Top Restaurants in Anna Maria Island
Where to Eat in Anna Maria Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
The quaint feel of Anna Maria Island makes it the perfect place to eat grouper sandwiches and kayak with dolphins. While you’re here visit Bean Point Beach, tucked away on the north end of the island — a cozy paradise with an Old Florida vibe. Then hop on over to Anna Maria Bayfront Park, which includes sweeping views of Tampa Bay and the iconic Sunshine Skyway. Numerous beaches, restaurants and events make Anna Maria Island the perfect relaxation spot for your next vacation.
Things to do in Anna Maria Island
1. Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 598 reviews
Authenticity is the key for us at the Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus™, and we strive to bring you the best in traditional German and Austrian cuisine. Our menu includes various versions of schnitzel, roasts, sausages, potato pancakes, brats and of course, German Gemutlichkeit (German hospitality). No question, we only serve the best German beers and wines. The atmosphere at the Schnitzelhaus™ is like what Anna Maria Island is for Florida: Fun, laid back, simply “gemutlich”. Come hang out and enjoy yourself on one of the wooden tables or by enjoying a or two beers or wines at the bar. Schnitzelhaus™ is the “Wirtshaus” where you gather with your friends, your date or even your grandmother. All are welcome, and all are encouraged to stay a while. We, the owners of the Schnitzelhaus™, are proud of what the Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus™ Team started bringing to the Island some 15 years ago. We want to keep their heritage and take the German spirit on Anna Maria Island up to new generations. So all will know what German food and spirit stands for in today’s world and what it means to enjoy a fantastic Schnitzelhaus™ night.
Reviewed By Randy K - Bradenton, Florida
Tasty, authentic German food and beer. However, service was ridiculous. Bread is served one slice at a time, as if rationed. Three different people, including the owner tried to take our bread plates and butter away from us. In class restaurants, you’re asked “would you like more bread.” This place pretends to be welcoming, but but the staff is intrusive and controlling. We will NOT go back.
2. French Table
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 265 reviews
We are a family owned and operated restaurant that specializes in French cuisine. We are from Toulouse in the South of France. Christophe is the chef and works only with local markets, and fresh products. He makes his special french bread everyday. We also have wonderful wines coming directly from France. Come to see us, our daughters and I will be glad to welcome you! Bon appétit!!
Reviewed By bostonpike - Philadelphia burbs
So we made the mistake of heading down to restaurants around 6 on Bradenton Beach during spring break. Went to three different places and the waits were '2 hours' (Beach House), 1:40 (Cantina) and 1 hour. Kids and wife were getting hungry and frustrated. About to go home, we run across this place that had seats available. WINNER! But despite this really being the 4th place finisher on places we were interested in, the dinner was a winner.
Kids were able to have food they wanted - pasta for one and a tasty chicken/mushroom dinner for the other - and the wife and I were able to have adult food. We loved the Duo de mer appetizer, the combination of the ingredients was tasty and different than we'd usually try. I had the grouper. I really liked the mango combination with the fish and the wife thought her poulet forestier was nice and moist.
An unexpected place served up a delicious meal that left everyone satisfied with there meal and was served in a relaxed but timely manner.
3. Ginny's and Jane E's Cafe and Coastal Store
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 1 reviews
We are located in the Historic City of Anna Maria, a quaint "Old Florida" area on the north end of Anna Maria Island. Our store is a unique collection of local art and interesting finds. We provide beach supplies, like suntan lotion, sunglasses, flip flops and other items to help you have fun and stay comfortable while at the beach. At Ginny's & Jane E's you will hear the sound of people enjoying a meal together with their friends and neighbors. Our cafe offers you a great breakfast and lunch menu. We bake our yummy cinnamon rolls from scratch each morning. We focus on fresh and natural ingredients. All our oink, clocks and moo's are the preservative and chemical free, from cage free eggs, no hormone and steroid free chickens ,to grass fed beef, we care about what we serve.
Reviewed By km198 - atlanta
I love this place. You walk through a very cute gift shop full of goods by local artists to get to the restaurant, then you must stand in line to order. If you see an open table someone in your party can go sit while you order. Despite quite long lines to order we had no trouble getting a table either time we were there since many people are getting take-out. Everything is fresh, Local, and homemade. The sticky buns and creme brûlée french toast are to die for, the veggie burrito was loaded with veggies, and the skillets and pancakes are enormous.
4. Blue Marlin Grill
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 951 reviews
Tele: 914-896-9737. Best food on Anna Marie Island.
Reviewed By musthavebeachsun - Iowa City, Iowa
First, after reading all the reviews we had high hopes for our dinner. We just couldn’t catch a break with this one. We seated five persons at a little bitty table, even with reservations. Four of us had the seafood soup, it was devoid of flavor and the seafood was scarce. One person had the potato soup and loved it. This is the reason for a 3 vs 2 rating. The wait staff was initially attentive and then disappeared. The food was overpriced and thoroughly underwhelming. Getting a second cocktail was difficult. We left unsatisfied and feeling bewildered by the TA reviews of this restaurant.
We will not return.
