Location: Oak Creek
Top Restaurants in Oak Creek
Top 10 Italian food in Oak Creek, Wisconsin, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Oak Creek. Oak Creek is a city in Milwaukee County, Wisconsin, United States. The population was 34,451 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Oak Creek
10. Toppers Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
We deliver to ALL Milwaukee Airport Hotels til 3am! We specialize in tasty handmade pizza. We make all of our dough in the store each day. We also chop all of our vegetables fresh by hand. We even chop our mozzarella ourselves. Fast delivery to the surrou
Reviewed By Nursek40
We got pizza delivered to our room after a long drive from the other side of WI. Our food was hot and fresh! Crust was a bit limp, we ordered hand tossed. The veggies on my pizza were cooked perfectly and the sauce was amazing! Will definitely order from here again when I'm in the area. Delivery driver was clean and friendly.
9. Ricardo's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 115 reviews
Reviewed By John B
We had another excellent dinning experience with friends at Ricardo's in February.The service, menu and atmosphere are always wonderful. It is one of our favorite restaurants in Greendale.
8. Casa Di Giorgio
Overall Ratings
3 based on 146 reviews
Reviewed By John D
Last minute decision to go out to dinner. The restaurant was just 15 minutes away, so we decided to go there. Good decision. My wifeâs eggplant Parmesan was delicious, and the generous portion was enough for 2+ meals. I chose the Sicilian pork tenderloin. Tender and tasty.Our server, Brianne, was cordial and attentive.A very nice evening.
7. Toscana Italian Ristorante
Overall Ratings
3 based on 54 reviews
Reviewed By Dennis D
You always know what you getting here. In the morning they sever breakfast. I've been here in the evening too, and the food is purely Italian. The music is too except for Dean Martin singing 'That's Amore' (at least the song is Italian)
6. Barbiere's Italian Inn South Milwaukee
Overall Ratings
4 based on 56 reviews
Reviewed By Mr_Rick_2016
Great Family Dining - Meat Ball Snacks-Pizza, Great Garlic Bread, Salads, Lasagna- with lots of cheese and much more! Fresh made dough in pizza crusts and Garlic Bread are one of the key ingredients in making Barbiereâs Pizza & Garlic Bread one of the Best in Metro Milwaukee Area. Large bar room and many changing specials plus very good beer selections. Lasagna, meatball snack and pasta dishes are all great! Fresh mozzarella cheese the good stringy kind... a Family favorite!
5. Cellar Pub & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
The Cellar Pub & Grill has been a renowned & sociable Oak Creek icon for many years. The Cellarâs history dates back to the 1860s & was once known as âOakwood Hallâ. Today, The Cellar Pub & Grill is well known for its inviting hospitality, friendly faces,
Reviewed By Marcia R
Having grown up in the area and gone for years, my husband and I decided to see if it was still as good as it was years back. The answer, Yes! We visited on a Saturday afternoon and there was a nice crowd. After checking the menu, I opted for the buffalo grilled chicken wrap with fries. It was delicious, although a little hotter than I expected, but it was very good. The fries had a crispy coating and were equally as good. My husband chose the french dip which he said was tender and flavorful with a generous helping of beef. We noted the fish fry on Fridays and will return to try it!Thanks for your great review Marcia, we are happy to hear you came back and enjoyed your time at the Cellar! We look forward to seeing you back for a fish fry!!
4. Marco's Pizza- Oak Creek
When you get those cravings for hot, cheesy pizza, with your favorite fresh toppings, you'll want to visit us at Marcos Pizza, Oak Creek, WI.
Reviewed By Scoutings
I liked the pizza, but it did have a LOT of seasonings. My husband felt it was overseasoned and, after one slice, didn't want any more. My preschooler who loves pizza was also uninterested. Even my dog, who is part goat (eats anything) wouldn't touch the sausage. I liked the pizza, but felt it wasn't for everyone (obviously). Also, I'm still surprised at the price. I think we paid about $19 for a medium takeout with 2 toppings. This is high in our book...we get much better pizza near home (Jet's Pizza) for half the price.
3. Pizza Man
Overall Ratings
3 based on 52 reviews
Reviewed By Dorothy T
This restaurant is a Milwaukee classic, recently new to the Oak Creek area. This pizza is strictly what you personally prefer, by that I mean. If you grew up earing this, you'd enjoy it. I personally don't find anything special here, and is quite overpriced for what you get. It's a cute, urban type of place, but I prefer good food over atmosphere. Milwaukee in general has many better places to pick from.
2. Vivere Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By Etblaine
There are plenty of good to very good Italian restaurants in the area, so I wasn't looking to add a new place to our rotation of places to visit.the local paper did a review of Vivere, so we gave it a shot and are glad we did.Very generous portions, very attentive service and great prices. i would say 20-25% lower than the competition.We went on a Saturday earlyish (5:30). Place was busy but they had seating available.We split a Lasagna and a Chicken Parm. My wife got Soup and I went with a Salad. Mine was tasty included Cucumbers, tomotoes, red onion and assorted greens.Fresh Bread is served with Olive Oil.Everything was delicious.We got carry out Pizza and Meatball Parm sandwich for our son the next night.Ready on time and this was great as well.It is now in heavy rotation.
1. Trattoria Di Carlo Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 246 reviews
Reviewed By panielsen
This place is now off our list as we have had only one good meal in the five times we've been here. The Cubano Panini was very dry and the bread was more like a grilled bun than a nice crisp panini. It did not have the Dijon mustard on it and pork slices were too thick while the ham was barely there, flavorless. The Italian Beef sandwich too, lacked flavor in all aspects and again very dry dispite having some grilled onions and peppers on it, there was no juice and they forgot to put on the Giardiniera so I had to ask for it, waiter obliged. It is a beautiful place and service has been good. The menu is large, prices comparable to others but the quality is just not there. I'm Italian and have had much better elsewhere.
Where to eat American food in Oak Creek: The Best Restaurants and Bars
