Location: Thunder Bay
Top Restaurants in Thunder Bay
Top 10 Italian food in Thunder Bay, Ontario, Canada
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Thunder Bay, Ontario, Canada. A vacation in Thunder Bay is about immersing yourself in natural splendor. Lake Superior, Sleeping Giant Provincial Park, and all manner of outdoor sports are at your disposal here. Fort William Historical Park’s costumed interpreters bring the region’s history to life for kids.
Things to do in Thunder Bay
10. Angelo's Pizza and Sub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By Ross D
Overall I have to say this is one of the best values in Pizza in Thunder Bay. Fresh ingredients great crust and an 18 inch with unlimited toppings for $20 how can you go wrong. If you have not tried them what are you waiting for?
9. Pizza Hut
Overall Ratings
3 based on 43 reviews
Reviewed By 1FOXYKAT
Had a 10 pan pizza of the day. It was DELICIOUS and only 10 bucks which is a steal. It was also not as greasy as Pizza Hut usually is so that was great!Gluten free crust..... hard and dry so meh. Stick with the original, thats what Pizza Hut is good for!!
8. Agostino's Deli & Bakery
Overall Ratings
5 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By bergdorfblond
If you haven't been to Agostino's you are missing out! A family run deli/bakery with imported Italian food items! It's a busy place especially at lunch when everyone is grabbing a specialty sandwich. Nothing beats the Lucy special! A must do while in Tbay!!
7. Mama Alfa's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 55 reviews
Reviewed By Catherine D
Although this place is a little out of the way, it is the best! Family run and excellent value. The staff were very pleasant and helped us with our choices. There was another large family group at the restaurant who were obviously regulars and it was a pleasure to see them interact with the staff. Our veggie pizza took some time to appear but we were treated to an excellent flavour mix, so fresh and amazing mix of freshness. I was on a road trip so will not be back, but I do wish I could be local and be a regular:)
6. Bar Italia
Overall Ratings
4 based on 78 reviews
Reviewed By tjmU4374LJ
A construction worker repairing the street directed me to ask for gnocchi here (it's rare to get it). No gnocchi but a fresh prepared pasta with sausage and rapini (something like broccoli) was well worth the visit, with crunchy Caesar salad as starter. Everyone else eating that evening seemed to know each other -- it's a community / neighborhood place. Well worth it to walk the extra couple blocks from the marina area (pass by the other two mass-market food Italian places). Friendly and attentive wait staff. As photos attest, the outside looks a bit informal -- don't let that keep you away!
5. Giorg Cucina e Barra
Overall Ratings
4 based on 82 reviews
Reviewed By Downeymi
This used to be our favourite restaurant many years ago, when we lived in the area. We were back in Thunder Bay for a visit, so thought we would check it out. It was even better!! The food was delicious and the service was on point!
4. La Casa Nostra Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By EddieA1
Very Welcoming and uniquely decorated restaurant. Very large portions. I had the spaghetti with meatballs. Had half to take home. Wife had small pizza which would easily feed two. Very delicious! Owner came by several times to check on quality of meal and finally to sing a number of songs on his guitar. He is very good. Owner and his friend played the piano on our way out. A lot of fun! Canât imagine a more unique and entertaining evening. Something everyone should try!
3. Caesar's Place
Overall Ratings
4 based on 61 reviews
Reviewed By danielkL8650FF
Ordered the âDeluxeâ medium panzarotti with extra cheese for pick up. The order was ready when stated, the ladies were friendly and courteous. There really wasnât too much filling in the panzarotti besides onions, a few finely diced green peppers and a couple of slices of ham. The cheese was plentiful but I paid extra for it. It was deep fried to perfection and the sauce was good. Just a little disappointed with the lack of fillings for a âDeluxeâ. It wouldnât take a lot of extra veggies to truly make that item really shine. In the meantime Iâll give it an average rating at best. Oh and it added up over $36 for two medium panzarottis for pick up.
2. Nook
Overall Ratings
4 based on 113 reviews
Italian style, family style. Handmade pizza and pasta made with quality ingredients, served in a lively atmosphere. Selection of daily specials.
Reviewed By bergdorfblond
First time to Nook....welcoming not so great....staff just looking around and basically ignoring the front door. We chose to sit outside, it was very busy. Our server was nice....a little reserved for being in the industry. We ordered pasta & pizza. Spaghetti with meatballs...was ok....but the pizza was amazing!!! All in all a pleasant meal...service needs improving!
1. Lot 66 Restaurant and Wine Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 396 reviews
Lot 66 Restaurant and Wine Bar brings the atmosphere of a cosmopolitan lounge to our bar and dining room. We offer an exceptional culinary experience in Thunder Bay, whether you're in for dinner, appetizers, or drinks. Owner and Executive Chef Mike Roulst
Reviewed By Mary L
Had another great evening and dinner at Lot66 this weekend. Friendly atmosphere, food was great as usual, server was very knowledgeable with wines and the menu. Also, was great to end the dinner with fresh coffee and persian cheesecake! Love keeping it local!! Thanks for another great evening and great food!