5. Waterfront Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 2 reviews
Our regular menu is based on the finest products we can find and updated seasonally. They are prepared in classic form, with emphasis on fresh, natural flavors.
Reviewed By BigSisIndiana - Indiana
Gave this 2/5 rating mostly because of our waitress. Our food was delicious and the portions were generous. Our dealings with the hostess was easy and pleasant. Unfortunately when it came to ordering our food and drinks, our waitress was disorganized and seemed more put out by our large party rather than pleasant and accomodating. Our food came out in a timely manner and was very good, however this was tainted by her unfriendly demeanor. As families that vacation together regularly, we are familiar with the issues of large parties and most waitresses are very helpful and flexible. Specifically when it came to ordering and spltitting the check, she informed us that she could not split the check between the three parties, stating that we were split up between three tables. (we were right next to one another) This was not explained at the start of our meal and we all agreed that we have never been to a restaurant that was unable to split the check. This goes directly back to the original sentiment that she was not flexible and seemed inconvenienced by our large party. I would reiterate that our expectations with a large party and a busy restaurant are reasonable and we understand the long wait and crowded atmosphere. However, we expected better service and a more pleasant experience from a highly rated restaurant.
6. Peach's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 545 reviews
Serving breakfast and lunch for over 20 years! Open daily from 6AM to 2:30PM, closed on Christmas Day and Thanksgiving. Locally owned and operated, stop in today and find out why we call ourselves fast, fresh, and friendly!
Reviewed By Bob H - Grand Rapids, Michigan
Saw all the great ratings for Peaches so we stopped in one morning during our stay on AMI. Had a very friendly server and had an excellent breakfast. Four different breakfast meals and everyone agreed they were very, very good. Though quite busy there was no attempt to hurry us on our way. High marks for that. An excellent place to stop for breakfast, and I would imagine their lunch would be equally good. Another place I will happily return.
7. Two Scoops
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 885 reviews
Two Scoops offers 32 flavors of delicious hand-dipped, homemade ice cream. Shakes are made to order with so many flavorful combinations! A full breakfast and lunch menu with a side of chips, candy, dips, coffees, gourmet treats and more! Be sure to try our world famous chili cheese dog for just $1.99. Two Scoops is located in Bayview Plaza - at the north end of Anna Maria Island right across the street from the Anna Maria City Pier.
Reviewed By TnTWalter - Indy
trash can flavor seems to be a hit. there's something about getting ice cream on vacation. also love the gift shop next door.
8. Beach Bistro
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 1 reviews
Beach Bistro has been Anna Maria Island’s romantic fine dining destination for 26 years. Located beachfront, looking out on the Gulf of Mexico, the scenic waterfront backdrop and spectacular sunsets make it the perfect place to celebrate special occasions or simply relax after a long day.The Beach Bistro boasts the highest Zagat ratings for food and service in the state of Florida and is currently the eight-time recipient of Florida Trend’s Golden Spoon Award. It is also the twelve-time recipient of the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence.The mission of the bistro is simple: to provide you with one of the best dining experiences that you have ever had.
Reviewed By Nicole G - Lexington, Kentucky
We went this week for my fathers birthday with 4 other couples. Sean was very nice to accommodate a party of 10. First of all I want to say the service was impeccable! Sarah did a fantastic job with our large, sometimes demanding, group. I had the salmon app which was unbelievable! Must order again! My friend said the seared scallops in bouillabaisse sauce was great. I can’t describe every meal because it would take too long but the restaurant never disappoints. We had the bouillabaisse, food heaven, lamb, shrimp and duck. Everyone loved their meal! Always try to come when we are in town. I want to try the Dr. Office next!
9. The Feast Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 851 reviews
The Feast Restaurant is a family owned and operated establishment opened in 2009. Brothers Joseph and Christofer Dale are the Chefs and Owners and you will always find one or both of them in the kitchen during service. We strive to offer our customers the freshest local and exotic cuisine in a warm family friendly atmosphere. We have a large selection of wines from around the globe and feature the islands largest craft and Microbrew beer selection. Open for lunch and dinner daily, reservations are recommended for dinner or large parties.
Reviewed By annmarie02151 - Revere, Massachusetts
This restaurant is in a strip mall, but don’t let that keep you away. The seafood is fresh caught and the dishes are delicious. We started with escargot and a beet salad, both were excellent. We both had the grilled hogfish with Brussels sprouts. Accompanied by a nice bottle of Acrobat Pinot Gris, this was a memorable experience
10. Vinny & Cheryl's Italian Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 328 reviews
Gourmet Take-out Lunch and Dinner Italian Bakery, Deli, Italian Market, Pizzeria and Catering for all accasion
Reviewed By ace091 - Saratoga Springs, New York
For me, the test of real Italian food are two dishes - Bolognese and Eggplant Parmigiana. This place passed both with flying colors. Great Bolognese with perfectly done pasta, and Eggplant Parm with the eggplant done so that it kept some texture and an incredible sauce.
This place will be a regular for Italian take-out. Solid menu, Vinny cares very much about what he serves.
Salute!
