hambre porque sirven mucho.
4. Ricomini Bakery
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 288 reviews
Reviewed By Raul D - Savannah, Georgia
This is one of the most popular Bakery/restaurants in town. They serve really good lunch and have an amazing selection of pastries.
5. Pizzeria Don Quijote
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 153 reviews
Don Quijote es un Restaurante & Pizzeria fundado en el 1991. Cuenta con una gran variedad de comida para todos los gustos como: Camarones, Langosta ,Filete de Chillo , Mero , Dorado, lasagna, Mofongo, Asopao ,Churrasco, Pizzas y mucho mas . Ambiente familiar calidad con mas de 20 anos de experiencia que marcan la diferencia.
Reviewed By Luz L - Aguada, Puerto Rico
Don Quijote restaurant is one of those places that stays the same over the years and you can rely on that. Is not a fancy place but a traditional one. The food taste great and the prices stay great too. Last visit I ordered the daily special, mofongo y caldo con masitas de pollo. The monfongo is not the best I have tried but it was good. Also, my kid ordered masitas de pollo with mashed potatoes and salads. Very good too. I rate the restaurant 3 because it's normal. It's a solid place, always full of people.
6. Restaurant Hacienda Latina
Overall Ratings
4 based on 148 reviews
Reviewed By Gabche - Mayaguez, Puerto Rico
This place is a MUST. Delicious PuertoRican food. The owner is always there and absolutely willing to make yours an excellent culinary experience. Prices are very reasonable. The staff is very friendly and fully bilingual. Opposed to what Tripadvisor shows, the restaurant closes, usually, after 11:00 pm. Friends of ours rented a villa in Rincón (very nearby) last weekend and Hac Latina provided all the food, tents, and chairs (AMAZING PAELLA COOKED ON SITE). Again, do visit. You won't regret it!!!!
7. E Franco & Co
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 65 reviews
Reviewed By Evelopez - New Windsor, New York
It's very popular in the island, so it's a stop you can't miss if you are in Mayaguez or near by. They have the brazo gitano, the guayaba is the most famous, but they also have it with different fillings. I found the little shop cute & unique. They also have some other puertorrican candies, honey, coffee, sangrias for sale. It's a good place to buy some souveniers if you are visiting. They also have a panaderia/ cafeteria at the back of the store were you can sit and have breakfast and/or lunch. I liked it.
8. Rex Cream
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 105 reviews
Reviewed By MALCulinario
HMF*
After a average lunch at Mayagüez we need something sweet and ask for a place. Locals seems to love this place... so lets try it.
I will said: Worst "helado" ever.
We try our named versions: Watery Coconut (no so sweet) & Muddy Chocolate Brownie (granulated)
The Only Good are the Prices, thats the reason probably locals like it. Don't Know Why!
As and old friend said: "Oops... I did it again!"
(Sorry no picts, was so fast we threw it to the closets trash can.)
*Hello My Followers
9. Buena Vibra
Overall Ratings
5 based on 757 reviews
Reviewed By Pedro R - Tampa, Florida
We had a great experience at this Restaurant , Excellent appetizers and great food .
Great variety of mojitos and super tasty food
You have to ask for Cayo Blanco and Volcan de Guayaba.
The owner Edrissy and one of the waiters , Carlos will make your dining experience greta .
10. Friend's Cafe Puerto Rico
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 138 reviews
Reviewed By li p - Rincon, Puerto Rico
A Great breakfast, brunch, and lunch spot provides a relaxing, friendly venue with great wait staff. The homey feel comes from watching the cook chat and cook simultaneously as you sit at the counter. Flashback to the 50's. That is not easy trick.
The french toast was a huge portion of fluffy, tasty, fried wedge of yeast bread that was cooked to perfection with dusted with powder sugar, cinnamon and nutmeg as a topper. I did think I could eat it all but it " went down smooth".
The conversation between staff and customers was lively and touched on a variety of topics. Totally satisfying experience after a long walk of the beach with a friend.
