Location: Mexico Beach
Top Restaurants in Mexico Beach
Most Popular Restaurants in Mexico Beach
Mexico Beach is a city in Bay County, Florida, United States. The population was 1,072 at the 2010 census. It is part of the Panama City–Lynn Haven area.
Things to do in Mexico Beach
1. Killer Seafood
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 707 reviews
Local Seafood "Dive" Restaurant. Hailed by Coastal Living Magazine as one of the top 50 Seafood dives on America. Fresh local seafood done right!
Reviewed By votfinoski - Middletown, Connecticut
After walking in this restaurant, you must place your order first at the counter before sitting down at an available table and then your order will be brought to you. Although this is a very popular restaurant, I would probably not go back. Service was good and very friendly service but I did not enjoy my meal as much as I expected to. My husband had a good grilled fish taco but my fried seafood platter was just ok but coleslaw was delicious.
2. Mexico Beach Sweets & Treats
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By flipflopcrazy - Coastal Georgia
First stumbled onto this awesome bakery in May when we visited. They have something I had never seen or tried, fried glazed croissants; like a doughnut but a croissant that has been deep-fried and glazed like a doughnut! THESE THINGS ARE AWESOME AND ADDICTIVE! Bought them all the week we were there and some to take home! We were back in August and I knew about them then so needless to say, they were on my list! Had a box at our rental for the week and ordered a dozen to take home! They are expensive but worth it! Also, this place has great ice cream, regular doughnuts and other pastries and pizza...but don't miss the fried glazed croissants!!!
3. Sharon's Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 306 reviews
Reviewed By Carol T - BH Florida
Staying in Apalachicola, we wanted to drive up to see the coastal waters of St Joseph Bay and Mexico Beach. We stopped in at Sharon's Cafe for breakfast and found the place adorably homey and the menu varied.
I had a combo meal with a Blueberry Belgian Waffle, ham and eggs. You can make your own combos there. So yummy and filling! Hubby had a similar meal. We both had endless coffee and a fun waitress. The only possible downside, if there is one, is you can't use credit cards. But sooo good- we'll be back!
4. Caribbean Coffee LLC
Overall Ratings
5 based on 45 reviews
https://www.facebook.com/CaribbeanCoffeeLlc/?fref=nf
Reviewed By Bob S - Duluth, Minnesota
If you want great coffee and incredibly delicious fresh cinnamon rolls, this is the place. This cafe has both inside and outside seating and sells a quality variety of teas, jams, sauces and salad dressings. I highly recommend stopping in.
5. Castaways Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 84 reviews
Reviewed By JTA74 - Texas
My wife and I stopped in for breakfast. She had the Southwestern omelet and I had the blueberry pancakes. The omelet was fluffy and served with salsa and fresh sliced avocado. Excellent. The pancakes were awesome- fresh blueberries with a crisp edge and perfect fluffy middle.
We returned for dinner. The broiled scallops were great- fresh in a spicy butter sauce. The grilled shrimp was the same.
Fresh food. Great service. Plain and simple, Castaways has the right formula.
6. Mango Marley's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 413 reviews
Reviewed By PoolBandit69 - Eunice, Louisiana
We got to Mexico Beach on a Monday afternoon late. We were hungry so stopped here to eat. It had almost a barroom feel to the place. With that and the old guy sitting at the bar with his whiskey and coke gazing around like a sandpiper on the beach, we took our food to go and are it at our rental house. The food was ok but there fried fish was really good. And a little over priced for what you get.
7. Toucan's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3.5 based on 1 reviews
Nothing complements Toucan's great, fresh seafood and refreshing tropical drinks like the cleansing salt air, gentle breezes and waves rolling onto the beach just steps from our door. The menu at Toucan's of Mexico Beach reflects exactly who we are. Toucan's of Mexico Beach Florida combines the three must-have ingredients for the perfect seafood restaurant experience: An amazing menu of the freshest Gulf of Mexico seafood, a fun, friendly family atmosphere, and ocean-side dining with a relaxing view of our white sand beaches.
Reviewed By MorganAndChristian - Ormond Beach, Florida
Local Oyster Rockefeller and fried shrimp were amazing along with a local draft from oyster city brewing out of Apalachicola! Service was good and the pristine view of the ocean could not be better. Just reopened from the winter months and well worth the visit!...MoreThank you for the great review! Come back soon.
8. Shipwreck Raw Bar
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 443 reviews
What better place than St. Joe Beach to be Shipwrecked. Luckily, the Galley is intact and the Ship's Cooks are preparing The Best Oysters, Seafood & Steaks on the Planet with a variety of Wine & Ice Cold Beer to quench your Castaway thirst. Rescue efforts take place seven days a week.
Reviewed By votfinoski - Middletown, Connecticut
Wonderful restaurant serving delicious fresh raw oysters and fresh steamed shrimp just about anyway you like. We chose garlic butter and old bay and it was great. Also had a cup of their homemade gumbo and it did not disappoint. Service was friendly and knowledgeable and efficient as well. Our server Joey was great. Beer was cold too!!
9. Beach Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 208 reviews
Reviewed By jamaicaboundin06 - South
The place itself is nothing spectacular, and we don't love the restrooms are on the outside behind the building but...the pizza was delish!
We ordered cheese bread, Greek pizza, and a stromboli. The cheese bread was hot dog bread baked with cheese, we'd pass on that next time. But the pizza and stromboli were really good! We didn't order a salad but they looked really nice.
We did get ice cream from their freezer after...which could be a really nice treat but the ice cream seemed old and grainy.
I would recommend ordering this pizza and having it delivered if I were going back. I think I would enjoy it much more.
10. 40th Street Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 107 reviews
Welcome to 40th Street Pizza, Inc. on Trip Advisor. There are new owners that bought the business on May 1, 2017. 40th Street Pizza, Inc. is a family owned and operated restaurant and we would love the opportunity to serve you and your family.<br>We thank those who have taken the time to order their food to go and those who come in and dine with us. You are all very special to us and we thank you for that. Hope to see you soon!!
Reviewed By Goldrockhunter - Fort White, Florida
We orders meat-lovers pizza one evening and Chicken Parmesan the next visit. The staff was very friendly and the food was very good. Next time in Mexico beach we would eat here againThank you for your great review. We greatly appreciate it. Hope to see you soon.
