Where to eat Italian food in St. John: The Best Restaurants and Bars

September 4, 2019 Tynisha Seiler

Find out what Italian restaurants to try in St. John. Ecotourism is alive and kicking on St. John. There's more than enough to do on land, from watching for wildlife in the national park to hiking miles of trails or strolling sandy white beaches. Hit the water for amazing snorkeling, swimming, even underwater photography—of course. This is the Caribbean, after all.
Things to do in St. John

1. Extra Virgin Bistro

18-11A Estate Enighed Near the Round-About, Cruz Bay St. John Italian, American, Caribbean, Seafood, Mediterranean Brunch, Dinner, Late Night, Drinks Reservations, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Highchairs Available, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Accepts Credit Cards, Table Service [email protected] +1 340-715-1864 http://extravirginbistro.com
Food
Service
Value
Overall Ratings

4 based on 943 reviews

Extra Virgin Bistro

Reviewed By misshannahj1

So excited that Extra Virgin is open again after taking a break after low season. First night open and they are right back into the swing of things, doing everything with excellence, as usual. Service=impeccable, love sitting at the bar where the service is amazing and everything came out super fast. The spinach salad was delicious and as usual the shrimp and crab pasta was heaven with every bite!!! Thank you again!

Top 10 Bar food in St. John, Caribbean

2. Cafe Roma

1-C Parcel, 00831 St. John Italian, Pizza Dinner Takeout, Seating, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Accepts Credit Cards, Table Service, Wine and Beer [email protected] +1 340-776-6524 http://www.stjohn-caferoma.com
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
Overall Ratings

4 based on 373 reviews

Cafe Roma

Cafe Roma has served St. John since 1981. The restaurant has been voted "BEST ITALIAN CUISINE" in the US Virgin Islands, seven years in a row. Cafe Roma serves delicious Italian Trattoria-style cuisine with an extensive menu, full bar and has a vast selec

Reviewed By MelissaLondon

My husband and I were excited to try Cafe Roma and were soooo disappointed by not only the food but the ambiance, if that is what you call it! The restaurant is situated on top of a bar and it's not in a nice area what so ever. Cafe Roma is dirty, dated and has FLIES EVERYWHERE! We have eaten outside many times in St. John and have never seen this many flies and it is in an air conditioned closed room! The food was mediocre...I ordered the flat bread and pasta with brocolli in a wine sauce. My husband got a salad and the same pasta with chicken added. My flat bread was basic...bread with cheese melted. Nothing special. The pasta was terrible...neither one of us liked it. The wine sauce was just WINE...no flavor other than that, and bad wine to boot! Trust me, we have had way better experiences on the island! Stephanie was our server and the only redeeming part of tonight's experience! She was friendly and kept apologizing for the flies...so why don't they DO SOMETHING ABOUT THEM? I would highly recommend you go somewhere else for dinner, because this set us back $90 with tip and that was a CRIME!!Hello Sorry about your visit to Cafe Roma.We have had to restaff due to the off season and we are under renovation. And the worst part we let your party down.When you return again to St John please try us again.The meal is on us. I read your review to my new staff who had only been together for 2 days when you had dinner.It was a eye opener and we will strive to improve.

Best Pizza food near St. John, Caribbean

3. Pizzabar In Paradise

Rte. 107 Coral Bay Shipwreck Landing, 00830 St. John Italian, Pizza Dinner Takeout, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Serves Alcohol, Live Music +1 340-201-1183 https://www.facebook.com/pizzabarcoralbaystjohn/
Food
Service
Value
Overall Ratings

5 based on 45 reviews

Pizzabar In Paradise

A tiny little pizzabar {in paradise} serving up Boston/NY style pizza, calzone, salad, beer, wine, Sangria, cocktails and more.

Reviewed By Acemajorphi

We called ahead and took a few pizzas and a calzone back to the house we rented. They do have a few tables, but you may want to call your order in if you do not want to wait. They have a bar and we ended up waiting enough time for one beer. If you like to explore, come out and grab a bite.

Most Popular Caribbean food in St. John, Caribbean

4. Ronnie's Pizza & Mo

Boulon Center, Route 10 Just off the traffic circle, around corner from Dolphin Market St. John Pizza, Italian Lunch, Dinner Delivery, Takeout, Seating, Television, Serves Alcohol [email protected] +1 340-693-7700 http://www.hillcreststjohn.com/ronniespizza.html
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
Overall Ratings

4 based on 129 reviews

Ronnie's Pizza & Mo

Ronnie's Pizza an' mo' is just that ,pizza an mo. A little taste of home for the wayward traveler and locals alike . Featuring our Island famous pizzas along with salads,calzones,hot subs ,buffalo chicken wings , french fries an' mo' !!!! And for th

Reviewed By Steve H

On our night to “cook” for the 13 people we were vacationing with, we elected to get 4 pizzas and some salads from Ronnie’s. It was a hit! Pizza was really delicious - we had a meat lovers, cheese, pepperoni and a pep/sausage. All were great, but meat lovers was my favorite. 4 large pizzas and two salads was just a bit over $100, which on the island is downright cheap. We got ours as takeout, which was really easy to phone in the order and easily pick it up. We called several hours early and ordered for a specific pickup time. Everything was ready and appropriately hot/cold when we got there. Super easy and delicious, will definitely order from Ronnie’s again next trip.

Caribbean Food Guide: 10 American food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in St. John

5. Lucky Chops Lounge

5A Cruz Bay Quarter (in the former Fish Trap space), Cruz Bay 00831 St. John Asian, Sushi, Italian, American, Caribbean Breakfast, Lunch Outdoor Seating, Seating, Serves Alcohol, Table Service, Takeout, Reservations, Private Dining, Parking Available, Television, Full Bar, Wine and Beer, Free Wifi, Accepts Credit Cards, Live Music [email protected] +1 340-690-3868 http://luckychopsvi.com
Food
Service
Value
Overall Ratings

4 based on 63 reviews

Lucky Chops Lounge

Lucky Chops is a newly renovated private event venue located in Cruz Bay on St. John in the US Virgin Islands. The space is available to rent for private parties including weddings, corporate events, birthday or anniversary celebrations, or any special oc

Reviewed By viliver

The food is great but the service is terrible. When we arrived 30 minutes past opening time, the staff was milling about do things that should have been done before opening. They were still preparing the little signs about the daily specials that didn't reach the tables for another 30 minutes. No one approached our table to ask if we wanted anything for at least 15 minutes. We had to get assertive and stop a staff person as they tried to zip past our table. Finally someone came out and put a couple plates on our table and some DIRTY glasses but still did not take an order. Finally when our food arrived it was put down and the server zipped away. We had to stop someone else to ask for silverware and napkins. The bartender was horrible and I guess was responsible for serving the tables in the bar area. He basically ignored our table but was partying it up with a table of young ladies. They need a waiter that is responsible for the tables in the bar and the bartender needs to do bartender work. We had to wave him down more than once to remind him of drinks we ordered. We felt like no one was responsible for serving our table. I love the food but it was a frustrating dealing with the staff.First, we’d like to apologize that you did not thoroughly enjoy your dining experience at Lucky Chops; and thank you for sharing your experience with us. We always want to know if there are problems with our service so we can address the issues and correct anything that does not meet our guests’ expectation. If you are still on St. John we would like to invite you back in so we can show you what an amazing staff we do have and give you a better impression of Lucky Chops. If you’re willing to give us another chance please call into our office for a reservation at 340-690-3868 (Monday-Friday 9am-5pm).

Where to Eat in St. John: The Best Restaurants and Bars

ThingsTodoPost © 2018 All rights reserved.