Location: Prescott
Top Restaurants in Prescott
Top 10 Italian food in Prescott, Arizona, United States
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in Prescott. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. Nestled in the conifer forests of the Bradshaw Mountains, Prescott is a historic city boasting much in the way of adventure and culture. Golfers flock to its six pristine courses, while outdoors enthusiasts find exciting hiking trails, secluded picnicking spots and adventure on the waters of its five lakes. Discover the history of the Old West in the city's museums, historic railways and the Pioneer Home Cemetery, where "Big Nose Kate" Elder, wife of Doc Holiday, found her final resting place.
Things to do in Prescott
10. Streets of New York
Overall Ratings
4 based on 68 reviews
Reviewed By azfoodie2009
First off, thanks to Amber for being a thoughtful and friendly server. It is much appreciated when someone comes in alone to any restaurant and is treated so well.Next, the breadsticks and nice sized garden salad in it's own cold bowl were great! Not a wilted leaf of lettuce to be found. And not just lettuce in this salad. It had a nice assortment on tomatoes, olives, zucchini pieces, pepperchini, etc. And always appreciate the dressing on the side so as to meter the amount.Now, the "piece d' resistance"...the broasted chicken. It was delicious. And the two pieces that came with the salad were perfect on such a hot day. If you haven't tried the Street's broiled/roasted chicken, you need to. It's not greasy or over breaded. Just perfect.Thanks again Streets for a great solo lunch experience!
9. Limoncello Pizzeria Napoletana
Overall Ratings
4 based on 152 reviews
Authentic Italian Food with fresh pasta homemade and True Pizzeria Neapolitan. Desserts are italian recipe from italian Chef .
Reviewed By gilbertgranny
Great food, very attentive wait staff and customer service above and beyond; those are the 3 things that make a great restaurant. Limoncello fits the bill for all 3. We had pizza. Since they have an oven from Naples the crust was done to perfection and the toppings were scrumptious. We all loved it! To our surprise, when we were done with our meal, I believe it was the owner who brought each of us a glass of Limoncello on the house! A great way to end a meal. We will be eating here again and again.
8. Rosati's Chicago Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 43 reviews
Reviewed By GhiaGirl
We were running errands in Prescott. Our usual go-to for Chicago-style stuffed pizza, Papa's, is closed on Mondays...but by chance our route took us right past Rosati's, new since our last visit to town. Being from Chicago originally, stuffed pizza is a rare treat for us in Northern Arizona.Rosati's stuffed pizza is EXCELLENT. They left it uncut for us so we could reheat once we made it back over the mountain to home. Huge, too. We froze more than half of it.The staff was awesome and helpful with our phone order. Though we carried out the pizza, I could see the dining room was cute and well-appointed. Just around the corner from the Courthouse plaza. Nice job, Rosati's! We shall return!
7. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 149 reviews
Reviewed By Benjamin M
Well have eaten in this particular restaurant a few times but the last two times were horribIe .I thought it may have been an off night .So we tried it again and not so good. I had ordered calimari it was over cooked and hard and they gave me a very small portion. I took pictures could not believe the dish. I had gotten shrimp scampi Fritta it was not even close to Scampi and was not crispy at all very mushy. My wife had gotten cheese ravioli now you would say what could you do to ravioli it was under cooked the edges were very hard .So to end the night it was our anniversary we ordered Sicilian cheese cake it was stale very hard and dry what a disaster .I do know what good Italian food is like I used to own pizzerias in Brooklyn N.Y. and was not looking for the greatest food around but have eaten in many olive gardens in my life and never received food like this .FYI only think you should retrain this place before you loose a lot of business my check #822739 Highway 69 Prescott .AZ 03/18/2019
6. Fresca Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 57 reviews
Hello From Fresca Cafe Our Gelato and Sorbetto is home made with the finest seasoned ingredients.We will always have 18 different flavors to choose from Our Italian meats and cheese are imported. Everything thing we serve is always fresh Thank You Frances
Reviewed By GoesBoom
Wife and I ate here for lunch. The sandwiches were quite good. Friendly staff. Smaller establishment, comfortable seating and fairly quiet. Service was a bit slow.
5. LaBruzza s Italian Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 102 reviews
At LaBruzza's Ristorante, excellence in all areas of our restaurant for the benefit of our customers is our constant goal. We appreciate people's opinions and welcome your feedback in order to better serve you. Having been in business since 1988, our loya
Reviewed By Richard J
Limited days and hours for dinner. Locally owned Italian restaurant. West of downtown, but worth the 15 minute drive. Opens at 5pm and parking lot is usually full and folks waiting to get in. I had to park in front of the dumpster. Variety of Italian dishes, with a half dozen chicken recipes. I had the Ravoli Italian which is about 6 large raviolis with three sauces, green, white and red. Basil pesto, cream and mariana sauces. Comes with all you want salad and bread. No wine or beer, but you can bring your own. Moderate cost.
4. Two Mamas' Gourmet Pizzaria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 117 reviews
Reviewed By Cinderbug
While shopping around the antique store next to Mama's, my husband said "Let's have lunch at this little place." I did not feel like pizza but he saw they had barbeque food and wanted wings. Upon reading the menu, we actually decided to share the Italian Beef sandwich and a chopped salad. The salad was one of the most delicious salads we had ever had. We were over the moon delighted with every single delicious bite. Service was excellent and food was outstanding and the price was even better. We are now big fans. This place is off the beaten path by a couple of blocks. We both thought they could do better business by rebranding. We did not have the pizza so maybe that is what they are known for but the name Two Mama's just didn't seem to fit the place or the food. We both hope this place will be there for a long, long time so we can eat there every time we visit Prescott. We will spread the word!
3. Rosa's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 937 reviews
Reviewed By Buddy P
We were greeted immediately and seated right away on a busy Friday night. Mathew was right there to take our drink order and make suggestions. Menu was wonderful and lots to choose from. Pizza, eggplant parmigiana, Caesar salad and garlic knots. Incredible and Mathew went beyond to take care of us. Great prices and great service what more can you ask for. They treat you like family.
2. Bill's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 618 reviews
Right across from the courthouse and whiskey row. Dine-in or take out. We have Happy hour all day Mondays and Saturday Nights from 8- 10.
Reviewed By Little_PC
Since I have Celiac, I had my own pizza! It was awesome. The rest of my family shared a large special with sausage and pepperoni. Everyone raves about how good it was. They only take cash and debit cards, but itâs worth it.
What to do and see in Prescott, United States: The Best Places and Tips
1. Papa's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1047 reviews
Reviewed By OneTwoThree456
We have been here twice. Both times we were seated at a tiny table, which is OK except that both times nobody cleared away excess dishes. Service was hard to come by. Wait staff disappeared after we were served. Water wasn't refilled. Food was good, but with almost non-existent service both times we probably won't go back. Hello OneTwoThree456,I sent you a private message and haven't heard back from you as of yet. I'm really sorry that your two visits to Papa's lacked the service we're known for. I can see from your post that you visited us almost a year ago and are just reviewing us now? It's hard to determine what happened from last November including who your server(s) were etc.. We aim to please and ask that you consider coming in again. We have recently been voted Best Waitstaff in Prescott, #1 in Dining Excellence as well as Best Italian Restaurant. Your positive comments about our food are most appreciated and we would love the opportunity to cook for you again. Give us another chance.. It would be our pleasure to welcome you back! Sincerely,Andrea at Papa's
Prescott Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Prescott
