Where to Eat in Commack: The Best Restaurants and Bars

April 14, 2018 Oliva Fomby

Commack (/koʊmæk/ or /kɑːmæk/) is a census designated place (CDP) that roughly corresponds to the hamlet by the same name in the towns of Huntington and Smithtown in Suffolk County, New York, United States, on Long Island. The CDP's population was 36,124 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Commack

1. Bagel Chalet

36 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY 11725-3409 Takeout, Seating, Wheelchair Accessible American, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options Breakfast, Lunch, Brunch +1 631-499-9820
Excellent
67%
Good
27%
Satisfactory
4%
Poor
1%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 88 reviews

Bagel Chalet

Bagel Chalet are the experts when it comes to fresh bagels in Commack. For delicious bagels, fresh wraps and salads- come explore Bagel Chalet!

Reviewed By Lois R - East Northport, New York

We've eaten here many times and the food and service is always great! From the salads (where you choose what should be in it), the creative sandwiches and of course, the best bagels around, you can't beat it! While the line sometimes is out the door, it goes very quickly because there are so many workers behind the counter. Don't miss it!

2. Pastrami N Friends

110 Commack Rd, Unit A, Commack, NY 11725-3461 Takeout, Seating, Waitstaff, Wheelchair Accessible American, Kosher Lunch, Dinner +1 631-499-9537
Excellent
62%
Good
26%
Satisfactory
9%
Poor
2%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 95 reviews

Pastrami N Friends

Reviewed By MonicaK614 - Deer Park, New York

I love this place. Since it's a Jewish deli/ restaurant everything is dairy- free. I sat at Rochelle's table. I love her. So sweet. So attentive. Complimentary pickles and slaw are served immediately. My friends and I all have the Canarsie: half sandwich with a single meat, fries or potato pancake and soup. I had pastrami. My friends had the tuna. We all had matzo ball soup for an extra charge. After, I had coffee and we split a brownie bar. Everything was delicious. Upon checking out, I had such a nice conversation with Ron, one of the men upfront. Everyone at this restaurant is so kind and loving.

3. Andrea's 25

6300 Jericho Tpke, Ste 7, Commack, NY 11725-2831 Reservations, Seating, Waitstaff, Parking Available, Television, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Takeout Italian, Gluten Free Options Dinner, Late Night, Drinks SGD 39 - SGD 39 +1 631-486-7400
Excellent
49%
Good
37%
Satisfactory
12%
Poor
1%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 93 reviews

Andrea's 25

Reviewed By Joe P - Dix Hills, NY

We revisited Andrea’s and it only seems to get better. We had the artichoke arancini and it was “oh my god” good. My entree was the seafood risotto luciano. My wife had the shrimp Lilliana which she really enjoyed. Overall it was a great meal and I highly recommend Andrea’s.

4. Premier Diner

690 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725-5404 Takeout, Seating, Waitstaff, Parking Available, Television, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol American, Greek, Diner, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Brunch, Late Night +1 631-462-0886
Excellent
32%
Good
39%
Satisfactory
18%
Poor
5%
Terrible
6%
Overall Ratings

4 based on 218 reviews

Premier Diner

Reviewed By TheYelllowDart

Stayed at a nearby hotel and we decided to stop here for dinner. This restaurant is busy, which tells you it’s a local favorite. The menu has something for everyone as they have a huge offering. The portions are gigantic and almost comical. The desert options should not be overlooked. Plan on taking a doggy bag home! Our waitress was amazing - attentive, funny, and made our dinner a fun experience. Would highly recommend.

5. LA Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria

34 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy, Commack, NY 11725-5410 Takeout, Reservations, Seating, Waitstaff, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options Lunch, Dinner +1 631-499-6049
Excellent
57%
Good
28%
Satisfactory
8%
Poor
4%
Terrible
3%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 121 reviews

LA Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria

Reviewed By Cathy C - Moriches, New York

Having visited this reliable gem of a restaurant for many years, I realized I hadn’t reviewed it yet. I came here for my New Year’s Eve early dinner and had a marvelous meal. The lobster bisque was outstanding ( not always available), the broccoli rabe with portabella mushroom and sausage was fabulous and I would recommend the veal saltimbocca with hard boiled eggs. My friend ordered the seafood Fra Diablo (medium heat) over penne. I tasted it and the pasta was al dente and the sauce delectable. They have outstanding decaf coffee and the polenta cake is “ to die for”. It has booths and tables. It’s intimate and the staff is welcoming. On Monday night from 5:30-8:30, they have a singer who plays the standards. She does requests. They do a very nice job for small family parties or retirement dinners( 20-30 people). It also has a casual area in the front for the best thin-crusted pizza in the area. The owner and management are very caring. When you have visited here over the years, they will treat you like “your family”. Definitely worth a visit for quality food, good value and accommodating service.

