Location: Brookville
Top Restaurants in Brookville
Where to eat Italian food in Brookville: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Brookville, Ohio, United States. Brookville is a small city in northwestern Montgomery County, Ohio, United States. The population was 5,884 at the 2010 census, an increase from 5,289 in 2000. It is part of the Dayton Metropolitan Statistical Area.
1. Sarah's Pizza
Reviewed By JnAMcGhee
We've been ordering Sarah's for many years and have not found a mashed potato pizza that comes close to theirs. Pizza dough topped with a GENEROUS portion of creamy mashed potatoes, fresh crumbled bacon, cheese, and if you wish, onions, it's topped off with sour cream (on the side). BEST choice you'll make! If you're in the mood for a meat pizza, their pepperoni and sausage pizza is very good as well. It's a bit more pricy and they don't run family-friendly price specials, but if you want a great pizza, it's better than a cheaper version at a chain-pizza place.
2. Marion's Piazza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 85 reviews
Reviewed By thouse1208
Went to this location to attend a birthday party. Most restaurants make special accommodations for birthday parties, but not this establishment. No extra help/support given to the hostess even though she had to order 10 pizzas to serve everyone invited to the party. No effort to make sure we had the needed plates or napkins or cups. We were treated just like the rest of the customers, and the place was packed, so made for a confusing start to the party. Not a place I would ever recommend to hold a birthday party.I did not find the pizza to be anything special, but then again, I prefer deep dish, Chicago-style pizza, To me, a thin crust pizza is no more than a cracker with some cheese, sauce, etc.
3. LaRosa's Pizza Englewood
Overall Ratings
3 based on 24 reviews
If you're travelling west on I-70, we're a convenient stop just off the Hoke Rd. exit. Of course, if you're from the neighborhood and you're just out shopping, we look forward to serving you, too! Select from our entire menu of LaRosa family recipes in ou
Reviewed By Oddmosis
First off I want to say that the food here is good, that's not the issue. A lot of people at ,my job started going here for their lunch specials. Now besides me and another co-worker decided to give them one last chance on 9-14-17 and after that we are DONE!! We got there maybe about 5 minutes the waitress came and took our drink order. Then about 7 or 8 minutes passed she took order. Now mind you there were about 6 other people there at the time dining. I looked as we were walking to our seats. And I said well they are not busy so we should be good on our lunch hour. We sat there for I know 30 minutes before being told that their ticket machine had wan out of paper and our orders plus another guest order did not make it to the cook. She asked if we were on break, she apologized and said her boss would make up for this issue. They said it would be about 5 more minutes and it would be out we said we will be late going back but we will wait because we were hungry. And they did bring out our salads about 15 minutes after getting there. Finally the food came out and my Chicken Ziti Noodles were not cooked all the way so it ruined the meal and at this point I was not about to complain. We got our bills and I could not believe the manger took a lousy $1.82 off our bill, are you frickin kidding me. That place need to get it together because it must be a bunch of younger kids running this place because it is not being managed correctly, they are lacking in a lot of ways. I will NEVER GO BACK there again during my lunch hour. I have never been there for dinner so it it's like lunch time they can forget it. Get your stuff together. It's very sad. I have had other bad experiences but yet I tried to give them another chance but you blew it big time.
4. Tony's Italian Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 124 reviews
Reviewed By ohioteacher
Tony's has been in Englewood for several decades. The food is good and the service fast and friendly. The only negative is the decor (wood paneling, lighting, wall decorations) is old and dated. The window blinds are dirty and many menus have seen better days. The restaurant is small,but always has customers as a testament to the quality and value at Tony's.
