Location: Callicoon
Top Restaurants in Callicoon
Countries
Top 10 restaurants in Callicoon, United States
Callicoon is a town in Sullivan County, New York, USA. The population was 3,057 at the 2010 census. The town is in the northwestern part of the county.
Things to do in Callicoon
1. Peppino's
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 108 reviews
Reviewed By Butchy11 - Boston, Massachusetts
While staying at nearby Villa Roma my companion and I went exploring. With few dinner choices in this small town, we thought we were settling for a pizza shop! Instead we were pleasantly surprised to find a first class Italian restaurant behind this modest store front! We were seated in a plush booth but would have chosen the outdoor seating if it were earlier in the evening. I opted for the tasty meat lasagna and an IPA draft beer with its fresh head was the perfect compliment. My companion was very happy with her veal. Service was excellent and the pricing was reasonable.
2. Ollie Grey's
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By chanele05 - Callicoon, New York
I went there on a Sunday afternoon with my son and ordered one of the specials. The grilled shrimp and bacon wrap. A girl took my order and then a few min later brought me a basket of shrimp and fries. Because I don't like confrontation I just let it go. Next time I decide to go best believe I'm double checking the order
3. Dutton's
Overall Ratings
5 based on 6 reviews
Reviewed By RoseDunmorePA - DunmorePA
My husband and I took a nice motorcycle ride along the PA side of the Delaware River and happened upon this beautiful area of Tyler Hill. Not only did we enjoy the scenic country and winding roads, but the topper was a stop at this small town diner. Their burgers were awesome, their homemade pies were wonderful and the owner was so friendly. Some say, "it's not the destination...it's the ride...well this stop was well worth it !
4. Stone Arch Inn
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By RFela - Pahrump, Nevada
Ordered 2 bowls of soup, an iced tea and a soda. Bill was $18.39. Asked about bill and was told drink refills are not free. This should be stated when you ask for a refill. Will not return for dinner here. Just a warning to others.
5. Matthew's On Main
Overall Ratings
4 based on 90 reviews
Reviewed By E D - Bluffton, South Carolina
The food was a great surprise. The flounder was beautifully prepared. All 4 guests were pleased with their dinner. The desserts were freshly made, the blueberry pie was outstanding. The only downside was the noise level. Bread was not served. The brunch menu looked look you such give it a try.
6. Dianna's Place
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 6 reviews
Reviewed By Vijaysinghdesimone - Damascus, Pennsylvania
visited this restaurant twice this month and I have to say they have been consistent with the buckwheat pancakes and our friends enjoyed their omellettes and home-fries. They need to change the brand of coffee they serve, it is never fresh tasting. Otherwise, it is a great place for breakfast and the pies are awesome.
7. Ted's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 45 reviews
Reviewed By BobAdams111 - Hoboken, NJ
We went for breakfast during our stay at Villa Roma. The food here was great and the service was better.
8. Villa Roma Resort
Overall Ratings
4 based on 130 reviews
Reviewed By shoots4themoon - Manchester, Vermont
Meals at the VRR were plentiful and the pastries were to die for-great service but sometimes food was overcooked.
9. Tavern on Main
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 15 reviews
Conveniently located right on Main Street, Tavern on Main is Sullivan County's newest community restaurant. Specializing in American fare that is both comforting and healthy.
Reviewed By Eileen1943 - South Fallsburg, New York
Had dinner with friends. The restaurant was jumping; not a free table in sight. Terrific waitress, Jessica, patiently and efficiently and most pleasant, took care of this somewhat picky group. Each dish was really special - the scallops, crab cakes, the ribs, the trout, etc....MoreThat you for your kind words! We are glad we were able to leave a good impression!
10. Callicoon brewery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 68 reviews
Reviewed By Richard H
We took a road trip from Brooklyn upstate and finished in Callicoon. What a spectacular drive, especially I guess during autumn.
We were looking for somewhere to have a drink and came across this superb pub. In fact it’s much more... there is also a micro brewery within the pub !
The place is just so interesting with highly original artefacts and the place has a great feel. The TV played UK premiership football whilst we were there... very homely.
But the atmosphere was so welcoming, we could have stayed all afternoon.
Tip, do take your camera, there are great photo opportunities within the pub and you will not be disappointed. The beers are great too.
So interesting, and a real unique experience. We loved it, and I guess you will too.
