Location: Sayreville
Top Restaurants in Sayreville
Top 10 Pizza food in Sayreville, New Jersey, United States
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Sayreville. Sayreville is a borough located on the Raritan River, near Raritan Bay in Middlesex County, New Jersey, United States. As of the 2010 United States Census, the borough's population was 42,704, reflecting an increase of 2,327 (+5.8%) from the 40,377 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn increased by 5,391 (+15.4%) from the 34,986 counted in the 1990 Census.
Things to do in Sayreville
10. Brother's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 44 reviews
Reviewed By ZERO-NONSENSE
Brothers Restaurant, Middlesex County, NJ1020 State Route 18, North, East Brunswick, 08816-4302732-254- 7171 NOW THAT is Little Italy Italian. You want REAL The Bronx Little Italy Arthur Avenue ZESTY SAUCE Italian, but don't want to travel to The Bronx's Famous Arthur Avenue. Then, IF you happen to be in Middlesex County New Jersey off State Route 18 Northbound, stop in to Brothers. IF you enjoy ZESTY Tarty spiced sauce on your REAL Italian meals, then this is the place to stop for huge portion zesty Italian sauce meals at phenomenally low prices. I am calling to your attention by repeating ZESTY/ TANGY, simply because, at least once, each time we go there to 'scratch' that REAL Italian yen, but don't want to travel to The Bronx' famous Little Italy Arthur Avenue, and, we go to Brothers, we always here someone bring back the food and say it's just not for them = TOO TART/ TOO ZESTY/ TOO TANGY.... fair-enough... everyone has regional preferences; and while one dresses up to please others, you DO eat TO PLEASE YOURSELF! amen!So, let's be specific in my summary praise.YOU find yourself in Middlesex County New Jersey?YOU find yourself near State Route 18 Northbound in East Brunswick?You find yourself having a yen for genuine Italian food with that zesty, tarty, tangy flavor then stop off at Brothers East Brunswick for zesty, tangy, Meatballs "to-die-for", zesty, spicy pasta dishes you have to take home after stuffing yourself and engorging yourself totally satisfying your palate.you order, take a seat, "tractor trailer" seems to parks in front of your table with tons of food! BEWARE! you are not the only one who wants that magnificent zesty food. Bring your patients and be prepared to wait during peak times. Everyone else thinks it's well-worth the long waits on line to enjoy their meals.... IF you are also, and, again, you love ZESTY Genuine Italian Food that rivals Little Italy Arthur Avenue Bronx, then you will not be the least disappointed.AMEN! BON GUSTO
9. Si Mangia (formerly F & J Pizza and Deli)
Overall Ratings
4 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By C D M
While in the area for work I came across F & J at lunchtime. The owner greeted us as we walked in the door. Offered many different choices for a quick and what turned out to be tasty lunch. One thing they had that kind of too me by surprise was homemade bread which was MUCH better then I thought it would be. I wound up having a sandwich which was very good, fresh and pretty tasty. NOT a bad choice if in the area.
8. Frank's Pizza Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By windsgroup
Our son loves to visit whenever heâs in town. However, everything was different including the poor service, food quality, cleanliness. Something has gone seriously wrong from a management perspective. Why do I say this? Here are the facts. We ordered two slices of pizza. One slice came as a plain slice with mushrooms and cheese thrown on top. Thatâs what was not ordered. When we questioned the order, the server and chef took offense by saying thatâs how itâs made. Wrong!! We know what should have been done to fill the order not just dress up leftovers for sale.My meal failed to come with soup or salad until we questioned the order. Finally a bowl came at the same time as the entrees. It was tasteless and too hot. The entrees were no different for our family. What a disappointment!! Even the portion size was reduced. There were very few patrons during dinner time. Something has changed and itâs not good. No recommendation here.
