Location: Cooperstown
Top Restaurants in Cooperstown
Top 6 Italian food in Cooperstown, Otsego, New York
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Cooperstown, Otsego, New York. Located in the foothills of the Catskills Mountains, Cooperstown is proud to be a one-stoplight town, with quiet streets and charming old homes, sitting amidst the natural beauty of Otsego County. The area is home to the National Baseball Hall of Fame, the National Soccer Hall of Fame, the Fenimore Art Museum and the Glimmerglass Opera. Otsego County is also a popular destination for activities as diverse as antiquing, horseback riding and golf.
Things to do in Cooperstown
6. Slices Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By Rico944
Stepped in for lunch on a Monday after induction Sunday. There was a large group of kids with an organization ,the staff had the slices and drinks ready and moved through about 30 kids and parents in no time.I deceided to stay and enjoy a slice and a cold root beer.The slice was great! almost bought some ice cream but the nise level was too much too handle,but everyone had fun!
5. Sal's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 430 reviews
Reviewed By HeatherG115
We enjoyed lasagna, chicken parm, pizza and wings over both of our visits. The food was delicious and affordable. They even offer a gluten free pizza for those that are gluten sensitive (when I called ahead they told me of the gluten free options when I asked but advised there is a lot of wheat flour there and to take that into consideration based on our gluten sensitivity level). The staff are accommodating but not Disney level cartoon character friendly. I donât think that would have fit with the vibe of the restaurant though. We enjoyed our meals on the back deck.
4. Toscana Italian Fusion & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 408 reviews
Reviewed By Memmett
Had dinner here with family and really enjoyed our meal. Tables big enough to accommodate 7 easily. Nice appetizers and something for everyone on the menu. Would recommend for a very fine yet casual meal right on the Main Street in Cooperstown. A great find!
3. New York Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 373 reviews
Great Little Pizzeria Restaurant Located In The Very Popular Village Of Cooperstown Ny Home To The Baseball Hall Of Fame...
Reviewed By corys946
This is just a short walk from the Baseball Hall of Fame passed Abner Double Day Field and is totally worth it for the buffalo Chicken Pizza.
Where to eat Cafe food in Cooperstown: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Nicoletta's Italian Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 662 reviews
Reviewed By mamacooking
Nicoletta's is very casual and comfortable with good Italian food. We can't remember what we ordered but, although not memorable, we do know that we both left happy. Our server was friendly and efficient. The only negative to our experience was that we saw a waiter setting up new tables carrying water glasses by putting his bare fingers in them.
1. Bocca Osteria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 857 reviews
Casual dining in a contemporary atmosphere. Serving Italian fusion dishes and wood fired pizzas.
Reviewed By BruinSeniorTraveler
At the suggestion of TripAdvisor, we followed up a day at the Baseball HOF with a dinner at Bocca Osteria. It is a bit misleading because it looks from the outside to be a bar-food, small restaurant. However, inside, the top-quality food was excellent. We started by sharing the BLT Chopped Salad. It is a full-meal, entree salad meant to be shared. It was well presented, fresh, and had a wonderful mix of flavors -- with a spring lettuce mix, crispy bacon chunks, grape tomatoes, chilled corn and shredded mozzarella topped with a light house-made ranch dressing. Our waiter (who was excellent), James, made a number of suggestions that were very helpful. My wife had Risotto Alla Pescatora, which was a large bowl of braised baby shrimp & scallops, roasted cherry tomato, mixed with spinach risotto and served with a whim truffle cream sauce. It was very good and far too much for anyone to finish. I had the Napoli Panini -- a piping hot panini filled with a salty mix of prosciutto, Genoa salami, sopressata, all melted into fresh mozzarella, spread with a pesto aioli spread. Just as a personal taste, I had him hold the roasted red peppers. The sandwich was served exactly as requested.
Otsego, New York Food Guide: 3 Healthy food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Cooperstown
