Location: Westerville
Top Restaurants in Westerville
Where to eat American food in Westerville: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Reviews on American food in Westerville, Ohio, United States. Westerville is a city in Delaware and Franklin counties in the U.S. state of Ohio. It is a northeastern suburb of Columbus. The population was 36,120 at the 2010 census. Westerville is the home of Otterbein University.
Things to do in Westerville
10. Westerville Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 82 reviews
Breakfast all day. Great diner food. Everything is fresh and delicious.
Reviewed By Tom B
Had breakfast here mid-morning recently during the week for the first time and had a choice of seating. Located in the heart of Westerville it is a classic diner- checkered flooring, simple tables for 2 or 4, limited counter seating, open service area - whose biggest distinguishing feature is a covered outdoor seating patio in warmer weather. The menu is somewhat smaller than many diners but extensive enough to satisfy most desires with slightly higher prices by not unreasonable. We had the corn beef hash and a twist on this classic of chorizo and hash with coffee. The portions were quite large topped with our choice of three eggs and toast or biscuit. Neither of us finished and we were offered to box it up to go. Both were made with fresh ingredients rather than the "canned" hash found in many diners. To satisfy my sweet tooth and as a throw back to my childhood ordered the "mush". Was surprised the entree was three "croquet" rounds sliced from the commercial cornmeal logs of mush rather than the nice sized rectangular slices usually associated with homemade. The service was diner casual, friendly, and attentive. Our coffee was refilled several times. Open until 9 pm most evenings serving breakfast all day with many traditional lunch and dinner diner favorites. Because of its downtown location parking could be an issue.Will definitely return and possibly try one of the lunch selections.
9. Delaney's Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 34 reviews
Jeff and Lisa Miller are the business owners and also an active part of the Westerville community. They have one daughter, Paige, who attends Westerville North HS. The home is shared with 4 rescue dogs who pretty much rule the roost. 'We have lived in the
Reviewed By travelrelaxrepeat
Upon entering I was greeted with the smell of fresh brewed coffee. The diner is a modern remodel with a old time look. It has plenty of seating and there was no wait for lunch. The server was happy and helpful. The only negative that knocked off a star for me is the lack of a gluten free menu or any indicators on the menu of what doesnât contain it. Ordering was a stab in the dark. I went with the eggs, bacon and hash brown combo. It was good! The price was very low too!
8. Northstar Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 60 reviews
Reviewed By CharlesP899
Dropped by Northstar with my wife.Sat at the bar, very comfortable, quiet enough to carry on a conversation.We ordered two pizzas and two cocktails.A vodka Buck for my wife(like a Mule) and a Makerâs Manhattan for myself.Good quality drinks at a $8.00 price point. A good value and very tasty.I ordered a pepperoni pizza with their homemade fennel sausage- excellentMy wife ordered a Foote pizza , cheese pizza with shaved Parmesan and a lemony green salad on top. She just raved about it.They even dropped off a free sampler of chips with house made pimento spread, very tasty!Friendly bartenders and servers, great quality food and drinks in a pleasant environment.Hard to beat!!!
7. Texas Roadhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 144 reviews
Texas Roadhouse is a steak restaurant providing legendary food with legendary service. Texas Roadhouse specializes in hand-cut steaks, fresh-baked bread, fall-off-the-bone-ribs, and made-from-scratch sides. We also serve ice cold beer and legendary margar
Reviewed By Mmadison66
Hubby & I stopped during the week for dinner about 530-545pm. We found it unusually crowded for a weekday! We were able to get seated & ordered a few minutes after 6pm. The waitress got our order in right away, so each meal was $8.99. Hubby raves over chicken critter salad & I had sirloin with sauteed mushrooms: includes 2 sides too They usually have happy hour specials or drink specials till 7pm. Call ahead to get your name on waitlist prior to arriving, even during the week!
6. Old Bag of Nails Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 148 reviews
Reviewed By 539_Keith_P
Nice atmosphere and friendly staff. Ample parking in rear. 2 non - alcoholic O'Douls, fried pickles and mushrooms for 2 for just over $43. A great deal and we'll worth another visit.
5. Eddie Merlot's Columbus
Overall Ratings
4 based on 293 reviews
At Eddie Merlotâs hospitality and the comfort of our guests are our highest mission; we pledge to provide the finest service, highest quality foods, in world class facilities for our guests to enjoy a memorable experience. Eddie Merlotâs features USDA Pri
Reviewed By T5493HFjessicaw
I recently visited Eddie Merlotâs after a couple of years and Iâm still pleased with the ambience, service and quality of food. We had the calamari appetizer and the filet mignon king crab oscar with a side of Eddieâs scalloped potatoes. The steak was perfectly cooked and delicious. For dessert we had strawberry shortcake-it was much larger than expected and quite good. Add a few glasses of wine and the bill gets hefty but itâs well worth it. Iâm glad to see that this restaurant is still at the top of their game even after Jeff Rubyâs opened.
4. 101 Beer Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 87 reviews
Locally & Family owned business serving the suburban communities of Dublin, Westerville & Columbus w/ scratch made food, craft beer & delicious cocktails. 101BK exists to provide seasonal, handcrafted products alongside friendly service with an uncomplica
Reviewed By SGMPhil60
I found this place online when visiting the Columbus area and decided to try it. They have a nice selection of craft beers, a comfortable atmosphere, and friendly staff. I tried one of the beers that was recommended by the bartender and it was okay, but not really my style. She should have given me the option to taste test it, which was obviously an option as the staff was taste tasting beers in front of me while I was there. I was not really hungry so I ordered the calamari appetizer. Considering the $13 price tag, I figured that would be some good calamari, I was wrong - the dish was lacking calamari, had mostly veggies, and was heavy on breading. Bottom line: I spent $23 on one beer and an appetizer that pretty much sucked. I must say that the food that others were getting delivered looked much better than what I got, and the beer selection is impressive, so I am not writing this place off completely.We can definitely understand why your visit was disappointing! This is certainly not up to our standards. We do offer tastes if a guest requests to but generally the staff is well trained on the products we offer and can guide guests successfully but obviously this did not work well in your case. We do hope to see you again as we have many awesome products! If anything is ever not up to par or your liking please let one of our team members know during your visit so that we can make it right and get you something that you love!
3. Polaris Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 329 reviews
Reviewed By Ewald G
Wonderful service from an adult. Good bar service. Excellent food and white tablecloths to boot. Was looking forward to their dessert menu, but the large servings were so good that â¦Good value and will return when in the Columbus area.
2. Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 173 reviews
Rusty Bucket is a casual American restaurant and tavern, a gathering place where people come to share laughter, smiles, and great conversation over food that makes everyone happy. Satisfying and familiar, the menu is classic American fare, thoughtfully pr
Reviewed By gefilte63
I moved from Columbus a year ago and ate at the Rusty Bucket every now and then. The new menu is quite an improvement. I had the Tuna Wrap--marinated tuna steak--and it was great. Fried pickles awesome as well.Good dessert too. My daughter and I split the daily special strawberry shortcake.This is a good place for an informal meal.
1. Uptown Deli and Brew
Overall Ratings
4 based on 166 reviews
Reviewed By Jim L
Smoke salmon is tops. Deli case with desserts, meats, cheeses,etc. Eat in the bar area, the front deli area or in warm times the quiet patio out back where Mario, the owner, keeps a collection of gorgeous blooming flowers. Located in uptown westerville, there are many interesting shops to walk to after your dining experience.
Most Popular Italian food in Westerville, Ohio, United States
