Location: East Lyme
Top Restaurants in East Lyme
Top Things to do in East Lyme
Top 10 Italian food in East Lyme, Connecticut, United States
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in East Lyme. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. East Lyme is a town in New London County, Connecticut, United States. The population was 19,159 at the 2010 census. The villages of Niantic and Flanders are located in the town.
Things to do in East Lyme
10. Charlies Place Restaurant & Lounge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 155 reviews
From pastas to seafood to Barbeque ribs brisket pulled pork , Pulled Chicken, Sunday brunch and Happy Hour Menu
Reviewed By skipmays
Just on the western fringes of Niantic, with excellent free parking, is Charlies Place. Our early Wednesday evening dinner was a mix of Italian and American dishes that were well proportioned, tasty and reasonably priced. The dining crowd was on the light side (5:45pm ?) and the service was excellent. We had a 7pm appointment in the village and the waitstaff accommodated that requirement with a smile. We'd be pleased to come back and dine again.
9. Black Point Pizza
Overall Ratings
5 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By jjs2
Weâve heard lots of good things about this relatively new local pizza (and more...) restaurant. Weâve consistently heard âgood food but uneven serviceâ. I must say that clearly the off-season has mitigated the service issues and the food is excellent. And you canât beat the price. My wife and I stopped in on a Tuesday night. The place was about 1/3 full. Katie the waitress was relatively new but very friendly and accommodating. She was honest. When we asked âwhatâs good and popularâ, she explained she was new and hadnât tried everything on the menu yet...we decided to split a Caesar salad and we split an entree, Polo di Mino. The salad was very large and easily satisfied the two of us. The dressing was excellent...tangy and hint of lemon. My only complaint was that the salad could have used a little less dressing. The salad was served with warm homemade rolls. They reminded us of Bertucciâs rolls made with pizza dough. Irresistibly delicious! They are served with those commercial butter packs....a small dipping bowl of olive oil would have been a welcome and nicer alternative...The meal arrived pre split. This is a very nice move that too few kitchens offer. The split portions were plenty adequate...after salad and rolls especially! The chicken dish was very flavorful...chicken cutlets pounded and dredged in seasoned flour, sautéed and finished was a delicate lemon wine sauce with artichoke hearts, mushrooms and a touch of tomato. Excellent flavor, moist and not overly spiced with garlic or onion (a mistake many pseudo Italian restaurants make...). We enjoyed our meal with a couple of very generous glasses of Chilean Pinot. All in all a great meal for two for slightly more than $40. Canât be beat. If I have any complaints itâs the fact that the place needs to take itself more seriously, despite the facility (formerly a gas station and quick mart) and location. Itâs not nouveau gourmet. But with a few touches it could raise its game beyond just a pizza place with good dinners. For example, the TV near the bar was set to âWheel of Fortuneâ. No one was watching it, the sound was on ( annoying) and itâs not separated from the dining room. Either turn the TV off or set it to that burning Yule log with music. Anything but the game show. Also, the waitress was great, but we sat at a table set for 4and the other 2 place settings were never removed. And we had to remind the waitress the turn down the lights. It was way too bright when we entered and the lights ARE on a dimmer. Someone needs to be attending to the little things. It will make a big difference. One last peeve...the picture of the dining room on the website is a generic restaurant...looks so warm and homey. Itâs unfortunately not what you find when you walk in. Again someone needs to focus on the little things. But remember, the food is great and for the price itâs a bargain. We will be back. Appreciate this feedback greatly!
8. Family Pizza Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 66 reviews
Reviewed By Barry S
Family pizza is a gem. Most pizza restaurants do well with the basics: Cheese, meatball, and pepperoni pizzas. Family Pizza delivers high quality pizzas in each of these basic areas. No other pizza restaurant, in my experience, offers the combination of spinach, feta, tomatoes and spices -- called the Athenian Pizza -- that you'll find at Family Pizza. Add to this distinctive array of pies, outstanding, truly family-oriented service.
7. Filomena's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 95 reviews
Filomena's is a restaurant and bar serving regional American food with Italian undertones. We offer a private dining section that holds up to 80 people as well as two private party rooms that host up to 150 guests.
Reviewed By Smily2015
We just enjoyed a wonderful luncheon celebrating an 80th birthday! The food was delicious, especially the appetizer platter. The service was great also. Nice place to book for gathering...
