Location: Massapequa Park
Top Restaurants in Massapequa Park
Top 10 Italian food in Massapequa Park, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Massapequa Park, New York, United States. Massapequa Park is a village and hamlet located within the town of Oyster Bay in Nassau County, New York, United States. Areas south and east of the village borders are considered the hamlet of Massapequa Park because they are under the jurisdiction of the Town of Oyster Bay rather than the village. The hamlet shares the same zip code, fire department and school district as the village. The population was 17,008 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Massapequa Park
10. Phil's Pizza II
Overall Ratings
4 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By Suzanne K
We eat here a few times per month. The pizza topping choices are always changing and inspired! The entrees and especially the weekly specials are extremely good. The food is always fresh and plentiful!! The owners, Sal and Tony, are two of the nicest people I've ever met. The dining room is newly redone.
9. Mercato Kitchen & Cocktails
Overall Ratings
4 based on 48 reviews
Reviewed By EdwardC3
We came for my wifeâs birthday. Arrived here at 12. They do take reservations. Food was delicious. Drinks were plentiful. The only problem was our waitress and I think it was just that it was crowded. But honestly no complaints. My first time here and will definitely be coming back.
8. Carmela's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 56 reviews
Reviewed By Measuretwice8
We stopped at Carmellaâs for a couple of slices while killing time in Massapequa. We were not disappointed.We ordered at the counter and ate at one of the outside tables. The white slices were excellent. We were divided on the Neopolitan and Sicilian slices - both were well made but my wife found the sauce slight sweet for her liking. Either way, the crust was excellent. We were especially happy to find that the people at the counter were very pleasant and really make you want to come back. We will do so when in the area again.
7. Leonardos Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By gordon11762
The staff is friendlier than any other Pizzeria that I have ever gone to. Dominic, the owner, is always friendly, courteous and helpful. They make the best Italian food available in our area. The pizzas are cooked to Perfection, the sandwiches are delicious and we still have to look forward to trying the dine-in experience. In the meantime, I can only say that we always look forward to visiting the Leonardo's staff and eating their delicious Italian food.
6. Giovanni's of Massqpequa
Overall Ratings
4 based on 57 reviews
Reviewed By Torres8174
Attended a reunion with about 35 others. The service and attentiveness of the staff was great. We had the veal and chicken it was very good, nice portion. We had a pre-fix menu but everything was great. Giovanni was attentive and ensured everyone was ok.
5. Cara Mia
Overall Ratings
4 based on 85 reviews
Reviewed By Suicu
We visited recently with a party of ten on a weekday for an early supper. We arrived ten minutes earlier than our reservation time and had to wait in the foyer while the waiter set our table. Unusual but no big deal.When they were serving our salads I asked for crushed pepper and was given a pepper shaker! Really. One of our guests asked for the same and the same waiter came over with a pepper grinder and took care of it. Again unusual but now kind of annoying. We then waited a very long time for our entrees. This was strange as it was only a party of 10 and it was before the dinner crowd and on a week night. My young niece was so hungry we asked for them to bring her entree before all of the others, which they did. By now we were very frustrated. A good waiter would have brought over some garlic bread or something else and apologized but not our waiter. After dessert we were all set to leave and our waiter was not available. A co-worker brought us the bill and told us he was on the phone. We were not told who he was speaking with but it must have been very important, maybe his recruiter? When he finally showed up I asked if we could use a promotion I had clipped wherein you get a $15 gift card if you spend over $65. Considering we had spent over $400 I thought it would not be a problem. The waiter said no and showed us the fine print on the promotion which excluded price fixe. While some of our meals were price fixe about half of the bill was not which included wine and appetizers. Sorry, but after the poor service we should have been given two gift cards. Anyway we will not be returning to Cara Mia. There are several good Italian restaurants nearby that value repeat customers.
4. Vittorio's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 136 reviews
Reviewed By DocRKS
Booked a reservation here based on a very strong recommendation from a Long Island friend. I am happy to say he was right on target and our visit here proved to be a wonderful dinner. I love when a restaurant cares about all parts of the meal - starting with the bread basket! Tremendous fresh and tasty artisanal loaf with EVOO and pepper mix. Very strong bar and cocktail libations. Home made Bucatini with Short Rib Ragu ( more meat than sauce!) ending with great desert assortment! Our waiter added to the strength of our visit here. The ONLY Negative is the parking situation here. The lot is far from the front door and those with a hard time walking may find this an unexpected and unpleasant challenge!
3. Phil's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 125 reviews
Reviewed By sukieusa
This is a gem of a little restaurant in a strip mall. It is also a pizza place. The decor is nothing fancy, but the food is fantastic. All are very large portions, enough to take home and have another meal the next day. The wine is a reasonable price too.First trip I had the eggplant parm, excellent and so much food. The second visit I had the grilled salmon. 3 really nice size grilled pieces, cooked just right and so tasty, served with a salad or pasta on a bed of broccoli rabe, also cooked just right.The only critical thing I can say is that there is way too much oil in everything and that is the only reason I didn't give it 5 stars, but of course that makes it taste good.The serve on both visits was good, attentive but not annoying. Will be back!
2. Zona Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 54 reviews
Reviewed By TheSushiGuy
On Christmas Eve, we picked up various items for dinner at our house. There was plenty to eat and it was delicious. Everything is prepared from scratch, that's why it's so good.
1. Bacaro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 127 reviews
Reviewed By Rocketscientist3
The only ding I have is that the meals are very rich and heavy. The risotto sides have a lot of cheese. Service was very good. One thing I noticed was that the acoustics were very good - meaning that other table talk throughout the restaurant was not echoing off the walls & drowning out our conversation. Catered very well to my wifeâs dietary issues.
