Location: Rutherford
Top Restaurants in Rutherford
Where to eat American food in Rutherford: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Find out what American restaurants to try in Rutherford. Rutherford is a borough in Bergen County, New Jersey, United States. As of the 2010 United States Census, the borough's population was 18,061, reflecting a decline of 49 (−0.3%) from the 18,110 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn increased by 320 (+1.8%) from the 17,790 counted in the 1990 Census.
Things to do in Rutherford
10. Blarney Station
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By wiilovethebeach
Great bar, great bar food! My party was 4 people, one had an awesome burger, one had a burger with bbq on it, fabulous, one had a roast beef sandwich, she said it was wonderful, and I had the cheese steak. Now the Cheese Steak was truly something I was so sorry to finish...it was the BEST!!! Now if you are thinking of philly cheese steak, not the same, this one is a real nice piece of a whole steak, not shredded, but when you bite into it, it is like butter...no ripping or tearing it. Just an amazing taste of something SOOOOO tender, covered in cheese and I added mushrooms, which made it perfect. The fries were tasty, and what made them even more tasty was I asked for a side of gravy. The gravy was delicious! We ended with a giant piece of the most decadent chocolate cake...lovely! Can't wait to go back ASAP!!! Friendly waitresses and quick service too. I'm not a beer drinker, but my buddies all enjoyed the extensive selection of beers they have on tap. This is really a great spot, can't believe haven't been before!
9. Steve & Andreas
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By JoeG_52
I have eaten at Steve and Andreas several times and have always had a great experience. I especially enjoy breakfast and really love their fruit filled pancakes. They tend to resemble crepes with the fruit added directly to the batter. This gives them a really nice flavor and texture as they melt in your mouth. Combined with a hot cup of their fresh brewed coffee its a hearty breakfast you'll really enjoy.
8. Candlewyck Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 177 reviews
Reviewed By EdM734
I have been here for 30 years. New modernized diner now. This was my 5th diner this trip and is the best. Clean and great service. I had the Steak Cacciatore special. I assumed it would be a few pieces of steak but when it arrived it was a perfectly cooked strip. I loved it. My daughter tried to steal it. She had the traditional chicken cacciatore. It was excellent as well. My wife had a huge Waldorf salad, which she thought was very good. This is a top level NJ diner. I highly recommend it.
7. Sonoma Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 47 reviews
Reviewed By Dan D
Bad diner food. rock hard calamari, fishy. burger was slightly larger than a slider. You would do better buying frozen food and microwaving it. NOT a "bistro." It really was terrible and I rarely call anything terrible. I rarely write reviews but Sonoma deserves one. Save your money.
6. The Shannon Rose
Overall Ratings
4 based on 126 reviews
The Shannon Rose Irish Pub combines Irish roots with a commitment to our community. The interior of the pub is entirely composed of furniture and decorations shipped directly from Ireland, but our chef-driven, scratch-made menu incorporates seasonal & loc
Reviewed By 592keshiaw
Stopped in for a quick bite to eat. This restaurant came recommended by a friend. The food and drinks were very good. Our server was Madeline and when asked for suggestions, hers were on point. The drinks were a lot bigger than expected and the was a welcomed surprise. Even if you stop in for appetizers, it is worth the trip.Hello, we are pleased to hear that Madeline was able to make your dining experience wonderful and that you enjoyed your drink choices. We canât wait to serve you again.
5. The New Park Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By Number1NolesFan
I have been to The New Park Tavern three times now. The first was sort of a last minute decision as my regular watering hole had a power failure and the kitchen was closed. The last two tomes because I really like the food and atmosphere. A large round bar with 35-40 bar stools in the center with another 15 or so high top tables in the front area and a large low table seating are in the back room make for a larger place than I am used to. The menu is extensive, I have had the wings, a Calzone and the Genaro steak hoagie and they were all exceptionally good. The one concern on food was the buffalo chicken tenders, mushy with a ton of vinegar (READ CHEAP HEAT) and a small portion equals an unhappy experience. The next day, the wings were terrific, so fix the chicken tenders issue....Very personable staff, knowledgeable and friendly. Quick to offer suggestions and recommendations based on preferences, very helpful.My first couple of trips, I sat at the high tops and got a bill for food and beverages, when I sat at the bar, I had the bartender send a waitress over for the food order and received two bills. As this place has been around since the 1930's, I would think they could get this worked out...All in all, a very good experience with a few points that could be better, but a good enough experience and value that I keep going back.
4. Biggies Clam Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 163 reviews
One of three New Jersey locations of the Biggies clam bar chain.
Reviewed By suzeq71
Poor service...waitress said she forgot she had a table to serve...inexperienced staff.. had to ask for utensils...food mediorce...not sure about going back..
3. Rutherford pancake house
Overall Ratings
4 based on 88 reviews
Reviewed By Robert B
Late breakfast for six people with one gluten free and one vegan. Good variety of choices for all. Mainly tables for two, but after a wait we were taken care of and service was good.
2. Colonial Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 134 reviews
Reviewed By stewartc787
Out for dinner. Great service. Great food. Large portions. Huge menu, food for all three meals. Awesome eggs Benedict. Great braised short ribs. Super sandwiches and lots of coffee refills. Once again service was outstanding and very friendly. Another great Jersey diner.
1. Rutt's Hut
Overall Ratings
4 based on 484 reviews
Reviewed By psudino
While others wine and dine their business relationships on steak and sushi, I bring them to Rutt's Hut. I tell them where we are going and what to expect and most people are excited to go to a local legend. The best part is that when I see them again, Rutt's Hut is almost always brought up. A steakhouse or other fancy restaurant is commonplace in the business world. Nothing is common about Rutt's Hut; quite possibly the best hot dogs on the planet!