6. Castello Of Niantic
Overall Ratings
4 based on 86 reviews
Reviewed By skipmays
After waiting for a couple of minutes for a hostess, a waitress (or bar tender?) advised we could sit anywhere we pleased. We then waited for several more minutes while the table that came in after us was served. First impressions? It counts! We eventually ordered and found the food to be tasty. We spit a traditional bruschetta app (small toasted pieces of what appeared to be a baguette with a dab of chopped tomatoes and onions and a mix of light colored beans beans. My main course was Lasagna made with Italian sausage and coated with a gallon or so of heavy tomato "gravy". A bit much, but simply a personal preference. My wife ordered the braised short ribs that were served in a soup plate nestled with mashed potatoes and some asparagus shots. Nice option. No time for dessert.
5. Charlies Place Restaurant & Lounge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 155 reviews
From pastas to seafood to Barbeque ribs brisket pulled pork , Pulled Chicken, Sunday brunch and Happy Hour Menu
Reviewed By skipmays
Just on the western fringes of Niantic, with excellent free parking, is Charlies Place. Our early Wednesday evening dinner was a mix of Italian and American dishes that were well proportioned, tasty and reasonably priced. The dining crowd was on the light side (5:45pm ?) and the service was excellent. We had a 7pm appointment in the village and the waitstaff accommodated that requirement with a smile. We'd be pleased to come back and dine again.
4. Illiano's Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 86 reviews
Reviewed By melodyhr
Our stop for lunch at Illianoâs Grill in East Lyme was a delicious surprise. The temperature was 90+ degrees outside, but our salads were crisp, fresh & nicely presented. A couple of slices of meatball pizza were delivered to our table as soon as we sat down as a welcoming appetizer. A smiling waitress brought our orders with a cheerful demeanor and a genuine smile. We both enjoyed our meals and would recommend Illianoâs Grill to other road-weary travelers.
3. Rebeka's Fresh Pasta Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 92 reviews
Reviewed By Helena C
We enjoyed the homemade fresh fried calamari. I don't usually order pasta in restaurants but I tried it here because it was homemade. It was delicious. The texture was perfect. Service was excellent!
2. il Pomod'Oro Restaurant & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
5 based on 177 reviews
Located in East Lyme amidst one of the most picturesque areas of Southern Connecticut and the Mystic region, il PomodâOro Restaurant & Pizzeria beckons Italian food aficionados with an intoxicating selection of dishes sure to tantalize everyoneâs appetite
Reviewed By Robertjcordisco
When people speak about dining out at an Italian Restaurant they rarely experience dining as if they were in Italy. The American influence has changed the Italian restauranteur to cater to the American palate instead of staying true to the Italian culture. Il Pomod'Oro does not waiver in the style that their heritage and customs have been instilled by the owner, Petrit. Their chef, Bruno, has brought his Italian culinary training to America for the first time in Il Pomod'Oro. They don't believe in sacrificing quality, their integrity is paramount to Italian country cuisine. It separates them from any other restaurant in Connecticut. Not one other dining establishment does what they do, the sacrifice is to great. The customer at Il Pomod'Oro is paramount. The staff is sworn to a dining experience like no other, this is the difference. They always make me feel that I am the most important guest in the house. There attention to detail is a benchmark in the industry. Wine Selection, food pairing, cleanliness, from outside to inside they are unrivaled. The menu creativity is what places this restaurant completely apart from a so-called competitor. If your not dining at IL Pomod'Oro once a week or twice a week you are missing the taste of True Italian Cuisine, I mean organic, farm fresh quality that is never compromised, never. Take a drive to East Lyme, settle in to the Italian way of life that one experiences in Europe. Bellissimo Il Pomod'Oro, Bellissimo!
1. Ballo Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 559 reviews
Inspired by San Galgano in the hills of Tuscany, BALLO Italian Restaurant brings to life all the majesty of an Italian cathedral coupled with exceptional service and a fresh, authentic menu of Italian favorites. To start, guests will enjoy an extensive by
Reviewed By Tracy B
When visiting the area we always stop into this restaurant for the great food and atmosphere! We love the decor and the staff is wonderful. My son has the table side Mac and cheese. The preparation table side is worth the trip! It tastes out of this world!! There is nothing bad on the menu, itâs all delicious!
