Location: West Caldwell
West Caldwell Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in West Caldwell
West Caldwell is a township located in the West Essex area in northwestern Essex County, New Jersey. It is located approximately 16 miles (26 km) west of Manhattan and 6 miles (9.7 km) northwest of Newark. As of the 2010 United States Census, the township's population was 10,759, reflecting a decline of 474 (-4.2%) from the 11,233 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn increased by 811 (+7.8%) from the 10,422 counted in the 1990 Census.
1. Cloverleaf Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 248 reviews
Reviewed By TonyK300 - New Jersey
A permanent fixture in the area, this place has been featured on TV as well as earning a great reputation for good food and reasonable prices. Although it's an essentially Irish Pub the menu options are more robust and very tasty.
I've never been able to get past the burger selections they have because they are huge as savory - try the triple Double if offered - then go to the gym.
Lively at night and weekends and parking is sometimes difficult, it's worth the effort especially in the warm season when their delightful rear outdoor seating area is open.
Clientele and staff are friendly and the atmosphere is casual. Always a great place to go in the area.
2. Cinar Turkish Restaurant 2
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 50 reviews
Reviewed By KidLove - Pennington, New Jersey
Had the Ayran Yogurt drink, Red Lentil soup and the Hunkar Begendi which is a classic Ottoman dish of lamb or chicken in a light tomato sauce over warm eggplant puree. Very delicious. The bread they serve here with oil is also very good. Esengul my waiter was patient and helped me with the food selection. Great place for a good meal.
3. Jose Tejas
Overall Ratings
4 based on 338 reviews
Reviewed By Framm617 - Parsippany, New Jersey
Amazing Tex-Mex! Never leave disappointed. The wait can be a little long, but that just shows you how great this place is. It's a cozy and comfortable mardi-gra atmosphere and the margaritas and chips/salsa are top-notch. One of the best in the area!
4. Starbucks
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 5 reviews
Reviewed By Quinnscommentary - Chatham, Massachusetts
Friendly staff, good fast service. Nice environment to sit, work, chat. They get to know regulars and you don't even have to order, they know what you want. Sandwiches prepared promptly. Nice variety of seating which is appreciated.
5. Sorrento Bakery
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 65 reviews
Reviewed By Artsyfran
Both the deli and the bakery (breads) are wonderful. The Italian bread is always fresh. As another reviewer noted, be prepared to wait in line, this place is always busy. Their Easter bread is soooooo delicious, and I patiently wait for that each year (only made at Easter time)!
6. Dough Artisan Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 89 reviews
At Dough, we have a deeply rooted passion for hand-crafted cuisine. Our philosophy means sourcing the finest & freshest local ingredients to provide our patrons with an authentic dining experience. We are proud to partner with local farmers & promote sustainability within our community. Our approach to food is simple: Use fresh ingredients, use the best techniques, & remain focused on the smallest details.
Reviewed By Quinnscommentary - Chatham, Massachusetts
Great service, friendly people from start to finish. Very well organized. Soup of the day was delicious, but a tad salty.
Pizza was different, true wood burning oven. Very tasty; thin and crisp. You have to have a taste for this type of pizza.
Unfortunately, very noisy.
7. Calandra's Mediterranean Grill
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 129 reviews
Reviewed By rayej - Clifton, New Jersey
I was a guest here for a 60th birthday party. The establishment was impeccably clean and beautifully decorated. Our food was served buffet style. Everything was delicious! The dessert platter of Italian pastries was to die for. This restaurant is inside of Hampton Hotel and nearby are two other Calandra's businesses so be sure to get the address for the right establishment. TIP: For some odd reason, the hosts were not allowed to bring home the leftover food that was paid for. So, establish this with management before booking in order to prevent any issues.
8. Pf Market Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 63 reviews
Reviewed By Jax12122015 - Roseland, New Jersey
First the service was horrible. Sat for 15 min after we were given menu, thought we were invisible. This happened all night we had to flag down a different waitress to get dessert menu and only 3 tables occupied
Food very disappointing, the fra diavlo sauce was not at all spicy, way too much salt and over cooked shrimp. Also pricey, for what they charge should be perfect. Have noticed the food is never consistent. Had chocolate lava cake for dessert, they need to look for a recipe because I had chocolate cake with Hershey syrup warmed and topped with ice cream, cake was so dry. Don't know if I would go back. Acoustics are bad can't hear any one at your table talking.
9. Divina Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By David T - Seattle, Washington
Have been frequently visiting family and doing business in the north New Jersey area from Seattle WA for many years, and always include a dinner at Divina Ristorante. A wonderful place that meets (and exceeds!) all the characteristics of a top quality dining experience: outstanding menu, top rate food preparation, delightful staff, and always a warm welcome. Its very popular with only a few tables, so it's a must to book a reservation in advance. Bring your own wine (there's a good value wide selection wine shop just across the street).
10. The Original Pancake House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 79 reviews
Reviewed By Luvs2TravelAnywhere - New York City, New York
This place is awesome. There was no line on a 90 degree Saturday morning in September which was a treat. Huge menu with huge servings - every dish comes with a side of pancakes so bring your appetite. The egg white vegetable omelette is baked in the oven, largest I have ever seen, and delicious. Pancakes are consistently good.
