Top Restaurants in Eleuthera
Top 10 restaurants in Eleuthera, Bahamas
The tranquil pink and white sands of Eleuthera beaches are the perfect remedy for any weary traveler. The Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve is an educational experience in beautiful disguise. No visit to Eleuthera is complete without a peek at the unique “glass window,” where the dark blue Atlantic bumps right up to the aquamarine Caribbean Sea. Hire a guide to show you the splendor of the island’s many mystical caves.
Things to do in Eleuthera
1. Tippy's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 888 reviews
Reviewed By Octlt
Call ahead for Reservations as it can fill up. Right on the beach so good to go when it’s light. Lots of regular dishes and specials, mostly local seafood. One of the best meals we had on the island. They also have pizzas but the are only listed in the bar.
2. Buccaneer Club
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 412 reviews
Reviewed By Emma B - Kingston, Ontario, Canada
I have been to Eleuthera many times and had somehow missed this amazing restaurant (new favourite!). Buccaneer Club is nestled under a massive tree, with lots of shaded outdoor Seating and some indoor Seating as well. We were a group of 10 and were quickly and easily accommodated. We ate around brunch time and everyone found something delicious to eat. They offer lots of true Bahamian dishes. I highly recommend the stew fish. I had been looking forward to finding this dish during our trip and now can’t imagine eating it anywhere other than Buccaneer Club! You MUST go.
3. Pammy's
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 97 reviews
Reviewed By abacogirl16
We've been going to Eleuthera for six years now, but this was our first time trying Pammys. Went for a carry out lunch. Great local Bahamian dishes, sandwiches, burgers, etc. The prices are the best on the island. Fast, friendly service. There are a couple of tables where you can eat in. We took our order and enjoyed our lunch outdoors at one of the picnic tables on the water where Da Fish Fry is held. Will definitely be frequenting this place on our next visit!
4. The Rainbow Inn Seafood & Steak House
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 461 reviews
Experience tranquilities at The Rainbow Inn Boutique Resort, where quality, style and tailored service come together. Our hotel accommodations surrounded by lush Gardens perched on the edge of the Caribbean Ocean, take relaxation to another level. Just steps away from our award winning Restaurant, specializing in fresh catch seafood, certified angus beef, woodfired pizza and organic produce, enjoy weekly live entertainment, sophisticated cocktails and unrivaled sunsets.
Reviewed By IowaRod - Iowa
They currently have pizza night on Mondays and Thursdays. Reservations are required. There is a band too. The wood oven grilled pizzas are great and one pizza will easily feed two hungry adults. The service was friendly but they messed up our order.
5. Sammy's Place
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 88 reviews
Reviewed By Ron T - Greenville, South Carolina
Stopped in here to get some sandwiches on our way to Lighthouse beach. Great friendly service, sandwiches were good.
6. Laughing Lizard Cafe
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 133 reviews
The restaurant is located precisely on Google Maps at 25.400986,-76.563503
Reviewed By trac655 - Dayton OH
Stopped by on a Saturday when traveling from North Eleuthera to Rock Sound. While the appearance does not stand out, the food does. Four in our party and we had a variety of lunch sandwiches: Italian, Mushroom, and BLT. All were hot, fresh, tasty, and unique. The desert was a key lime pie that rivaled any I had ever had.
The staff was friendly, helpful, and timely.
If in Eleuthera, try it!
7. Front Porch
Overall Ratings
5 based on 250 reviews
Reviewed By NHSeaurchin - nh
Give me something good and real and unpretentious. Add a beauty of a setting in a relaxed aquamarine world, add cheerful, intelligent conversation, a pile of the day’s haul of stone crab claws... and the peace to enjoy.
A treat to eat at the Front Porch, Eleuthera.
Everyone around was having a good time, gentle, relaxed, and hearing the sea .
Best wishes to the genuine lovely couple who own the place.
Cheers!
8. Daddy Joes
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 207 reviews
Queen's Highway North, 1 mile south of Glass Window Bridge, 3.5 miles north of Gregory Town. Two Story Building, white trimmed with yellow.
Reviewed By Delish45 - Saint Louis, Missouri
Based on TA reviews, we stopped for lunch. Very limited menu and mediocre food. Indifferent service. Maybe it’s better for dinner, but definitely would not go back for lunch.
9. da Perk Coffee Shop
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 265 reviews
Serving Lavazza espresso & coffee drinks, fresh fruit smoothies, pastries, hot/cold breakfasts and gourmet salads and sandwiches. Beer, wine, Goombay Smash and Bloody Marys.
Reviewed By Dan V - Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Great place for cup of coffee! This may be the only place in Governor’s Harbor where you can get a cup of coffee. Hard to find, but worth the effort.
10. The Shipyard Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 200 reviews
Fine waterfront dining in Spanish Wells! Fresh cooked food with a modern twist. Serving Lunch and Dinner Wednesday through Sunday
Reviewed By Anton P - Bolzano, Italy
Finally a restaurant on the island with a beautiful view. Been there for the second time and really enjoyed it. Excellent food, service and reasonable prices. We had the Pork griot and the Pork Cubano, a Kalik, 2 Perriers and 2 espressi for 62 $...MoreThis review makes us smile so much - this is the exact reason we opened the Shipyard! Thanks so much for leaving such a nice review and making us feel like we achieved what we set out to! Hope we will see you back soon!
