Top 10 restaurants in Shelter Island, United States

April 14, 2018 Layne Dawes

Shelter Island is a town and island at the eastern end of Long Island in the U.S. state of New York. It is part of Suffolk County, although it is separated from the rest of the county by water. The population was 2,392 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Shelter Island

1. 18 Bay

23 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Reservations, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Waitstaff, Parking Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options Dinner SGD 33 - SGD 131 +1 631-749-0053
Excellent
81%
Good
14%
Satisfactory
4%
Poor
1%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 128 reviews

18 Bay

18 Bay is a Chef owned and operated restaurant. We serve a four course Italian inspired Chefs menu that is a direct reflection of the local markets. Dinner begins with four different antipasti, followed by a handmade pasta, a choice of entree and dessert. The menu changes every week. We make handcrafted cocktails using organic syrups, serve local wine including two on tap, as well as international wines from small producers. We offer a vegetarian menu and accommodate for any allergies or aversions. We look forward to sharing with you our interpretation of the best of our terroir.

Reviewed By Jean C - Rockville Centre

The food was delicious. Chef's tasting menu on the night we visited consisted of a tasting of four expertly prepared appetizers including beets, incredibly fresh striped bass sushi with cucumber noodles, roasted smashed truffle parmasean potato and grilled lamb. Pasta course was a spaghetti with red clam sauce that was really more of a red clam broth over salty pasta; we chose as our entree wonderfully prepared fresh Atlantic Halibut. The Almond cake dessert had a delicate flavor and fluffy texture. The service was excellent.

2. Lucharito's

119 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944-1563 Takeout, Seating, Waitstaff, Television, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Accepts American Express, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Free Wifi, Accepts Discover, Accepts Credit Cards Mexican, Southwestern, Latin, Bar, Spanish, Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options Lunch, Dinner, Late Night SGD 13 - SGD 26 +1 631-477-6666
Excellent
62%
Good
28%
Satisfactory
6%
Poor
3%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 213 reviews

Lucharito's

We will be CLOSED Jan 22 - Feb 1. Both Locations. Reno & Relaxation. See you for lunch Friday the 2nd!

Reviewed By buzzinaround - Atlanta, Georgia

I've eaten here twice. Most recently got the nachos. Very tasty and way too much food. One small quibble is that they used cheese sauce instead of actual cheese. This place can get really crowded in the season, so don't go really hungry.

3. Marie Eiffel Market

184 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island, NY 11965-2003 Wheelchair Accessible, Takeout, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Street Parking, Accepts American Express, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Digital Payments, Accepts Discover, Accepts Credit Cards American, Cafe, Delicatessen, Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Brunch SGD 7 - SGD 39 +1 631-749-0003
Excellent
54%
Good
32%
Satisfactory
8%
Poor
1%
Terrible
5%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 123 reviews

Marie Eiffel Market

Marie Eiffel Market is your local cafe and market for fresh baked goods, organic produce, groceries, artisan meats, imported cheeses, locally-sourced fish, chef-prepared deli sandwiches, salads, and hand-rolled pizza right here on Shelter Island. Bring our fine foods home with you, stay and enjoy our cafe, or sit out back with a dockside water view.

Reviewed By David R - London, United Kingdom

Stopped at this beautiful quaint cafe on Shelter Island whilst staying at Sag Harbour. The food and service was excellent - it was wonderful and so peaceful sitting outside on the waterfront. Well worth the trip.

4. North Fork Table

57225 Route 25, Southold, NY 11971-4704 Reservations, Seating, Waitstaff, Parking Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar American, Gluten Free Options Lunch, Dinner, Late Night SGD 33 - SGD 51 +1 631-765-0177
Excellent
76%
Good
15%
Satisfactory
7%
Poor
1%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 306 reviews

North Fork Table

Reviewed By KatieMargaret - Brooklyn, New York

We were there on an off season Saturday night (our anniversary), and had a really nice, quiet, evening. We both had the 3-course menu with a wine pairing. The waiters were excellent, and all of our dishes were very good. By the end of the meal, we were too full for two desserts but the cookies can be taken in a to-go bag. We took them, and we ate them for days.

5. The American Hotel

45 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963-3012 Reservations, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Waitstaff, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Free Wifi American, Gluten Free Options Lunch, Dinner, Brunch, Breakfast, Late Night SGD 54 - SGD 105 +1 631-725-3535
Excellent
52%
Good
30%
Satisfactory
11%
Poor
5%
Terrible
2%
Overall Ratings

4 based on 287 reviews

The American Hotel

Reviewed By FlaGolfer55 - Pembroke Pines, Florida

I took my father to have dinner at The American Hotel and the food was excellent. Of course, we had the traditional Thanksgiving dinner but the wait staff performed flawlessly. A couple of observations though. First, the hotel does not have dedicated parking. You park on the street or in a little alley way adjacent to the hotel. For Thanksgiving this would be no problem but when the summer crowd arrives, parking is at a premium. The second is that it was just a tad chilly in the restaurant. Everytime someone arrived, the cold air seeped through the restaurant.