6. Sangria 71

1095 Jericho Tpke, Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725-3001 Takeout, Reservations, Seating, Waitstaff, Television, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar Spanish, Latin, Mediterranean, European, Seafood, Vegetarian Friendly Lunch, Dinner +1 631-670-7606
Excellent
60%
Good
24%
Satisfactory
10%
Poor
4%
Terrible
2%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 82 reviews

Sangria 71

"Tapas and More by brothers from Spain" Sangria 71 serves up a large selection of authentic Spanish Tapas, Sangria and savory Paella in a festive casual atmosphere.

Reviewed By LuCi-CMH

We were a group of 10 that went for tapas dinner. We ordered multiple things to share as our meal. Service was friendly, though they got a few orders wrong (chicken instead of beef empanadas, stuffed mushrooms instead of shrimp, etc).
Best things: white lightening sangria, croquetas, pan tumaca, almond stuffed dates wrapped in bacon.
Cons: food came out of the kitchen quickly but was COLD! The pulpo a la Gallega was a bit rubbery and lacked the traditional potato accompaniment, the chorizo was sliced so thinly it was difficult to appreciate the full flavor, calamares a la romana seemed to be from a freezer bag, stuffed clams were average, and unfortunately, the saffron rice was horrible - dry, cold, and lacking flavor like it was out of a box with a few peas added.
Pricey for the amount of flaws.

7. Mannino’s Italian Kitchen & Lounge

2158 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725-2905 Takeout, Reservations, Private Dining Italian Lunch, Dinner +1 631-462-0909
Excellent
47%
Good
33%
Satisfactory
12%
Poor
4%
Terrible
4%
Overall Ratings

4 based on 163 reviews

Mannino’s Italian Kitchen & Lounge

Reviewed By nymg17 - Smithtown, New York

The waitress accidentally spilled a drink all over my wife’s pants. She apologized often and replaced it. The 4 of us split 2 apps, ordered 4 entrees and split 2 desserts. We all had a drink each. When the bill came, the only item taken off the drink spilled. We left a normal tip yet approached the waitress. She told us that the restaurant doesn’t make concessions like comping desserts etc... She told us to not tip her. We would not stiff her. The owners are known for this. The restaurant takes no reservations and is noisy. The food is ok but is pricey. Make sure that you wear a bib because the restaurant may only pay for your dry cleaning bill.

8. Taormina

34 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY 11725-3409 Takeout, Reservations, Seating, Waitstaff, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner +1 631-499-6900
Excellent
52%
Good
40%
Satisfactory
5%
Poor
3%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 52 reviews

Taormina

Reviewed By Vicki S - Commack, New York

Consistently very good pizza and Italian food. Service is friendly albeit sometimes a little slow. Worth the trip !

9. Nisen Sushi

5032 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725-2815 Takeout, Seating, Waitstaff, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Reservations Japanese, Sushi, Asian, Gluten Free Options Dinner, Lunch SGD 41 - SGD 66 +1 631-462-6868
Excellent
54%
Good
31%
Satisfactory
10%
Poor
5%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 87 reviews

Nisen Sushi

Reviewed By LongIslandFlan - New York

I'll make this quick. The sushi is okay but there are much better sushi restaurants, just not nearby. The problem is the place smells like fish and for me that is death for a fish place. I love the decor, but now I can't even get takeout as when I walk in -- fish.

10. Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

6401 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725-2832 Takeout, Seating, Waitstaff, Television, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar Italian, Bar, Pizza, Pub Lunch, Dinner +1 631-858-2625
Excellent
46%
Good
31%
Satisfactory
13%
Poor
6%
Terrible
4%
Overall Ratings

4 based on 91 reviews

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Reviewed By Andy Wilson - Billericay, United Kingdom

Visiting at 7 pm on a Wednesday evening, Anthony's was busy and noisy with a good atmosphere. The food was excellent; meat balls with ricotta and simply cooked wings to start, followed by a large half and half thin crust pizza (margarita one side with Italian sausage and mushrooms on the other). More than enough for the 3 of us to share. Good selection of draft beers and wines at sensible prices (e.g. Californian Sauvignon Fume at $33/bottle towards the high end of the list). Very friendly and efficient service from a local student (Victoria?) on recess from university. A very enjoyable meal.

ThingsTodoPost © 2018 All rights reserved.