Location: Circleville
Top Restaurants in Circleville
Top Things to do in Circleville
Most Popular Restaurants in Circleville
Circleville is a city in and the county seat of Pickaway County, Ohio, United States, along the Scioto River. The population was 13,314 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Circleville
1. Lindsey Bake Shop
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 60 reviews
Reviewed By Auburnfan76
I was in town for a couple of days for work & wanted to visit a couple of local places. After seeing the reviews & pictures, this was the first place I wanted to visit with some coworkers. Definitely coming back even being an hour and a half away. They have amazing thumbprint cookies. Nice 2 bite & very flavorful. I even got some donuts to try. The pumpkin donuts are wonderful. Great flavor with a not so sweet icing on it to make it overkill. It's perfect. Gotta try the strawberry filled too. It's pretty amazing.
2. Roosters Wings
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
Reviewed By Jmesis - Freehold, New Jersey
This is my second visit to a Roosters in one week. The food is simply delicious. The BBQ burger was perfectly cooked and the Dumpster Fries were amaxing, just wish they had added a few more fries. I recommend this location for lunch or dinner. Stop by, you'll be glad you did.
3. Wittich’s Candy Shop
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 57 reviews
In addition to delicious candy and nuts, Wittich's offers ice cream treats at our vintage soda fountain. Enjoy standards such as milkshakes, malts, cones and sundaes, as well as classic sodas and phosphates. The recipe for our decadent hot fudge sauce is a long-held family secret. Visit us and take a tasty step back in time.
Reviewed By Novakvicki - Circleville, Ohio
Family owned business that is one of the reasons still fantastic. Recepies are still made from the 1890. They put a soda bar in a while back that makes it very quaint.We're very glad you enjoy our "old fashioned" ways of making candies and serving ice cream treats! Thank you for the kind review.
4. Pizza Cottage
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 46 reviews
Serving Central Ohio since 1972 Pizza Cottage has strived, as always, to give you a relaxing, clean atmosphere with fast service and outstanding food.
Reviewed By Chops1971 - Columbus, Ohio
Difficult to believe that great pizza is hard to find in a city such as Columbus, Ohio. However, all the big chains seem to rule the market, and all of them are just.....ok.
Pizza Cottage is, without a doubt, the best pizza in or near the Columbus area. My husband and I are more than willing to drive the 45 minutes to visit Pizza Cottage........that is how good they are. If you haven't tried them, you must put them on your list!
5. Dairy Shed
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By lori a - Royal Oak, Michigan
We pulled up to find a boys little league team & families converging for some celebration treats. Sooo many soft serve flavors. The peanut butter was highly edible. Just loved watching those 6 year old boys, families celebrate. Good ole USA.
6. Richie's New Yo RK Corner
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By jeannie d
Best Reuben! Delicious Lite Delight!! Yummy mac salad and red potatoe salad on the side. Sensational small cannoli to finish. All started with Hola!! when we walked in the door!! Great suggestions from the experts behind the counter. Whoever Richie is, has it going on!!
7. Gibby's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 68 reviews
Reviewed By LuigiBasco - Melbourne, Florida
At Gibbys there are three in the kitchen who know what they're doing! If you're passing through Circleville and you're hungry this is the place to go. We were traveling through the town and couldn't find a place that looked convenient and had adult beverages and possibly good food. Gibby's had both in a clean and well-ordered atmosphere.
Our waitress was friendly, prompt and helpful! I ordered Bibby's burger medium, pink and it came out to perfection along with a generous helping of fries that were served in a little metal basket. They were as good as the fries I had in France which to me means they weren't cooked in old fat and were delicious.
My wife ordered the Southwestern wrap with vegetables and chicken that she proclaimed delicious as was the fresh cut cole slaw that accompanied.
She had a glass of Pinot Grigio and I opted for the Guinness and both were fresh out of the bottle and keg.. The special today was spaghetti and meatballs; all you could eat and the dishes looked enticing as they were carried to the tables. Four meatballs! We didn't see any seconds because the customers did indeed get all they could eat with one serving.
We won't miss this great spot when traveling through or close to Circleville.
8. Buffalo Wild Wings
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By JubileeJerry - Springfield, Ohio
We ate a late dinner here and I ordered the sweet BBQ salad. It was delicious. My wife ordered the sweet BBQ wings and they were good also.
The restaurant was a little loud as all Buffalo Wild Wings are late at night. If you can put up with the loud music the food is good.
Service was good also.
9. Bob Evans
Overall Ratings
4 based on 60 reviews
Reviewed By mallorybostwick
Nothing particularly outstanding or negative about this restaurant. The service is a little slow but the food is on par with other Bob Evans restaurants. I use the pick up option more than dine-in. It's not my first but sometimes chicken and noodles is just what the doctor ordered.
10. El Palomar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By Heather S - Surprise, Arizona
Needed a place for a graduation dinner that was relaxed and could accommodate large group. This was the choice and it was definitely a good one! Service was a little slow at first but got better.
All of us had something different from the menu which would be 13 items and we all loved our food! Prices were very fair and portions were very good! Would recommend for casual Mexican dining in Circleville.