6. Hellenic Snack Bar & Restaurant

5145 Main Rd, East Marion, NY 11939-1667 Takeout, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Waitstaff, Parking Available, Television, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Wine and Beer, Reservations Mediterranean, Greek, Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options, Vegan Options Lunch, Dinner, Brunch, Breakfast +1 631-477-0138
Excellent
56%
Good
30%
Satisfactory
9%
Poor
1%
Terrible
4%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 202 reviews

Hellenic Snack Bar & Restaurant

Hellenic Snack Bar & Restaurant in East Marion, NY serves authentic Greek cuisine and a great selection of local wine, local harvest and local seafood on the North Fork of Long Island. The portions are plentiful and great for all occasions! We offer year round indoor dining and either full outdoor dining or covered outdoor dining in our enclosed pavilion. It is heated and available year round for catering. We also cater off-premise in your home, on the waterfront or at your favorite winery.

Reviewed By MIAP377 - New York

Place has good food with good service and is very clean. The only downfall to this place is that it's expensive. I'm giving it three stars for the pricing not the quality of food.

7. Vine Street Cafe

41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Wheelchair Accessible, Reservations, Seating, Waitstaff, Parking Available, Free Off-Street Parking, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Accepts American Express, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Takeout, Outdoor Seating American, Gluten Free Options, Vegetarian Friendly Dinner SGD 54 - SGD 105 +1 631-749-3210
Excellent
56%
Good
30%
Satisfactory
10%
Poor
3%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 202 reviews

Vine Street Cafe

Reviewed By MinCam

My husband and I went to Vine Street and had a wonderful meal. We went on Monday evening and the special was Bouillabaisse. We decided to share a salad and the Bouillabaisse. The mozzarella and heirloom tomato salad was delicious and the Bouillabaisse was outstanding and just right for the two of us. The atmosphere is casual and pleasant. The staff and service was top notch. We will surely come back when we are in the area.

8. Southold Fish Market

64755 Route 25, Southold, NY 11971-4746 Takeout, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Parking Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol American, Seafood, Soups, Gluten Free Options Lunch, Dinner +1 631-765-3200
Excellent
71%
Good
22%
Satisfactory
7%
Poor
0%
Terrible
0%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 124 reviews

Southold Fish Market

Reviewed By PAM_from_LINY - NY NY

Southold Fish Market is located in a convenient spot right off the main road with plenty of parking, in a relatively recently built facility. The fresh fish never disappoints and there is a wide selection of fish and shellfish, along with frozen and refrigerated sauces, spreads and selections. The spreads are great for party appetizers. On the opposite side of the store is a dining area--most of the menu is fried seafood and fried sides, better than bars in the area but the preparation does not take full advantage of the freshness of the fish. The servers in general - both in the raw store and the dining area - are young and impatient. During the summer season when this place is busy, they can be surly, giving the eye as you select the fish you'd like to purchase, even if you are placing a large order. There is a large garbage hamper in the parking lot and during hot summer months there have been times it stinks badly, the seagulls love it, though.

9. Sterlington Deli

3 Sterlington Cmns, Greenport, NY 11944-1630 Takeout, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Wheelchair Accessible, Accepts American Express, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Free Wifi, Delivery, Parking Available, Accepts Credit Cards American, Delicatessen, Vegetarian Friendly Breakfast, Lunch, Brunch, Dinner +1 631-477-8547
Excellent
82%
Good
13%
Satisfactory
3%
Poor
1%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 126 reviews

Sterlington Deli

Reviewed By Ashton S - Mashpee, Massachusetts

My husband and I stopped here for lunch before beginning a wine tour of the area, and it was superb! As soon as we walked in, Freddy, the owner, the was very kind and told us a bit about the menu. Once he found out...MoreThank u Ashton! I hope you had a great time at the vineyards! Stop in to see us again on your next trip to the NOFO.

10. Page at 63 Main

63 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963-3012 Takeout, Seating, Waitstaff, Television, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Accepts American Express, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Free Wifi, Accepts Discover, Reservations, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Accepts Credit Cards American, Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options, Vegan Options Lunch, Dinner SGD 20 - SGD 55 +1 631-725-1810
Excellent
45%
Good
36%
Satisfactory
12%
Poor
5%
Terrible
2%
Overall Ratings

4 based on 237 reviews

Page at 63 Main

Page: Restaurant is a modern American restaurant in the heart of historic Sag Harbor. In addition to our Aquaponic Garden, where fresh organic produce is cultivated in-house, renowned Executive Chef James Carpenter engages local farmers and fisheries to bring the best of the East End directly to your table. Page: Restaurant provides a relaxed and elegant atmosphere with a year-round atrium room and seasonal outdoor dining.

Reviewed By Qwickrick - Amagansett, New York

Page is open year round which might explain it’s consistently excellent food and service. Menu is varied with interesting daily specials. We recently had their daily special, duck two ways, which should be added to the menu as it was perfect.

Another outstanding dish is their fish or shrimp in a curry sauce. We have had it several times, and great preparation with veggies and sticky rice.

ThingsTodoPost © 2018 - 2024 All rights reserved.