Top Restaurants in Geneva on the Lake
Where to Eat in Geneva on the Lake: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover the best restaurant in Geneva on the Lake, United States including sunrise cafe, Madsen Donuts, Whip N Dip Ice Cream, Crosswinds Grille, Effin Burrito, Katie's Korner Ice Cream, The Loft at Indian Creek Restaurant & Lounge, Eddie's Grill, Piero's Pasta House, Alessandro's
Things to do in Geneva on the Lake
1. sunrise cafe
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 279 reviews
Reviewed By Stacy S - Canfield, Ohio, United States
My husband and I were visiting the area for our 30th anniversary. We were staying across the street from Sunrise Cafe and stopped in for breakfast. We didn’t know it’s history for insults but found it hilarious. We ate breakfast with two Dicks, locals who come in every day. The waitress kept referring to them as two Dicks and we laughed the whole breakfast. The two Dicks were so knowledgeable about the restaurant and the area. Had it not been for the family style seating, we would have missed out on such an interesting conversation. The food was great too. Eggs were cooked just the way I ordered them and we will definitely be back. Just a side note, if you’re a snooty poot, please don’t go in. You will be disappointed!
2. Madsen Donuts
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 152 reviews
Reviewed By mmequiche - Warren, Ohio
I grew up in the area and it is truly part of every summer experience. I didn't realize until I was older how rare truly great doughnuts are. Nothing else quite compares to fresh, homemade Madsen's. I can't say enough good things about them.
3. Whip N Dip Ice Cream
Overall Ratings
5 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By bigohdawg - Painesville, Ohio
A must stop if your in the Geneva area and looking for a dessert treat. This establishment is a VERY Friendly place with reasonable prices and exceptional ice cream quality/ They have both a large variety of flavors and ice cream dishes. Very family friendly for everyone !
4. Crosswinds Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 306 reviews
Specializing in wood-fired farm to table cuisine. Our chefs work closely with local farmers to create seasonal menus featuring the freshest ingredients available.Whether it is a birthday or anniversary celebration or a romantic dinner for two, Crosswinds Grille is the perfect setting! Stop by and enjoy a delicious meal along with fine wines and a spectacular view of Lake Erie!
Reviewed By ben d - Columbus, Ohio
Got together with wife's family before staying at lodge. Reserved through opentable and no hassle seating for 8. Food and beverages very good, steaks done well and my liver and onions thick and tasty. Restaurant using natural home grown products. Setting nice near the lake.
5. Effin Burrito
Overall Ratings
5 based on 67 reviews
A unique fusion of Tex-Mex and Caribbean flavors wrapped in a tortilla shell, and weighing in at over 1 pound. Outdoor seating available with a stunning view of Lake Erie. NOTE: This is a seasonal business open between the months of May and September.
Reviewed By Gemelli - Columbus, Ohio
Beef burrito, chicken burrito, veggie burrito, vegan burrito. All huge, all one price. Add guac for a dollar. For a normal human one is enough for two meals. For a sixteen year old boy, it's perfect for one. Order at the window and enjoy on the tables outdoor or to go. Will definitely go back. Great food and a huge serving.
6. Katie's Korner Ice Cream
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By Bobbi58 - Lancaster, Ohio
Stopped here after lunch to enjoy an ice cream treat and loved it! Many flavors to choose from and love the fact it is homemade and hand dipped! The young gal dipping was sweet and friendly! Hope to return in the future!
7. The Loft at Indian Creek Restaurant & Lounge
Overall Ratings
3.5 based on 8 reviews
Reviewed By jj5683
The menu consists of pizza, wings, burgers, subs, appetizers and such. My wife got the meatball bomber and it was very, very good. I didn't care too much for my chicken fingers but I got them hot and they were too hot for me. We stayed at the campground next door and we'd go back to try some different items.
8. Eddie's Grill
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 241 reviews
I'm surprised that Eddie's has no reviews. It has been at it's location for at least 20 years and is outstanding in every way. Plus Eddie is just a great guy.
Reviewed By Chrissy L
Amazing! My family and I look forward to eating at Eddies every year! The food is always great. Best cheeseburgers around. Atmosphere is unique and bright. Seating available inside and outside. No credit cards accepted. Make sure you have cash.
9. Piero's Pasta House
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 191 reviews
Reviewed By Samuel R - Coconut Creek, Florida
Horrible horrible horrible. They were sooooo rude $16 for a plate is Spaghetti. Brought two tiny meatballs when there should've been three and almost no sauce on it. Then when we asked for extra sauce they came over to the table and told me they were going to have to charge me for it. They put a little bit in the coffee cup and one warmed the microwave and brought it to us. I got yelled at for sitting at a table that was empty finally and cleaning it off myself. I've never been to a restaurant where they charge me for extra sauce because there was none on the pasta to begin with. One waiter said there was no ice for the sodas then the next waiter brought me some. It had to be the worst restaurant meal experience of my life. The busboy was the only nice person there and I tipped him and left nothing for anyone else and they were angry about it and I did it on purpose just to let them know how horrible the food and other waiters were The manager acted overwhelmed if I asked for anything. It was s family of 18 of us. I will never go back there.
10. Alessandro's
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 112 reviews
Reviewed By g R - Youngstown, OHio
Great Italian food, fresh and delicious. Homemade bread, good wine selection. On a weekend get there early, or expect to wait. Always worth the wait.