7. Giddy's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By Gary S
The pizza was very fresh and delicious.Their website says they also offer baked ziti, fish, salads, French fries, but they were nowhere to be seen when I walked in.You may have to ask for those.and its kosher.The ambience does not exist, so this is not a great place for a first date or to bring business associates.But if you want good pizza, this is the place.
6. Bella La Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By Jan R
This is a small place with a small parking lot. Inside is a typical style pizza area and a separate dining room. We had a 15 minute wait.The food is very good. The meals come with a large salad and bread that tastes freshly made. Typical Italian dishes. The waitress came to every table and gave each diner a sample half slice of pizza. The slice we tasted was very good. The service was decent but a little slow.
5. Rustoni's Pizza
Overall Ratings
5 based on 23 reviews
Reviewed By joee5
Family ordered from here previously,several times. Today was my first time and will not be the last. My dinner was simple, baked ziti. But this one, unlike their competitors whose name begins with a âCâ, was better. It was cheesier, the sauce was just right and not overpowering and the noodles were perfect and not soggy. I thoroughly enjoyed my dinner today. Located in a strip mall, ample parking. Interior very, very clean with nice decor. Staff actually smiled and were pleasant. One came over and held the door open for me as I was leaving. Saw a nice display of several varieties of specialty pizza. Itâs the small things as the above mentioned that will bring repeat customers back over and over again. Oh and I noticed a delivery person so you can call in your meal and have it brought to your front door. Recommended and Iâll be back.
Where to eat Seafood food in Sayreville: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Camillo's Italian Restaurant Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 98 reviews
Reviewed By Barry S
We have been eating at Camillo's for more than 12 years. Dinners, lunches, parties, you name it we did it here. The food is exactly what it is supposed to be.. great food, friendly prompt servers, very reasonable prices in a welcoming comfortable restaurant. I can't guess how many times I have eaten here, how many dishes I tried, but it has been many and I have NEVER been dissatisfied, and NEVER left hungry (and almost always with a doggy bag full of food that tasted just as delicious the next day). The owners are the chefs, and are delightful friendly people. I just enjoyed another marvelous dinner of shrimp scampi with spaghetti in the same sauce and I am still smiling about it. Worth the trip to Jersey, and worth the visit to Camillo's.
3. Mikes Pizza and Catering
Overall Ratings
4 based on 92 reviews
Mikes Pizza was started in 2014 with a "Good Food Fast" menu concept and specializes in many varieties of hand tossed extra large Neapolitan, deep dish, and Sicilian style pizza baked in our state of the art brick-lined stone hearth ovens. Dough is made f
Reviewed By Venture11868556523
We order from Mikes at least one a month. Great pizza, apps, entreeâs and great customer appreciation with the constant coupons offered.
Best Fast Food food near Sayreville, New Jersey, United States
2. Nunzios Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 92 reviews
Award Winning Gourmet Pizza & Authentic Italian Cuisine
Reviewed By PaulaNYFL
Our first choice was closed for renovations so I found Nunzioâs and other TA members gave it great reviews. We sat in the dining room for a nice dinner. Merry our server was awesome, bubbly and service with a smile. I ordered large grilled seafood (calamari, baby shrimp & fresh mushrooms) -fantastic!!! Grilled to perfection & just a touch crispy-perfect. Taking 3/4 of it home for lunch tomorrow. Hubby had chicken parmigiana, small order-which was very large -the red sauce on his was delicious. Overall, this is place the type of place we crave on Long Island but canât find anymore. We need to be in the area for a few days and will come back for a pizza. Glad we came and experienced a piece of our childhood!!
Top 10 American food in Sayreville, New Jersey, United States
1. Mancini Brooklyn Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 117 reviews
Reviewed By EmJayBV
The carne pizza is really very good, beaten only by Franco Peppe's (we eat pizza often). The eggplant pizza was good - could do with more eggplant on it though. The large pizzas are enormous but being delicious nothing goes spare. We ordered through ubereats and wouldn't hesitate to order from them again.
Most Popular Deli food in Sayreville, New Jersey, United States
