Location: Sea Isle City
Top Restaurants in Sea Isle City
Sea Isle City Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Sea Isle City
Sea Isle City is a city in Cape May County, New Jersey, United States. It is part of the Ocean City Metropolitan Statistical Area. As of the 2010 United States Census, the city's population was 2,114, reflecting a decline of 721 (-25.4%) from the 2,835 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn increased by 143 (+5.3%) from the 2,692 counted in the 1990 Census. Visitors raise the population to as much as 40,000 during the peak summer season from Memorial Day to Labor Day. Sea Isle City is located on Ludlam Island, which also contains the Strathmere section of Upper Township.
Things to do in Sea Isle City
1. Maryanne Pastry Shoppe
Overall Ratings
5 based on 56 reviews
Reviewed By michellelynnp - Lancaster, Pennsylvania
We always get a butter cake from Maryanne's. This year we liked it much better than last year. There is always a line and they can sell out of some of their more popular baked goods. Service is wonderful and friendly. They only take cash.Hello Michelle- Thanks for the review. We're glad you enjoyed the butter cake and the friendly service we strive to provide. Look forward to seeing you again soon. PS- we do accept debt cards, credit cards and gift cards at all our locations.
2. Mako's American Grille
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 147 reviews
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, BYOB, Fresh, Healthy, Casual, Gluten Free Menu. Serving only the best product with nothing fried or frozen.
Reviewed By cmo1061 - Phoenixville, Pennsylvania
We have eaten here several times and have really enjoyed the fish tacos, but this time, they were barely lukewarm and dry.
3. Mrs Brizzle's Buns Incorporated
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 109 reviews
Reviewed By H6294DLpaul - York, Pennsylvania
We have come here for their cinnamon buns since finding them on our first trip to SIC 3 years ago. They are delicious. This year we also decided to try them for lunch. The subs are huge! We ordered a half sub and it was enough for 3 people. It also had very good quality meats and cheese. Glad we gave them a chance for lunch as well.
4. Yum Yums Ice Cream
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 36 reviews
Reviewed By Michael P - Huntingdon Valley, Pennsylvania
Went here for a nice afternoon ice cream break during the week and it was not crowded at all which was strange because the night before around 10pm there was a line out the door. They have many many flavors including the classic and not so classic. Huge portions, we got the "kids" which is the standard american kids size which is too big even for kids. Prices are fair, even reasonable, for where they are. Think kids size cone was under $3. Ice cream was very tasty and full of quality ingredients. You have to stop here for ice cream if in Sea Isle. They have some seating inside and out. No public rest room and they are CASH ONLY, strangely (to me) like most other Sea Isle establishments.
5. Basilicos Ristorante-Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 154 reviews
Basilico’s Ristorante and Pizzeria is owned and operated by Chef, Scott Oliver and Pizza Man, Vinson Powell. We have been a family owned and operated business since 1999. We are dedicated to offering you quality ingredients and authentic Italian cuisine.
Reviewed By QuakerBoy90 - Newtown Square, Pennsylvania
Always make a reservation. Bring some wine and enjoy the food, good service and a nice environment. Although there are some traditional Italian dishes the chef includes a lot of seafood, chicken and veal. It's more than your average Italian restaurant at the shore. The prices also reflect an up-scale restaurant, but don't expect a tablecloth or cloth napkins-a small disappointment. In-season it's noisy, but there's not much they can do about that, I suppose. We enjoy coming here. The BYOB option is a big draw. Parking can be a challenge in season, of course, so be prepared.
6. Marita's
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By KaliRaven - Cape May, New Jersey
Here at Marita's there are plenty of good quality hard ice cream choices but only the usual vanilla, chocolate, & twist in soft. I prefer hard so I go with chocolate peanut butter, fudge brownie, almond joy, or cookie dough. They also have sundaes, shakes, frozen yogurt, water ice, hot dogs, soft pretzels & a variety of cones/bowls. Like most resort areas it is a bit pricey but not any more than similar establishments. I tend to return to Marita's since it is the most tasty in town. Be prepared to stand in line during summer evening hours, but it's worth it.
7. O'Donnell's Pour House
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 106 reviews
In 1999 the Ocean Drive proudly opened O'Donnell's Pour House right next door. As Sea Isle City's only Irish Pub, their focus is on an upscale casual dining experience, quality beverage and a pub like atmosphere where you can go to enjoy some live acoustic music, grab a perfect pint of Guinness and a booth for some conversation with your friends.
Reviewed By 45marianer
A quick look at the menu enticed us in. Outdoor seating for two was comfortable at 7:00 PM on warm July day. My order of short braised ribs with garlic mashed potatoes and fresh green beans was topped with chopped scallions in an attractive presentation, generous portion and delicious meal. My friend chose bruschetta which came as an amazingly grand plate of freshly chopped and seasoned tomatoes, onions and basil with thick slices of mozzarella, all garnished with toasted baguette slices and balsamic drizzle. The waitress and assistant wait staff were attentive and prompt. Dessert options are just as tasty. From food, to staff, to atmosphere, O'Donnell's is a guaranteed great place for dinner out.
8. Mike's Seafood & Dock Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 301 reviews
Where the Locals Go for Fresh Seafood! Mike's Seafood and Dock Restaurant - Helping Visitors to Sea Isle City create memories that last a lifetime!
Reviewed By Kelly B - Sea Isle City, New Jersey
Can't even tell you how many times we ordered crab legs from Mike's this summer. They were so good. Love their soups, crab balls and buffalo shrimp too! Even the chicken tenders are really good! Fun atmosphere, like the casual environment. Take out and restaurant are great!
9. Andrea Trattoria II
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 91 reviews
Reviewed By cindyvWeston_Ct - weston, ct
Based on reviews and location we chose Andrea Trattoria for our first night in Sea Isle City. Food and service were very good. The place was packed, so I was glad I made a reservation a couple of weeks in advance before Memorial Day weekend.
10. Hank Sauce
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 58 reviews
Reviewed By miscalane - Collegeville, PA
This place is awesome - food is quality, fresh & worth the prices! This time we got the pulled pork tacos, the black & blue burger, and a kids mac & cheese. All delicious & filling! Take out or eat in. It doesn't look like anything special on the inside but it is! Take some bottled sauce home to impress your friends! Ours always look forward to it!!
